Yesterday we ran a story on how an elderly man was only covered S$4.50 for his post-subsidy bill of S$4,477 by MediShield Life.

Responding to this issue, former NTUC Income CEO Tan Kin Lian shared on his Facebook page on how the national insurer’s system is rather confusing and messy, and offered a solution to curb this problem.

In his post, he said that the problem is that medical expenses are too high and the government places caps on the use of MediSave, in an attempt to prevent too much money being siphoned out. Therefore, this results in the patients having to fork out a large sum of money out of their pocket.

In the case of the senior citizen, Tan explains, “This is a complicated arrangement. I call it the ‘bits and pieces’ payment system – some part paid here, some paid there. No wonder the people are confused with this system.”

According to him, the government thinks that it is important to make patients responsible in order to control medical expenses. However, in reality, most patients are very confused that they fail to play a part to “control” the expenses.

“The only control that they have is to choose the medical facility to go to. After that, they have to face the charges and add-ons for various kinds of treatment.”

As such, Tan’s solution to this problem is for the government to take responsibility and set the charges for various types of treatment, if MediSave and MediShieled Life are to be used.

He added, “The public hospitals and clinics, which also have access to the subsidy, should also be expected to take the lead to provide services based on these approved rates. These rates will still yield profit for the restricted hospitals, but not the big margins that they enjoy now.”

The approved rates by the government should also be an all-in for the treatment, and hospitals should absorb any variation in the treatment.

By coming up with proper rates, many private hospitals will probably join the scheme as they should be able to gain profit.

In addition to that, he says deductible under MediShield Life is too high and should be reduced to S$500 or lower.

“All the caps on MediSave should be removed. After all, the patient is going to an approved hospital for an approved treatment.”

Although he doesn’t claim that this method will solve all the problems, but he is “sure that it will be a better basis to deal with the problem than the current confusing and messy system.”

Many netizens also agree that the system is confusing and a bunch of them feel that healthcare has become a commercial entity for moneymaking.

 

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

连氏基金长期护理研究(2)– 终身护保索赔条件严苛 学者:依级别赔付扩大安全网

连氏基金会和国立大学社会科学研究所两位助理教授何琳贻和黄瑞莲,针对我国长期护理前景进行研究。 除了昨日《海峡时报》所报导,强调更多年长者选择居家或中心式看护服务,且成本高昂,显示有必要提升现有社会保障机制。有关研究报告也针对现有医疗保健政策提供建议,特别呼吁应改善终身护保计划(CareShield Life)的受保赔付条件,让保户获得较广泛的保障。 报告列举出一些新的看护政策或计划逐步涌现,例如整合式居家和日顾计划(IHDC),让那些无法离开住家的年长者,中心能暂时派看护人员到家服务,至于那些在家护理者,则被鼓励在行动便利下能转移到中心接受看护。 至于“活跃乐龄中心”也在新的公共组屋区提供整合式乐龄看护服务,例如日顾、复健和代送日用品等。 “近年来,私人领域填补了乐龄看护领域的空洞,特别是针对想获得更多元和专属服务的中产和中上阶级。自愿福利组织也开始与私人业者合作。” 该研究发现,缔造获颁关系是实现规模经济和专业化的有效手段,同时也能落实提供全方位和持续性服务的目标。研究也认为,社会与家庭发展部把社会关怀任务,转交给卫生声部,使得看护领域获得更集中的规划和精简化,有望使该领域受惠。 研究报告欢迎政府推出终身护保计划,在应对长期护理成本日益攀升,提供民众保障。然而研究也点出其问题,包括终身健保符合赔付的条件严苛、相对较低的保赔和妇女需支付出更高保费。 去年仅6.6巴仙长者严重伤残 保户需符合严重伤残资格,即日常起居至少三项无法自理,才能领取每月600新元的赔付。然而,报告指出在2017年,只有6.6巴仙长者—约3万4千人面临严重伤残情况。这意味着,有大部分人都在符合申请赔付的范围外。 Elaine Ho指出,许多新加坡人的长期护理可能面对保障不足。在2017年,有三分之一年龄介于40至84岁人士,仍未购买基础乐龄健保(ElderShield)。…

Dr Koh Poh Koon's social media fiasco: Picture of him carrying "32kg" worth of newspapers

Earlier last week, MP for Ang Mo Kio GRC Koh Poh Koon…

唐振辉:反假新闻法案料明年上半年呈国会

律政暨卫生高级政务部长唐振辉透露,打击网络假消息的法案有望在明年上半年提呈国会。 在接受《亚洲新闻台》的访谈上,表示相关法案预料最早在明年上半年提交国会,以立法作为打击假新闻的手段之一。 唐振辉也是研究蓄意散播网络假消息特选委员会的成员。他在访谈中指出“假消息对民主制度的影响更为广泛,除了选举也对日常生活造成影响。” 他表示,政府将研究立法的必要性,以期打击那些在选举期间散播假消息的举动。 对于滥用“假新闻法”钳制言论自由的担忧,唐振辉则强调“良好、有效和有力的公共辩论不能相提并论。” 他补充,如果在公共辩论中混入假消息、或者由网络智能机器人、假账号来放大吹嘘假消息,结果就会变成泛泛空谈,绝不是有效的公共讨论。 然而,根据本社的观察,不论在中英文社交媒体,却有更多的假账号似乎采取亲行动党的立场,在公共议题的辩论上,捍卫政府政策。 我国总理在今年11月,指出明年举行选举“一切都有可能”;11月23日,人民行动党公布中央执行委员会完整名单,财政部长王瑞杰任第一助理秘书长,贸工部长陈振声任第二助理秘书长,加紧交棒第四代领导人的步伐。 马国选前匆匆通过假新闻法 今年509第十四届全国大选前,马国前朝政府于四月匆匆通过了2018年假新闻法。马国默迪卡民调研究中心形容,这是国阵政府在选前的“临时抱佛脚”,却无阻国阵60年政权倒台的命运。 新政府上任后,即废除《假新闻法》,声称现有法律已足够应对假消息传播的问题,例如1998年通讯与多媒体法等。 在今年8月16日的国会辩论中,首相署部长哈尼法在回应国阵议员阿莎丽娜的提问时,哈尼法指出,警察和其他相关执法机构理应扮演更重要角色,来应对假消息散播的问题。…