The People Association (PA) and one of its Grassroots Organizations (GRO) have been questioned by the Auditor-General Office (AGO) in its report released yesterday (17 Jul) over 2 tenders whose contract value totaled $500,000 for the Mid-Autumn Festival 2016 and Chinese New Year 2017 events.

AGO found that the GRO responsible for calling the 2 tenders had used the same foreign contractor for the manufacturing of the street light-up decorative items. In fact, the same foreign contractor had been awarded contracts for the annual Mid-Autumn Festival and CNY events since 2014.

AGO observed that the GRO was bias and had not evaluated the proposals from the other tenderers on the same basis. “Besides the issue of fairness, there was also no assurance that the contract was awarded to the tenderer which could provide the best value,” AGO noted.

Furthermore, the foreign contractor who was awarded the contract was from overseas and it required the GRO to bear additional obligations which included accommodation cost for its workers during their stay in Singapore, transportation charges for materials and provision of a site for assembling lanterns.

“These additional costs, on top of the tender price, were not considered by the GRO in its tender evaluation for price comparison. There was also no mention of these additional obligations in the tender evaluation report and tender recommendation report for the tender approving authority to make an informed decision,” AGO said.

The other question, of course, is whether these workers who came from overseas to assemble the lanterns for the events had the right permits to work here, even if they were supposed to be working temporarily for the projects.

GRO accepts tender proposal from sole foreign tenderer after tender closed

In the case of CNY 2017 event, the same foreign contractor was the sole bidder and had also stated in its proposal additional items which the GRO had to bear under the contract. Again, the additional costs were not mentioned in the tender evaluation report and tender recommendation report.

For the CNY 2017 tender, AGO noted that the GRO had accepted the tender proposal of this sole foreign tenderer after the tender was closed.

“The GRO had also allowed the tenderer to submit two revised tender proposals mainly to revise the quantity and lighting effects on the lanterns and consequently, the bid price after the tender had closed,” AGO said.

“Accepting late submission of tender proposal and allowing the tenderer to amend its tender proposals and bid price after the tender had closed went against the principles of open and fair competition, and transparency. Such lapses could lead to allegations of unfair practice.”

To further complicate matters, AGO observed that the contracts signed with the foreign tenderer were not based on the laws of Singapore but those of the tenderer’s country. So, any unresolved disputes would be filed for litigation in the courts of the tenderer’s country, even though the work is done in Singapore and for Singapore.

“Such provisions in the contracts might not safeguard the interest of PA and its GRO,” AGO said.

AGO did not mention the name of the GRO nor the name of the foreign contractor.

PA explained that the contracts were prepared by the foreign tenderer and the GRO did not seek the advice of PA’s legal department before signing the contracts. Moving forward, the GRO would prepare the contract, PA said.

PA also informed AGO that the procurement lapses were largely attributed to the procuring team having inadequate understanding of Government procurement guidelines and operating under time constraints. PA said it would take measures to improve staff understanding and compliance with Government procurement requirements as well as ensure proper contract management documentation.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

苏丹清真寺开放让街友入住,成首个提供临时居所的清真寺

苏丹清真寺与社会与家庭发展部合作,开放让街友入住,成为新加坡首个让街友可借宿的清真寺。 上周本社报道,国立大学法学院的调查发现,目前狮城流落街头者仍有约千人,大部分均为50岁以上在职的人,已露宿长达六年或更久,他们基于各种理由如家庭冲突、与租客相处不佳或不想给亲人带来不便等,才会开始流浪。 对此,社会与家庭发展部表示,在协助街友的过程中,有者担心与拒绝当局或志愿者的援助;而苏丹清真寺,将清真寺成为临时庇护所,提供无家可归的街友住所。 苏丹清真寺则继教堂、寺庙以及慈善机构等,成为首间提供住所给街友的本地清真寺。 目前清真寺开放的时间是由晚间10点至早上7点,将清真寺内的其中一个大厅布置为庇护所。据清真寺说,该大厅是清真寺内的多功能大厅的附属建筑屋下的一个地下室,与其他主要厅室和祈祷大厅都有一定的距离,而且街友们只能透过侧入口进入清真寺,因此向信徒保证,不会干扰到清真寺的信徒。 “苏丹清真寺除了是重要的礼拜场所,也有责任协助这群弱势群体”,苏丹清真寺社会发展部执行官员贾玛鲁定(译音,Muhammad Aizuddin Jamaludin)向新传媒透露。 目前,庇护所仅提供男性住所,不分任何种族与宗教。清真寺代表表示,今后将可能会扩大协助范围。 尽管清真寺为街友提供临时住所,但清真寺表示街友仅能在清真寺提供几个晚上的住所,并无法长居,但这些街友在接受住宿的当下,便将会有其他相关民间机构或政府机构介入,协助他们找到常住居所。 今年6月,耶稣君王堂(the Church…

