President of non-profit organisation Transient Workers Count Too (TWC2) Deborah Desloge Fordyce proposed that any Key Performance Index (KPI) requirements instituted for domestic workers should be matched with adequate rights and protections.
In a letter published on Straits Times (Match KPIs for maids with rights, protections, 20 September), Ms Fordyce was responding to a previous letter by a Mr Lawrence Loh (Maids should have KPIs too, 17 September) who suggested that foreign domestic workers (FDW) should have KPIs to ensure better performance and manage expectations of both the domestic worker and their employers.
Mr Loh has said that even the lowliest workers in Singapore have a set KPI, noting that “in working life, a worker who falls short of his KPIs is subjected to reprimand, counselling, forgone bonus, promotion freeze, and even dismissal.”
He posited that FDWs cannot be treated differently and that this system should be “emphasised during the settling-in programme” before they are placed with a family in Singapore.
In her response, Ms Fordyce pointed out that domestic workers are in fact treated differently. One example she gave was that they are isolated in their place of employment in a way that no local workers are.
But she added that TWC2 are in favour of domestic workers having obligations and entitlements comparable to those of other workers. She added, “Any requirement that they should have Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) to fulfil should be matched by an assertion of rights and protections that are enjoyed by other workers, including a cap on working hours, weekly days off, freedom of communication, an ability to leave an employers’ premises during time off, and a real possibility of leaving an employer whom they feel does not treat them properly – rights that, as Mr Loh states, “even the most lowly” of local workers have.”
Ms Fordyce then suggested that those could be viewed as KPIs for employers and Singapore as a society.
In his letter, Mr Loh brought up the issue of misrepresentation, specifically that FDWs are encouraged by agents to lie on their biodata about their skills which then leads to false expectations and disappointment on the part of the employers.
Ms Fordyce responded, “TWC2 believes that it is wrong for recruiters and unscrupulous agents to encourage would-be domestic workers to misrepresent their experience and training,” adding that it honesty would be encouraged by policies and practices that empower domestic workers to speak up.
Ms Fordyce explained that sometimes deceptive behaviour is a defence mechanism when the domestic workers is in fear of being scolded or physically abused, or that her services will be terminated and she would be sent home destitute as a result of recruitment fees.
The key here is to create an environment where domestic work is more highly valued, whether it is done by locals or migrant workers, said Ms Fordyce, explaining that we should treat domestic workers to the same sort of standards we would wish for ourselves if we were in their position.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Singaporean abolitionist groups call for halt to execution scheduled for 21 April

We Believe in Second Chances and the Singapore Anti-Death Penalty Campaign has…

港示威者闯入立法会 林郑月娥凌晨四时开记者会

香港一批示威者昨晚近九时成功破坏立法会大楼闸门,闯入大堂。 原本香港警方在闸门另一头驻守,与示威者对峙。不过在示威者闯入前却突然撤走。而后警方在脸书发布短片,谴责示威者占据和破坏立法会,发出警告。并表示将到现场进行清场,如遇阻碍或抵抗,将采取适当武力。 昨日是香港回归中国22周年,在昨早香港政府举办22周年主权移交纪念升旗仪式,而反对《逃犯条例》修法的示威者,则发起“七一游行”,也齐聚升旗场地外游行抗议。 期间有示威者和警方再次爆发冲突。而其中一批示威者,则在下午约1时许试图冲击立法会,即便有议员在现场劝阻也不听。 没有警方驻守下,在昨晚9时成功打开闸门的示威者进入立法会会议厅,有者在墙上涂鸦,并写上“太阳花”、“释放义士”、“反送中”、“真普选”等字眼,甚至涂鸦会议厅香港区徽和历任立法会主席肖像。 在视频中可见有示威者试图把香港殖民时代旗帜覆盖在港特区区徽之上。 游行人士对占领立法会意见两极化 据了解,也有和平游行人士不认同示威者占领立法会,认为此举反而让建制派有借口谴责“反送中”抗争,让警方有借口把事件定义为“暴动”。 至于占领立法会后的示威者此后则讨论是否继续留守,最终决定在警方返回清场前撤离。原本有数位“义士”坚持留下,不过最终被示威者们劝离,因为担心“以后再见不到他们”。 https://youtu.be/6p84g3_EFqI 警方凌晨12时清场 警方在凌晨12是开始在立法会附近道路驱散示威者和投放催泪弹。不过当警方重新返回立法会时,现场只留下记者和议员,示威者们早已全数离开。…

Calls to Stop the Execution of Yong Vui Kong

~ By Kumaran Pillai ~ TOC has received more than 100 emails since…

Singapore prime minister diagnosed with prostate cancer

Prime Minister Office has released a statement on Sunday that Prime Minister…