Ng Teng Fong General Hospital (Image by ZDL / Shutterstock.com)

A member of the public raised her concern over the lack of air-conditioning in subsidised wards in a letter published by the Straits Times on 3 June.

The letter written by Lily Ong noted that patients in Class C wards are left to the mercy of the sweltering heat that is blanketing Singapore as those wards are not air-conditioned.

Noting that many of the patients in Class C wards are elderly, the author suggested that such wards be equipped with air-conditioning unit, arguing that it is a basic necessity in a country as hot and humid as Singapore and in the wake of global warming.

Ms Ong also raised concerns of health complications that would result from patients lying next to open windows in the hospital considering that the Singapore Institute of International Affairs has projected the return of severe haze in Singapore this year.

MOH reply: Going green and keep costs low

In a reply which was published by ST (8 June), the Ministry of Health Director of Infrastructure Planning & Policy Division Low Chian Siong said that ‘patients who prefer air-conditioned accommodation may opt for A or B1 ward types’.

Mr Low elaborated that public hospitals in Singapore provide “safe, affordable and effective care to patients” and in order “to keep subsidised wards affordable for patients, they are designed to cater to essential patient needs.”

Mr Low also highlighted that improvements have been made to the design and infrastructure in subsidised wards of newer public hospitals, noting that these hospitals meet the Building Construction Authority’s Green Mark Platinum certification which “requires naturally ventilated spaces, including subsidised wards, to meet thermal comfort requirement such as air temperature, air movement and humidity.”

As for older hospitals, mitigating measures have been taken such as spot cooling to bring down ambient temperature, he says.

Addressing concerns on the impending haze, Mr Low said that all public hospitals will take additional measures when necessary.

Is denying air-conditioning to subsidised wards a form of classicism?

The thing is, hospitals in Singapore boast beautiful design elements from articulated facades (Sengkang General Hospital) to lush rooftop gardens filled with verdant greenery (Singapore General Hospital). Clearly, no expense was spared in creating a beautiful, well-equipped healthcare infrastructure.

But imagine just for a moment how much it would cost to maintain those gardens? How much would it have cost to create a beautiful outer façade and include balconies in rooms? And yet, there seems ot be a need to skimp on additional cost of installing and running air-conditioning for Class C wards?

Chance are the cost for landscaping and maintenance for Jurong Hospital, for example, would be more than the cost required to air-condition Class C wards. We’re talking about hospitals here. Comfort should be prioritised over aesthetics.

The reply from MOH on the lack of air-conditioning clearly noted that the reason subsidised wards don’t get air-conditioning was due to budget concerns and wanting to keep costs low. If that’s the case, they should be consistent.

On top of that, given that Singapore is already capable of generating much more electricity that it needs, thus lowering costs, it really wouldn’t burden hospitals much at all to provide air-conditioning to all wards.

Even so, let’s say MOH is motivated by the goal of being environmentally friendly and wanting to meet the mark for the Building Construction Authority’s Green Mark Platinum certification. If that’s the case, then shouldn’t they scrap air-conditioning from all wards completely and not just Class C?

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

部长高薪论 令开国元勋后代感羞辱

已故建国元勋E W巴克(Edmund William Barker)的女儿,吉莲巴克,忆起父亲过去接受了比原本薪资还低的薪水,但是并没有抱怨,反之鞠躬尽瘁,为国家未来奠下扎实基础。 针对荣誉国务资政提及部长薪资过低,招来的可能都是非常庸俗之才。吉莲的丈夫汉奥利对此在脸书留言,称其妻子吉莲忆述,父亲在巴克1963年入阁,还接受了70-80巴仙的减薪,即便如此对服务人民也无怨无悔。 “要求财,应离开政界” “他(EW巴克)率领委员会起草新加坡宪法,并且撰写马新分家法律文书,在不同时期统领五个部门,也是全球任职最久的律法部长,从政期间做出了许多贡献,包括组屋计划、推动体育项目、填土工程和解决武吉知马水患等。 对于酬劳低只能吸引庸俗之人的说法,令我妻子感到冒犯。形同羞辱建国元勋。他们即使领着低酬劳,“前人种树,后人乘凉”,他们的付出为国家未来成就奠下扎实基础。 如果他们想为高薪找理由,那么有更好的良才可选择,才不至于显得羞辱选民智慧。但是公共服务的理念呢?如果你只为财,那么就到外面赚钱去,政府应该是为服务人民的。” 有着欧亚裔血统的EW 巴克,是国人熟知的“平民部长”,在1963年当选新加坡立法议会东陵区议员,在政界服务了25年。 另一方面,新加坡时评网站Wake…

