(Photo: Imofo/Shutterstock.com)

It was earlier reported that a CPF member, who would be turning 65 in May this year, recently received a mail from the CPF Board.

It informed him that he would be eligible to receive $250 per month for about the next 8 years when he hit 65. It also told him that should he want to get his payouts starting at 65, he must inform the CPF Board. Otherwise, CPF Board would only start disbursing his payouts at age 70.

Regardless, his payouts would only be $250 per month for about 8 years. This means the amount of money left in his CPF account is very little, calculated to be less than $30,000.

It’s not known why he has so little in his CPF account. Perhaps he started working a few years in his earlier years before becoming a self-employed rich “towkay”, since a self-employed person does not need to contribute to his CPF. Or perhaps he was just an unlucky odd-job laborer, going from job to job his whole life.

Whatever the case is, there exists a large group of elderly Singaporeans with little CPF savings in their account.

Almost half don’t meet Minimum Sum

Last year, in response to a question asked in Parliament, Manpower Minister Josephine Teo revealed that for the cohort who reached 55 in 2016, only 53% of active CPF members “met their Full Retirement Sum in cash and pledge at age 55 in 2016 (i.e., able to set aside the Full Retirement Sum fully in cash, or met Basic Retirement Sum in cash and provided sufficient property pledge or charge)”.

That is to say, 47% or close to half of the 2016 cohort did not meet the Full Retirement Sum (i.e, the Minimum Sum under the old terminology). And even for those who met, a substantial portion of them had to pledge their property, which means in terms of cash, it is half of the Minimum Sum.

The Minimum Sum for the 2016 cohort is $161,000. But since 47% did not meet FRS or BRS plus property pledge, that means the cash they have in their CPF accounts is less than $80,500. Hence, we can safely conclude that for the cohort who reached 55 at 2016, almost half had less than $80,500 cash in their CPF account.

Some may argued that since CPF contributions are tied to pay and pay is tied to ability, perhaps these Singaporeans who have little in their CPF only have themselves to blame since they are not capable enough to earn more.

This myth, however, has been busted by former Associate Dean of LKY School of Public Policy (LKYSPP) Donald Low (he resigned from LKYSPP last year).

Former Associate Dean: If Sweden allows 3rd world immigrants to work, wages of Swedish bus drivers will immediately be depressed

Dr Low once wrote an article to debunk this myth. Dr Low noted that incomes of middle- and low-wage Singaporeans have been growing very slowly in the last decade.

“There is some evidence to suggest that Singapore’s workers in the service industries are less productive than their counterparts in other rich countries. Cleaners, bus drivers and construction workers are probably more productive in Sweden than they are in Singapore,” he wrote.

“But the question still remains: why has inequality increased at a time when quality education in Singapore has become widely available? The democratisation of education suggests that differentials in productivity should have narrowed, which in turn suggests that wage differentials should also have been reduced.”

“Why should lower-wage Singaporean worker, who has benefitted from the state education system, be less well-paid than his Swedish or Swiss counterpart doing a similar job? Is it possible that something else other than individual productivity determines our wages?” he asked.

Dr Low opined that one important determinant of market wages in rich countries is immigration. Low-skilled workers in many European countries earn more because of their tight immigration controls.

“If these countries were to import large numbers of low-skilled workers from poor countries, it is hardly conceivable that their low-skilled workers can earn the wages they do now, their relatively higher productivity levels notwithstanding,” he said.

“A Swedish bus driver for instance earns 50 times his Indian counterpart. If Sweden were to allow Indians and other immigrants from poor countries to enter its labour market, simple economics tells us that the wages of bus drivers in Sweden will be immediately depressed.”

Therefore, in the case of Singapore where immigration policy is much liberal, Dr Low attributed the low wages which our low-skilled workers are getting to high intake of low-skilled foreign workers.

“Too rapid an inflow leads not only to more competition for jobs and reduced wages, but also stretches the country’s physical and social infrastructures,” he added.

