Senior Minister of State for Law Edwin Tong. Source: CNA

Senior Minister of State for Law Edwin Tong has hinted at the tabling of a Bill aimed at curbing the spread of deliberate online falsehoods in the coming months after numerous consultations and debates among legislators and members of the public surrounding the potential anti-“fake news” laws.

Mr Tong’s revelation came not long after Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong had mentioned the possibility of bringing forward the next General Election, which might indicate that Singaporeans will soon be heading to the ballot boxes as early as next year.

In an interview with Channel NewsAsia, Mr Tong, a member of the Select Committee on Deliberate Online Falsehoods, stated that the impact of falsehoods on democratic institutions and processes is “more general” and “impacts daily life much more than just elections alone”.

“If you have provisions that deal with how you tackle falsehoods … [and] stem its proliferation, that would in many ways go towards the same objectives as well during elections,” he said, adding that the Government will study the necessity of implementing laws in the process of combating falsehoods during the election period.

He added that the issue of “fake news” should firstly be dealt with in a “general nature” before deciding “whether there needs to be any special rules for elections subsequently”.

Addressing concerns surrounding the potential abuse of “fake news” laws via the stifling of dissenting voices, Mr Tong stressed that “good, effective and strong public discourse is not the same as saying (anything a person wants).”

“When you have public discourse riddled with false information, or bots which amplify the false information, or fake accounts that … overblow a situation … That’s not effective public discourse, that is discussing something on false premises.”

However, TOC observes that majority, if not all, fake accounts on Singapore’s internet landscape seems to adopt a pro-People’s Action Party stance or to defend the government’s policy against public criticism.

Malaysia’s Anti-Fake News Act was part of Barisan Nasional’s “last-minute own goals” prior to GE14: Merdeka Centre

Previously across the Causeway, the tabling and subsequent enactment of the Anti-Fake News Act 2018 on 2 Apr and 11 Apr respectively were among the measures dubbed by Malaysian opinion research firm Merdeka Centre as Barisan Nasional (BN)’s “last-minute own goals” in the period leading up to the 14th General Election (GE14) that took place on 9 May, which witnessed BN’s downfall after six decades of rule.

The Act has since been repealed by the new Pakatan Harapan government, as there are “existing laws” to deal with the problem of fake news, said Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Mohamed Hanipa Maidin.

In his winding-up speech, he told legislators in Dewan Rakyat – the lower house in Parliament – on 16 Aug: “We don’t need new legislation. We already have existing laws, such as the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998 and others that can deal with this issue.”

Speaking in response to BN’s Azalina Othman Said – former Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department who played a significant role in passing the Anti-Fake News Act under the Najib Razak-led government previously – Mohamed Hanipa added that the police and other law enforcement authorities should play a greater role in combating the spread of fake news.

“During Barisan Nasional’s time, the police were used to protect them [BN politicians].

“They were not used to fight crime,” he charged, adding that “with the Pakatan Harapan government, the police will be used to fight crime, and not to cover us [instead]”.

However, in what appears to be the first rejection of a Bill by Dewan Negara – the upper house of the Malaysian Parliament – the Senate had voted against the repeal of the Anti-Fake News Act on 12 Sep, which would result in a retabling of the Bill with amendments.

Malay Mail reported that Opposition Senators, primarily from BN, voted against the repeal of the Act, as they believe that “the law prohibiting misinformation could be improved”.

Senator Khairul Azwan Harun from United Malays National Organisation (UMNO) said: “I understand that this is a very unpopular law, but we must also recognise that we live in world of fast information. Just this week the PM was a target of fake news.

“Grand old institutions, such as that of the US democracy, have had their elections compromised precisely because of targeted misinformation.

“The threat is real and I fear our political landscape is too young to be further polarised because of fake news,” warned Khairul.

Malay Mail also highlighted that out of 68 Senators in the Dewan Negara, 52 had taken part in the bloc voting process.

Dewan Negara Speaker SA Vigneswaran told the Malay Mail that 28 Senators rejected the repeal of the Bill, 21 were in support of the repeal, and only three senators abstained from voting.

Laws targeting “fake news” susceptible to potential abuse such as suppressing legitimate online dissent and to “deflect attention from important policy debates” pre- and post-election

Research Fellow at the Centre of Excellence for National Security (CENS) at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS) Gulizar Haciyakupoglu, in her analysis of Malaysia’s Anti-Fake News Act and its potential impact on Malaysia’s GE14, argued that while it is “unlikely that any investigations into “fake news” allegations made in the lead up to the election will receive sentencing before polling day,” campaigns made by opposition candidates and parties “may be exhausted by court cases filed against them under this Act”.

In her analysis, published on The Diplomat on 26 Apr, just less than two weeks before GE14, Dr Gulizar also highlighted that “Some opposition candidates may feel threatened by the penalties specified in the Act”, adding that if the penalties succeed in instilling fear in the opposition candidates, “such scenarios might impede the opposition’s efforts to popularize their arguments, reach wide audiences, and garner sufficient support”.

“Moreover, the “fake news” label may be further exploited to discredit opponents in the campaigning period, rendering it not only a defamatory weapon but also a tool to deflect attention from important policy debates,” she warned.

