Speaking at an OCBC Forum entitled Singapore Politics and Business in an Age of Disruption (12 Jul), Executive Chairman of Banyan Tree Ho Kwon Ping said that the Singapore government is aware of the “jibes made against us and our political system” by the Malaysians. However, this “may not be applicable in totality”.

He was a referring to an earlier comment made by Malaysian PM Mahathir bin Mohamad in May to the financial times that Singaporeans – like their Northern neighbours – “must be tired of their government”.

“[We are] drawing the wrong lessons if we look at Malaysia and think that the fall of the PAP is imminent for whatever reasons that are happening across the Causeway.” Ho said

He added that there is “a high degree of tolerance within Asian countries for even incompetence. But there is very little intolerance for totally selfish regimes which only perpetuate their own well-being.”

This marks a huge and critical difference” between both countries and Singapore did not follow the “egregiously blatant” corruption ways of the Najib administration.

Additionally, Singapore is still helmed largely by its second generation of leaders who “clearly remember and largely perpetuate” the principles of former Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew.

The PAP could possibly lose power over the next 20 years if it cannot rejuvenate

Nonetheless, Mr. Ho also acknowledged the possibility that the PAP might lose power in the next 20 to 30 years.

He noted that political parties historically maintain their passion and integrity of their founders for about 3 generations before “hubris sets in and the rot begins”. There “must be an inflow of totally fresh new blood into the political system if we are to avoid” a fall of the PAP.

While Ho believes that the PAP does not tolerate corruption, this could change if they allow nepotism and cronyism to set in. The PAP also must be careful not to create “quasi cronyism amongst cliques of elites” as it draws people from immediate circles of friends, the military or administrative service.

Other factors include complacency, applying the “same old formulas” to solve future problems, and the lack of internal competition within the party could also be detrimental to the PAP.

Academics: PAP’s leaders are elitist and are completely out of touch with the ground

If Ho’s analysis is to be believed, then the picture painted by several academics may hint at PAP’s fall.

In an article for Asia Nikkei earlier this week (10 Jul), former Political Science Professor Bridget Welsh at the Singapore Management University said that the problem with 4G leaders is that they are “a highly elitist party, largely unable to relate to ordinary Singaporeans”.

This is because the “intertwining of the PAP and the bureaucratic state has created singular agendas and resulted in a distancing from the electorate and its needs”. Many of these 4G leaders “emerge from within the party, government, [and] the military” and “they are seen to be for the system”.

This was concurred by Professor James Chin from the University of Tasmania. In an article in May for the highly respected Australian Financial Review, he said the PAP elite “graduate from the best-known universities [and] hold the most prestigious scholarships. They are totally removed from the hard lives of ordinary Singaporeans”.

If one were to look at some of the policies given by the current PAP leadership, then the picture does not look pretty:

  • Cabinet Ministers have urged Singaporeans not to get a degree merely for the sake of one, while the PAP lavishes somewhere to the tune of $400 million on scholarships to foreign students.
  • Our CPF system pays an interest rate which is one of the lowest in the world amongst all pension funds of 4.2% on average, which is barely enough to fight the long-term trend for inflation (2%)
  • The HDB flats which we spend 30 years of our lives paying for will have its value drop to zero at the end of its lease while the value will plunge sharply after 40 years thus deviating from the promise of asset enhancement by the political leaders.
  • Singapore has become the most expensive city in the World while a minimum wage has not been defined. BBC estimates that 400,000 Singaporeans have less than $5 a day after spending on their necessities
  • GST, conservancy fees, electricity tariffs, and water charges have all increased while their parent organisations have already made substantial profits
  • With weak labour laws and an ineffective fair consideration framework, Job security and Costs of Living are now the top concerns of average everyday workers.
  • Elderly workers have to resort to picking cardboard and cleaning hawker centres in their retirement age. In 2016, the Chinese media reported that an 80-year-old cleaner died in the toilet while taking a break:

What do you think?

 

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

掐前女友脖子国大生被轻判引哗然! 尚穆根:将检讨现有法律框架

国大牙科生对前女友动粗,甚至猛掐对方颈项,却只被判罚短期拘留12天,拘留结束后须遵守日间报到、进行社区服务等。然而如此判决,引起社会哗然。 内政部长兼律政部长尚穆根称,针对这类案件,政府将检讨现有法律框架,从三方面作出检讨: 1)未来对类似案件实施的刑罚 2)诸如学术背景等因素与判决的关联 3)不同罪行间刑罚的相对性 他指出理解公众对有关判决“有强烈情绪”,但我国有独立的司法体系,法官是根据案情下判,“问题不在法庭”,反之该检讨的是司法政策框架。 另一方面,人民行动党妇女团也对有关判决表示失望,认为刑期和被告罪行不成正比,并强烈谴责针对妇女的暴行。 不留案底 23岁的国大牙科生殷子勤(Yin Zi Qin译音),不甘女友在去年5月9日提出分手,被告当晚到在女友家人不知情下爬进她睡房,还拿出玫瑰花试图挽留感情,但遭拒绝。 凌晨1时10分,被告表示很难过,女友原本还想解释,却被被告掐住脖子。女友尖叫挣扎,被告又用拇指紧紧压住女友左眼,直到她左眼流血昏迷才住手。…

王乙康短片出现小学生 警称不采取进一步行动

本月2日,原教育部长、三巴旺集选区候任议员王乙康,被选举局告知,他的其中一则出现与小学生对话的短片,已违反选举规则,王乙康只得撤下短片。 根据选举法(第218章)第83条文,不得参与选举活动的人士,包括中小学生、非公民、破产、或有犯罪记录者,都不得参与选举活动。 7月5日,也有民众向警方报案,指控王乙康,让小学生涉及竞选活动,此举违反选举法令。 不过,在选举局和警方告知媒体的最新消息,警方虽确认接获有关报案,但不会对王乙康采取进一步行动,理由是选举官已经训诫后者,需遵守选举条例。  

Reduced legal cost does not mean overcharging: LawSoc

The Law Society of Singapore (LawSoc) has issued a statement to clarify…

【冠状病毒19】6月23日新增119例确诊 三例社区病例

根据卫生部文告,截至本月23日中午12时,本地新增 119 例冠状病毒19确诊。 新增病患大多为住宿舍工作准证持有者。今增 三起社区病例,本地累计确诊病例已增至4万2432例。当局仍在搜集病例详情并将在晚些时候公布。