ST Electronics and ST Marine come under the ST Engineering group of companies.

The Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) has just awarded a tender to local electronics firm ST Engineering (Training & Simulation Systems) Pte Ltd to supervise and manage the construction of boats for the Police Coast Guard (PCG) over the period of up to 50 months, or just over 4 years.

The contract of S$1.46 million was awarded to ST Electronics for providing marine engineering services in overseeing the construction and outfitting of these boats locally and overseas, in either China, Taiwan or Latvia.

Screenshot of GeBiz document showing award of MHA tender to ST Electronics.

According to the contract, the boats would be built in phases overseas and once completed, would be shipped to Singapore for the installation of specialised equipment. After that, the boats will undergo tests and trials until the commission for the boats. ST Electronics would be responsible in overseeing and managing all the phases from construction abroad and testing locally.

Screenshot of GeBiz document showing G-Master’s (left) & ST Electronic’s bids on the MHA tender.

According to the government’s procurement website GeBiz, two companies bid on the tender – ST Electronics, the electronics arm of ST Engineering of which the majority shareholder is Temasek Holdings; and G-Master Marine Services Pte Ltd which provides management consultancy services in the marine sector. ST Electronics offered a lower bid at S$1.46 million to G-Master’s S$3 million. Ultimately, ST Engineering won the bid.

Now, while the award of the contract to ST Electronics seems fine, if you recall our series of articles from February/March this year, this particular shipbuilding project for the police coast guard was awarded to a company called ST Marine, which is another company under the ST Engineering group.

The newest contract requires ST Electronics to oversee the construction and outfitting of these new boats for the PCG, to ensure that the construction, outfitting, and testing of the boats by ST Marine proceeds as planned.

Common sense dictates that awarding a separate contract for the overseeing and management of a construction project is a way to ensure quality and efficiency of said construction.

However, when the role of overseer is awarded to a company under the same umbrella as the company that is doing the construction, one has to question the neutrality of the supervisor should any mistake or flaw crop up in the process which would indubitably damage the reputation of its sister company.

TOC has written to MHA for comments on this apparent conflict of interest.

Screenshot of GeBiz document showing tender posted by MHA in September 2018.

Another point of curiosity is the date the tender was awarded. The tender was first posted by MHA on GeBiz in September 2018 for the duration of 180 days or about 6 months. The contract start date was supposed to be March 2019. However, the tender was only awarded to ST Electronics in May 2019. Presumably, they project won’t start immediately after the tender is awarded. So this means the schedule for the project has been push backed by at least 2 months.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

金融局查办42金融机构 罚款高达1680万新元

2017年7月1日至2018年12月31日期间,共有42家金融机构,因涉及滥用市场、金融操守不当和洗钱等违规行为,结果被新加坡金融管理局(MAS)惩处,开出总值1680万新元的罚单。 根据金管局于星期三(3月20日)发布的第一份执法报告,该局还对两宗内幕交易案件和一宗未经授权交易案件,罚款总值69万8000新元。 一人因刑事定罪入狱 金管局的调查,也让投资者莫毕亮,在去年1月因造假交易而被判入狱四个月。 2014年,莫毕亮在13个交易日于即将闭市时,进场购买维利顿资源(Wilton Resources)的股票,导致维利顿资源的闭市价,受到 “人为” 推高,制造假象。 2016年5月至2017年的12个月期间,在金管局调查一马公司丑闻调查结果下,有八家银行被惩处共3千万元罚款。 报告由执法部门编制 有关的报告是由金融局执法部门编制,随后将在每18个月发布一次报告。 有关执法部门是于2016年8月成立。除了金融制裁和刑事定罪之外,该报告也指出,已经向金融专业人士发出19项禁令,禁止他们重返金融业,进行了37次谴责和223项警告。所有案件处理至结案时间平均需时8个月。…

Collection of NRIC numbers and photocopying of identity cards to be made illegal starting 1 Sep next year

Amendments made by the Personal Data Protection Commission (PDPC) to rules regarding…

失信滥用客户款项 三人接金管局禁令

利用职业行诈骗之事和不诚实行为,两名前银行职员和一名前保险从业员遭新加坡金融管理局(MAS)严禁从事资本市场行业或保险业,长达10至20年之久。 金管局昨日发出有关文告指出,接到禁令的三人分别为前银行职员邓玮玲(译音,Emeline Tang Wei Leng)、前银行职员阮唯明(译音,Nguyen Duy Minh),以及前保险从业员许展龙(译音,Koh Zhan Loong John)。有关的禁令于4月5日起生效。 前汇丰银行(HSBC)职员的邓伟玲以代为存款入定期户口为由,骗取五名客户超过500万元,并提供了伪造文件给这五人,让他们以为有关现款已经汇入户口了。因此他被控滥用超过500万元以及不诚实行为,被金管局禁止20年不可从事资本现场的行业。 阮唯明原为大华银行(UOB)的职员,因为售卖假的金融产品给八名客户,甚至在没通知客户的情况下伪造文件,以他们的名义购买其他的金融产品,并且滥用客户的钱,导致八人蒙受50万元亏损。…