So, with the high intake of foreign workers into Singapore, it’s no wonder the incomes of many middle- and low-wage Singaporeans are depressed, resulting in having little savings in their CPF to retire.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

研究显示调高公积金缴交率益处多 网民斥恐加剧年长雇员觅职困境

本地主流媒体《联合早报》报导,一项研究指若55岁至64岁员工的公积金缴交率保持和年轻人一样,那10年间就能累积超过14万元,能提高年长者工作意愿,他们的公积金入息甚至足于缴交房贷。 但是网民们对此的反应似乎一面倒,表示难以接受,因为提高公积金缴交率不仅减少了现有的可动用资金,甚至会让年长雇员更难觅得工作,因为雇主的公积金缴交率也提高了。 这项由新加坡政策研究所演技研究员进行的模拟推算发现,若是将55岁至64岁员工的公积金保持和55岁之前一样,他们的退休储蓄可在10年内累积超过14万元,退休后的每月入息也会因此增加超过一倍。 这项由该研究所高级研究员余国安和副研究员黄锐洲展开的研究,假设一名员工在55岁后的公积金缴交率保持和年轻员工一样,那么在从55岁到64岁之间,其普通和特别户头储蓄能够在这10年间累积多少。 终身入息可增加150巴仙 有关的研究以人力部公开的数据,估算了55岁到59岁员工的大概月薪金额后进行推算,发现最低和最高的第10个百分位的员工,能够累积到3万1056元至14万5117元。研究人员推算发现员工在10年内,累积的储蓄能增加三倍,月薪处于第20个百分位的员工,储蓄从2万5610元增加到6万6524元;处于中位数的员工的储蓄从5万1557元增加到13万3923元。 如果将这些额外储蓄纳入公积金终身入息计划(CPF LIFE)中,月薪处于第20个百分位的员工在65岁起,每月能领的入息将从166元增加到414元,增幅约150巴仙;月薪处于中位数的员工每月入息,也将从326元增至777元,增幅为140巴仙。 他们也发现若只是把缴交率提高一个百分比,处于第20个百分位的员工也能够在10年期间多存约5000元,每个月的公积金终身入息能多领33元。 一次性调高或需累进元素 本地年长员工的公积金缴交率曾于1988年、1993年和1999年,在面对金融危机时进行下调,确保他们在经济萧条时段能够保住工作。缴交率虽然在之后有所恢复,但是55岁之后的缴交率仍然不如年轻员工。 目前55岁以下员工的公积金缴交率为月薪的37巴仙,雇主17巴仙及雇员20巴仙;55岁到60属于的缴交率为26巴仙,雇主和雇员各13巴仙;60岁到65岁为16.5巴仙,雇主9巴仙和雇员7.5巴仙;以及65岁及以上的缴交率为12.5巴仙,雇主7.5巴仙而雇员5巴仙。…

COVID-19 infections surge in Nepal fueled by double mutant strain from India

Reuters reported yesterday (26 Apr) that COVID-19 cases have surged rapidly in…

【武汉冠状病毒】钻石公主号五名狮城人获准下船 返新后仍需隔离

历经两周的隔离后,在钻石公主号上的五名新加坡人终于获准下船,但外交部表示,五人如果在下船后的14天内回到新加坡,仍须再隔离一段时间。 日前,停靠在日本横滨的钻石公主号,因出现武汉冠状病毒确诊病例,导致船上乘客必须接受隔离,待在船上14天。 经14天的隔离后,乘客陆续下船,而船上也有五名本国人,如今也被获准下船。 外交部发言人表示,“该五名新加坡人若在下船后14天内返新,将需接受目前公共卫生协议所采取的额外防护措施,再进行隔离。” 发言人补充,他们建议在这段期间密切注意自己的身体健康。 钻石公主号于本月初出现确诊病例,船上3千700名乘客及船员将被隔离检疫10至14天,621多名乘客也被检测出感染。 其中两名日本籍80多岁男女,在船上感染后住院接受治疗,惟昨日宣告死亡,成为“钻石公主号”首起确诊死亡病例,令日本在检疫安排面临越来越多批评。 男性年长病患此前就有支气管哮喘和心绞痛的病史,至于女病患则没有已知病况。两人确诊感染后于本月11日和12日下船,并被送往医院治疗。

Potential 3-cornered fight at West Coast GRC with PAP, PSP and RP

The Reform Party (RP) unveiled its first batch of candidates yesterday (15…