Photo: The Telegraph / ALAMY

The recent heated debates on social enterprises and how the concept is eroding the quality and authenticity of hawker centres – the latter deemed to be an iconic part of Singapore’s culture – has revealed the attitudes of operators of such social enterprises and possibly even the Government towards hawkers.

In a letter submission to TODAY, a reader pointed out that “the abilities of the hawkers and stallholders seem to have been obfuscated, treated as if they are completely devoid of any intelligence.”

Lee Siew Peng argued that far from the current perception being painted by such discussions, “stallholders and hawkers might have been illiterate, but they were able to organise themselves when needs arose in their community,” citing her father’s experience as a “jhee yoke loh” (literally, Cantonese for “pork man”, or pork seller) at the Alexandra Road market.

She illustrated her point further when she revealed that her father, as a hawker, “was able to convert mentally the traditional measurements they were using, such as “kati” and “tahil”, into metric units” decades ago “when Singapore adopted the metric system of measurement in the 1970s.”

Dr Lee wrote: “They knew exactly how long to trade to maximise profits. They ensured good value, service and quality because they knew customers voted every day — not once in five years like our General Election — with their feet and wallets. “Quality control” by some office-bound executive was unnecessary.”

“They were fully capable of organising themselves to resolve pressing issues such as dish collection and dishwashing.

Dr Lee also said that the burden to meet Government objectives regarding hawker centres should not rest upon hawkers “who have spent a lifetime teaching their children not to take after their profession (because it was seen as not socially mobile),” but on the Government itself “to fund the training of a new generation of “hawkerpreneurs” by stepping up its efforts.

“Two things they [the hawkers] could not do were to maintain the fabric of the buildings (and its environs) and attract younger hawkers. The former is the responsibility of the landlord.”

She proposed that the Government ought to “adjust the rental charges” in order to attract a new generation of hawkers, and to ramp up its “marketing” and “education” efforts regarding hawker centres, adding that “it’s not rocket science.”

Dr Lee also lambasted the apparent unfairness of the social enterprise model against hawkers, citing an article on TODAY in which it was stated that “under the social enterprise model used by the National Environment Agency (NEA), operating surpluses are to be shared among its stakeholders “such as the stallholders, the manager and the NEA”.

She argued: “Why should NEA profit further from the blood, sweat and tears of the hawkers that they have left in the hands of private businessmen?”

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

When saying “traditional, conservative society” doesn’t cut it anymore

By Joel Tan The spotlight is once again on the fight for…

Minister Ng says Trump welcomes Singapore buying 4 F-35s costing more than half a billion dollars

In the budget debate in Parliament today (1 Mar), Defence Minister Ng…

承认为中国套取情报 狮城男子公然亲中?

上月24日,美国司法部宣称,一名新加坡男子姚俊威,承认自2015年至2019年期间,以顾问公司为掩护,替中国向美政府及军方人员套取情报。 此次事件也引起中美再次口水战,中国外交部发言人也指责美方执法部门“不断炒作中国渗透”,更反指美国在全球都有搞间谍活动。 据《海峡时报》报导,姚俊威过去10年,也曾积极在诸如《外交家》( The Diplomat)杂志和以中国为主的部落格等发表评论,或是在社交媒体Quora发表看法,有时甚至是和其他网民打笔战。 在一些评论中,他更毫不遮掩对中国的仰慕,在回应一些与中国历史有关的贴文,也坦率表达自己的亲中立场;若有网民表达对中国的偏见,他也总会表现极大的不耐烦回应。 在一则贴文,他强调新加坡不能远离东盟和亚洲,“当华盛顿(美国政府)对自己在全球的地位愈发困惑,意味着我们比任何时候,需要更多地参与和拥抱中国的经济崛起。” 姚俊威也是立化中学和国家初级学院毕业生,他对现代化中国“感到骄傲”,更赞扬中国“活力四射、热情、尽管有时急躁却非常努力。” 此外,姚俊威也强调自己出身卑微,父母没受过正式教育,8岁那年与有钱亲戚到快餐店用餐,但经历“感到屈辱”的待遇,当时有钱阿姨到柜台帮他支付,不过妈妈坚持不肯,认为身为华人,不应让孩子看到自己比他人穷,为此妈妈买了最基本的乳酪汉堡;姚俊威也指自己迄今不吃乳酪汉堡,那是亚洲的时髦品。 目前,姚俊威将面对10年监禁,并将在10月9日判刑。他在2015年,到新加坡国立大学李光耀公共政策学院就读博士学位。2019年申请缺席假。但在被逮捕和遭美国司法部指控后,上述学院也终止姚的博士生资格。 李光耀公共政策学院院长曾强调,该案只涉及杨俊伟个人意愿,据目前所知,并没有牵涉其他师生。 而网上迄今还存在的一篇报导,姚俊威以“新加坡国立大学李光耀公共政策学院博士”的名号,赞许中国的“新四大发明”(共享经济、无现金支付等),能为包括新加坡等东盟国家的年轻一代带来影响“:…

民主党徐顺全吁青年珍惜生命,重视心理健康

民主党秘书长徐顺全希望青年若面临心理困扰,一定要寻求协助,珍惜生命! 近日,一项有关自杀率的调查报告显示,去年我国20至29岁的青年的自杀人数占71人,引发关注。对此,徐顺全13日在脸书上发文表示对该年龄层自杀问题的关注。 针对上述调查,他也感同身受,因为自己的小孩正处于该年龄段,因此无法想象自己在失去家人后的痛苦。 “更重要的是,这些正在面临心理困扰的青年们更是令人心碎,生命弥足珍贵,不应该如此了结,尤其是当这世上一切仍有令人兴奋的事情正在对你招手。” 他也承认如今可能较为脆弱的青年所经历的绝望感是相当真实,无法言喻,甚至离不开药物的支持。 因此他也给出建议,劝导青年可以深入寻求更为光明和有希望的日子。 “我知道正念说比做更容易,但很幸运的是,这并非不可能。” “或许在寻求光明时,你才开始了解你是谁,并且逐渐为此感到骄傲。此外,父母也在其中扮演重要的角色。” 徐顺全在文末也提供电邮𝗯𝗯@𝘆𝗼𝘂𝗿𝘀𝗱𝗽.𝗼𝗿𝗴给正在黑暗漩涡内的青年,若正处于迷惘的青年,无处哭诉也可透过电邮告知。 “我不知道我能付出多少,但至少我可以聆听你的苦楚。你比你所知道的更值得拥有。” 此外,他也提供 新加坡援人协会(Samaritans…