Singapore national record holder, Soh Rui Yong. (Image from Run Society. Photo credit: Romaine Soh)

Meritocracy remains a key principle for recognising individuals in Singapore despite weakening faith in the ideology, says Minister of Education Ong Ye Kung, stressing that although meritocracy is ‘under siege’, it has yet to fail.
In recent years, the idea of meritocracy and its effectiveness has been debated due to its association with elitism, adding to the discussions around the social divide in Singapore society.
Speaking at the Raffles Institution’s (RI) 196th Founder’s Day ceremony on 27 July, Mr Ong defended the concept, saying “Even those who rail against meritocracy struggle to come up with a better system.”
He also noted that this doesn’t mean the system cannot be improve, noting that it isn’t just on the government but everyone in Singapore to “overcome the limitations of meritocracy and consciously fight against the ossification of social classes.”
In his speech, the minister also pointed out that the definition of merit should be broadened beyond just academic achievement.

Meritocracy only when it suits them

Now, the recent news of long-distance runner and two time SEA champion Soh Rui Yong being excluded from representing his country in this year’s SEA Games in the Philippines seems contradictory to Mr Ong’s insistence that meritocracy remains a key principle.
Mr Soh’s record speaks for itself, being the national record holder for 10,000m, half-marathon, and marathon events while also being the first Singaporeans to win two back-to-back gold medals in the SEA Game marathon.
But despite his capacity to bring home the gold, Mr Song was denied a chance to represent Singapore apparently due to his prior conflicts with the Singapore National Olympic Council (SNOC).
In a statement, the SNOC said they denied Mr Soh’s nomination to represent Singapore in the 2019 SEA Games as “there have been numerous instances where Soh has displayed conduct that falls short of the standards of attitude and behaviour that the SNOC expects of and holds its athletes to, considering that they are held up and seen as representatives of the country and as examples to our sporting youth.”
These conflict include a warning by SNOC to Mr Soh for a breach of regulations relation to the promotion of personal sponsors on social media as well as another incident in which Mr Soh’s actions of cutting holds into his race vest before the 2017 SEA Games led to a loss of sponsor.
This year, Mr Soh was served a legal letter of demand by the SNOC to retract his accounts of what happened at the 2015 SEA Games marathon in which he had recounted how his fellow Singaporean runner Ashley Liew didn’t slow down after a route-related error left the leading group trailing behind. Mr Soh’s accounts contradicted SNOC’s view of the incident. In fact, SNOC had nominated Liew for an international award for the act of sportsmanship during that marathon.
However, even with those disagreements, doesn’t the SNOC’s decision run contrary to Mr Ong’s case for meritocracy and how it should work? Or is Singapore’s current brand of meritocracy merely for those to conform to the authority and agree to toe the line rather than for those who are capable and have a mind of their own?

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

More residents come forward to reveal foreigners have used their residence address without permission when registering with MOM

On 25 April (Thursday), TOC published a story about a netizen named…

民主党:政府恰恰错过关键时机 让新加坡进行必要改革

上月18日,副总理兼财政部长宣布2020财政预算案,对此新加坡民主党主席淡马亚(Paul Tambyah),曾点评今年财案“充满小调整,却缺乏大胆举措”。 本周三,民主党再举办网络论坛直播。该党认为政府看似过于专注“微调而复杂的计划”,却恰恰错过了一个关键的时机,让新加坡进行必要的改革,以减低工薪阶层与中产阶级的财政负担。 民主党连同财政主管林文兴、主席淡马亚、江伟贤以及Alfred Tan回应2020 财政预算案,并针对几项关键措施与问题提出建议与看法。 首先针对增加消费税一事,林文兴表示,鉴于新加坡的中产阶级与工薪阶层正受困于日益高昂的生活成本,政府应将调涨消费税(GST)的计划取消,而不仅仅是推迟。 林文兴:应取消调涨消费税 因为这大大影响了工薪一族的财务管理、工作效能甚至是退休前景,而且新加坡的外汇储备已相当膨胀,为何仍需要提高消费税? 他指出,“自2016至2018年,我们所累计的财政盈余(budget surplus)已高达191亿美元,即使将扣除赤字109亿美元,我们仍有82亿元的余额。” 林文兴亦提及,曾任副总理的尚曼达于2015年大选前的声明,表示应取消医疗等基本必需品的消费税,提高奢侈品的消费税。…

PA says the officer who submitted dubious receipts for reimbursement claims has quit last year

It was earlier reported that the Auditor-General Office (AGO) has questioned the…

【冠状病毒19】樟宜监狱迄今共三名囚犯与一名护士确诊

截至本周五(29日),樟宜监狱有三名新入狱的囚犯,以及一名在该监狱工作的护士,确诊冠状病毒19。 新加坡监狱局在今日(30日)发表声明称,四名患者相互间无关联,也未出现进一步传染现象。 三名新入狱囚犯在经检测确诊后已被隔离。其中两人经已出院,另一人也在康复中。至于有关确诊护士也已康复并返回工作岗位。 监狱局强调他们对囚犯和工作人员都有采取防疫措施,例如新入狱的囚犯都要隔离14天等。每位囚犯也会获得一片可重复使用口罩。 昨日我国再有1337名确诊病患出院,此外新增九起社区病例,包括三名本地公民和永久居民,其中包括一名在樟宜综合医院工作的物理治疗师。