文莱首名冠毒确诊患者 曾赴吉隆坡万人集会、砂美里一日游

邻国马来西亚的武汉冠状病毒(COVID-19)确诊病例,在昨日激增20起,累计确诊149例,治愈出院病例26例。 文莱也出现首名冠毒确诊患者,曾于2月底到马国首都吉隆坡参与一场穆斯林集会,随后在砂拉越的美里趴趴走数天后才返回文莱,迫使该国卫生部下令各州属展开调查追踪。 文莱当局出现确诊病例后,于3月1日下令全国停课,并发出文告,要求国民不要踏足砂拉越。 马国卫生部总监诺希山昨日发出文告,表示已经收到文莱按国际卫生条例所发出的通知,文莱一确诊病患曾于参与2月27日至3月3日,假吉隆坡大城堡回教堂举行的多人集会,且在回程时也曾到临近文莱的美里市,带着一家大小逛街。 他指出,有关的穆斯林集会获得世界多个国家的民众参与,马国的参与者预计有5000人,还有来自泰国和印度尼西亚的参与者。 根据《星报》指出,这名参与集会的53岁穆斯林患者,但是和三名友人于2月27日乘搭飞机到吉隆坡后,于3月3日乘搭亚航AK5651班级返回文莱,随后于3月6日带着家人到美里游玩一天,并在甘榜特拉邦回教堂(Kampong Sungai Teraban Mosque)进行周五祈祷后才返回文莱。 他于3月8日开始出现症状,3月9日确诊,而昨日文莱当局也发出文告,指患者的五名家属,包括一名61岁的年长者和30岁的儿子、46岁的妻子和两名分别只有12和5岁的儿子也已经确实感染冠毒了。 当局也指出,该国当时有约90人参与穆斯林集会,因此发出文告,要求国民非必要的话,不要出国,以保护自己国人和他人。 马国卫生总监因此敦促相关当局采取追踪行动,并吁请出席者给予配合,避免出现社区感染情况。…

“Ask Paul Anything” where Professor Paul Tambyah answers your questions on COVID-19

In a candid “Ask Paul Anything” session livestreamed on his Facebook page,…

插入导管刺破静动脉 74岁肾病患者死于意外

进行导管插入手术时,74岁肾病患者静脉和动脉意外被刺破,导致急性内出血而亡,这也是我国首次发生类似死亡事故。 据验尸庭指出,患有肾脏衰竭的74岁Lee Kuen Ngian于2016年11月10日,在陈笃生医院接受腹膜透析治疗(peritoneal dialysis),及把一种特殊的无菌液体灌入腹部内,再引出血液中的杂质。 死者之前已接受过检查,被评估为适合长期接受有关的治疗。 在当天进行手术时,肾内科负责医生See Yong Pey将导管插入腹部后并未见任何异常,但是在引入空气到死者腹腔时,却见死者忽然倒下,导管也被移出。 死者的脉搏曾在抢救时恢复,但是之后就出现两次“无脉搏性呼吸”,最终抢救不治。 据法医Chan Shijia指出,死者是因为在导管插入过程中,静动脉被刺破了,引发急性内出血,而高血压和肾病也有影响到病情。…