Dr Gulizar also raised the potential abuse of laws targeting “fake news”, which can manifest itself in the suppression of online dissent “by labeling unfavorable comments on contentious topics, such as the scandal surrounding sovereign wealth fund 1MDB, as “fake.”

“This risk is of particular importance during both the campaigning period and for post-election discussions, as the tight control over traditional media has rendered the internet the most viable avenue for critical voices to promulgate narratives alternative to the Malaysian government’s,” she stressed.

However, Dr Gulizar added that should “fence-sitters perceive the ruling Barisan Nasional (BN) to be exploiting the Act for political gain and to silence dissent”, it may compel “undecided voters” to “cast their ballots against BN candidates” as the “legitimacy of the ruling coalition” comes into question.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Chee Hong Tat: “Zero tolerance” for abuse of public transport workers

The Senior Minister of State for Public Transport, Chee Hong Tat, mentioned…

罗拔申码头周末人群聚集 网民质问“双标准吗?”

有网民发现,周末下午的罗拔申码头处聚集多人,甚至有人不戴口罩、或近距离交流喝酒,不禁令网民问道,“这是政府的双标准吗?”。 网民Lectress Pat周末(5月16日)在脸书上分享了数张,据称是来自其友人,傍晚6时25分在罗拔申码头拍下的照片。 照片中只见不少人聚集在罗拔申码头一带,有的是一家大小在广场或走道上聊天或跑步,有些人并没运动,却也没戴口罩,甚至没有和他人保持安全社交距离。其中一张照片中,更见到三个人在一家酒吧外喝酒聊天,且都没有用口罩遮盖口鼻。 网友表示,友人当时打算尝试新的运动路线,却没想到会看到这惊人的一幕。 她指出,在亚历山大公园连道有两名执法人员和一名警员驻守,但是在五分钟路程外的罗拔申码头却没有执法人员驻守。更甚的是,该区的餐饮业者也没有劝阻在该处饮酒聊天的人们,也没有把摆放在外的站立式桌子收起。 她表示,这些照片不禁让人们质疑,执法当局对于本地的组屋居民等市民都密切监督,并采取快速的对付行动,却能让这些俗称“拥有自主权”地区的居民不戴口罩和聚集,“这不是双重标准吗?”。 她也批评这些不遵守阻断措施的任性行为,是毁掉本地社区和前线人员所做出的防疫努力。 Lectress Pat的帖文很快引起网民们的关注,议论纷纷。一名餐饮业者在脸书上澄清,指照片中显示的站立式桌子并非该店所有,也强调遵守阻断措施的重要性。 市区重建局发言人则告知媒体,当该局执法人员在相关地区进行巡逻时,发现除了有些餐厅向顾客出售外带酒精饮料之外,并没有发现有很多业者或人们不遵守安全距离措施。 基于出售外带酒精饮料会导致更多人聚集在相关商店周围,为了避免人们聚集,当局已经向业者发出书面指示,即日起禁止出售相关饮料,否则将遭到严厉对付。…

雇主未能准备住宿 有马国客工被迫留宿地铁站

马来西亚18日起发布行动限制令,限制国民出境,这导致大批马来西亚籍客工为了工作连夜过长堤,我国也承诺会善待这群为工作奔忙的员工,然而却有人发现不少人在越过关卡后,无处可去,留宿地铁站的地板上。 据《今日报》报导,有约20名客工被迫于周四(19日)凌晨1时,在克兰芝地铁站的地板上,铺了纸皮就地露宿。 早前,当局指我国政府在短短数小时内,为超过1万名马国客工配对临时住宿。 “雇主还在安排地点” 一名因雇主无法及时提供住宿的仓库管理员,阿米尔(31岁,Armel Sharil译音)受访时表示,他只有约四小时的睡眠时间,必须在凌晨5时地铁站站开放时起身。育有两名孩子的他表示,其雇主还在为他寻找住处。 克兰芝地铁站往日的晚上10时左右都会呈现拥挤现象,通勤者会在此等待前往马国新山的跨境巴士服务,然而现在非常冷清,没有任何活动。 阿米尔和其他人在冷硬的地板上躺下准备休息,有者撑开雨伞用于遮挡,有者将行李、外套或帽子充作枕头,呼呼大睡了。 基于未能及时在锁国前带上行李,阿米尔身在只带着钱包、没网络服务的电话、便捷式充电器、小罐装的发胶以及刚刚购买的漱口水。 马国于18日开始实施锁国措施,以遏止武汉冠状病毒(Covid-19)疫情的传播,迄今马国已经有两宗死亡病例了。 成千上万在本地工作的马国客工纷纷在16日晚上开始涌入我国,长堤上的车龙甚至持续到17日晚上。因为害怕交通拥堵,有不少客工决定拖家带口、大包小包地走路越过长堤。 为了应对有关措施所带来的大量马劳涌入,人力部长杨莉明曾表示会和三方合作伙伴联手,为受影响的员工寻找合适的住处,甚至为他们提供每日50元的住宿补贴,以控制人流。然而在事情过了一天,仍然可见有马国员工在地铁站过夜。…

CAN: Special safe guards needed for criminal cases involving minors

Singapore based NGO, Community Action Network (CAN) has issued a statement to voice its…