Last Sat (22 Jun), ST Forum reader Isaac Neo Yi Chong wrote that even as Singapore’s economy has been consistently growing, the rise in income inequality has been accompanied by “middle-class incomes stagnating, and even real wage declines for the lower class”.

He also noted that inter-generational income elasticity (the disparity between incomes among generations) is heavily correlated with social mobility, with countries that have lower inter-generational income elasticity, such as Denmark and Norway, having higher social mobility rates.

“If income levels remain stagnant, social mobility increasingly depends on the income level that one starts with, and if income inequality worsens over time, this affects the next generation’s chances of social mobility,” he said.

And even though the education system is one way by which lower-income families can achieve social mobility, “higher-income families can invest heavily in their children by enrolling them in enrichment classes to give them a head start”, he added.

“This is a privilege that lower-income families cannot afford, and if their incomes stagnate, the result is that children from more affluent families will have greater access to educational opportunities.”

Mr Neo asserted that there is a need to recognise that a “rising tide does not lift all boats and to dispel the notion that a growing pie means bigger slices for all”.

He said, “Inequality, even as it might lead to overall growth, does have pernicious effects on access to opportunities for the poor.”

“Hence, we should always strive to ensure that efforts to reduce inequality are aimed at ensuring greater social mobility and a more egalitarian society,” he concluded.

Govt refutes Mr Neo’s assertion

Today (26 Jun), Sandra Lim, Deputy Director (Income and Expenditure Division) from the Department of Statistics, and Ang Boon Heng, Director (Manpower Research and Statistics Department) of Ministry of Manpower, jointly wrote to ST Forum to refute Mr Neo’s assertion.

“Forum contributor Isaac Neo Yi Chong was mistaken in asserting middle-class incomes had stagnated in Singapore and that the real wages of the lower income had declined,” they wrote.

“Income growth in Singapore has been broad-based for several years, including the last decade.”

Writing on behalf of the govt, they said that real incomes in the bottom 20 per cent of resident employed households grew by 3.1 per cent per annum on average over the last 10 years (2008 to 2018), on a per household member basis.

For households in the middle quintile, income growth per member was 3 per cent per annum on average, they added.

“In both cases, incomes grew a little faster than the income growth of the top 20 per cent (2.5 per cent per annum),” they claimed.

They further showed statistics to say that real median incomes from work of full-time employed residents grew by 2.7 per cent per annum over the last 10 years and real income growth for the 20th percentile was 2.9 per cent per annum over the same period.

“The data on these trends is published regularly,” they said.

They also proclaimed that Singapore has achieved broad-based income growth to date while economic growth has not necessarily translated into income growth for the lower-and middle-income groups in other advanced economies.

“The Government in implementing polices to support a competitive economy and in designing effective programmes to help citizens; employers in transforming jobs and investing in their people; unions supporting workers in upgrading their skills; and individuals and families themselves,” they wrote.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

一女子惊觉受骗报案曝光 留英才子拟出国潜逃

敢做不敢当,涉嫌偷拍最少11名女性的本地留英大学生,在上周获得法院批准继续出国深造后,被指想要出国潜逃。 面对19项侮辱女性尊严以及一项拥有猥亵视频控状的22岁被告,昨日(14日)被控方在庭上揭露,前者曾经私讯友人,有计划到外国时寻求庇护,因此要求法庭撤销批准被告出国留学的决定。 据悉,原本案件中的受害者一共有11名女性,但是在案件新闻曝光后,一名与被告相识了六年的女子向警方报案,表示自己也是被偷拍的受害者之一,更将被告有意潜逃的手机短信内容交给警察。 女子不知自己也成受害者 控方指出,该名女子原本并不知道自己是受害者,一直到她看到自己成为被告偷拍的猥亵视频“主角”后,才惊觉自己被骗了。 女子透露,在不知晓自己就是受害者时,曾于去年10月接获被告的手机短信,指被告向她仔细分析了利弊后,有意到国外寻求庇护。 受害者要求公布被告身份 除此之外,控方也要求法庭解除隐瞒身份禁令,因为案件中的10名受害者一致认为,被告不该受到禁令保护,应该公开身份。其余的两名受害者中,其中一人仅有16岁,需要征询家人意见后才决定,另一人则所有保留。 针对公布被告身份议案,被告代表律师持反对票,他认为案件受害人和被告熟识,一旦公布被告身份,受害者身份也可能曝光。 法官表示,基于接获新的证据,针对是否允许被告继续到英国深造,以及是否接触隐瞒身份禁令,都将会在明日(16日)开审宣判。

Police alerts public on unsolicited calls claiming to be from government

Singapore Police Force (SPF) alerts members of the public who receive unsolicited…

Video of big group of South Asians arriving at Changi Airport is misleading, says Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore

On Thursday (6 May), The Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore (CAAS) has…

India-Singapore air travel bubble ‘under negotiation’, says India High Commissioner

India and Singapore are currently in negotiation to open an air travel…