Safety procedures not followed in fatal accident: SMRT

Updates by SMRT state that safety procedures were not followed in the…

【选举】IHH收购印度医疗机构受阻 惟前总裁陈诗龙荣休今年参选

人民行动党上周在线上介绍了27名新面孔,其中一人是55岁的IHH医疗保健集团管理层的前总裁兼董事经理,陈诗龙医生。令人感到疑惑的是,在他离职时,IHH正面对收购印度医疗机构富通的交易纠纷,而他似乎没选择留下来提供协助。 陈诗龙于2014年1月至2019年12月在IHH任职。然而在他去年合约结束,选择退休。 IHH医疗保健集团在我国、马来西亚、中国、土耳其和印度都有业务,也是我国和马来西亚的上市公司。其旗下的百汇班台(Parkway Pantai Ltd)更是集团的御宝,在亚洲拥有医院网络,包括我国的伊丽莎白医院、伊丽莎白诺维娜医院、鹰阁医院和百汇东岸医院。 行动党委派陈诗龙医生出战马林百列集选区,直接对垒工人党。 IHH在印度收购富通受阻 IHH医疗保健公司在2018年7月,成功赢得收购印度第二大医院经营机构-富通保健股权的竞标战,并于同年11月通过优先配股购买31.1巴仙股权,还打算随后收购额外的26巴仙股权。但是日本制药公司第一三共株式会社(Daiichi Sankyo)和富通保健的创办人辛格兄弟对簿公堂,因此印度最高法院下令IHH暂缓收购交易。辛格兄弟当时也接受印度当局的欺诈调查。 在2019年11月15日,印度法院裁定富通保健前持有人,辛格兄弟和富通藐视法庭罪名成立,也表示或对当时已经由IHH掌控的富通公司展开藐视法庭审讯。这是因为法院指IHH和富通的部分交易,被视为违反了2018年12月的庭令。 法院当时曾对双方部分交易展开调查,甚至调查富通董事会和管理层的详情,发现相关交易都是非常仓促和秘密在进行,进而违反了2018年所发出的庭令。 印度当局下令调查富通…

误判大马海啸影响乃“愚蠢失误” 行动党还能再战30年?

悦榕集团执行主席何光平指出,因为马国变天,就得出新加坡人民“和大马人一样厌倦政府”,以为行动党政府也会步国阵后尘的结论,乃是“愚蠢的失误”。 何光平认为,虽然新马两国有一些相似的情境,例如人民行动党和国阵一样都是自独立以来就执政至今,但不代表前者会和国阵一样遭受相同命运。 如果因大马变天,就以为行动党的倒台迫在眉睫,说明大家还没吸取真正的教训。 “国阵败北并不是因为缺乏民主机制、人权议题、打压异议或威权式政治,而是纳吉政府下的庞大贪腐问题。 华侨银行于本月12日主办“毁坏时代中的新加坡政治与企业”论坛,何光平在致词中认为,新马两国最大差别在于,大马前朝政府领导涉及过于明目张胆的贪腐,导致国阵倒台。 希盟在509胜选后一周,敦马曾对《经济时报》评述,大马变天可能冲击新加坡证据,因为新国人民和大马人一样,已经厌倦同样的政府执政。 认为2、30年后才变天 何光平估计,至少2、30年后,人民行动党可能会走下执政舞台。他分析,当前,新加坡仍由第二代领导人主导,他们仍谨守建国总理李光耀的治国理念。 历史上,后独立建国政党的初衷理念和诚信至少能维持三代,之后才因为狂妄和腐败,开始陷入困境。 他反驳西方的观点,指民主改革的诉求不会导致行动党倒台,反而是领导涉及重大贪腐。对于亚洲政治文化,良好施政更被重视。 他认为,亚洲国家一般对于无能有很高的容忍度,但不会原谅中饱私囊的自私政权。新加坡容不下贪腐,行动党也不得放任和滋养裙带关系、避免精英圈子任人唯亲,从军中、朋友圈和公务体系提拔自己的亲信。 何光平:需警惕裙带文化滋生…