• About Us
    • Fact Checking Policy
    • Ownership & funding information
    • Volunteer
  • Subscribe
  • Letter submission
    • Submissions Policy
  • Contact Us
The Online Citizen Asia
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Commentaries
    • Letters
    • Comments
  • Current Affairs
    • Singapore
    • Malaysia
    • Indonesia
    • China
    • ASEAN
    • Asia
    • International
  • Finance
    • Economics
    • Labour
    • Property
    • Business
  • Community
    • Arts & Culture
    • Consumer Watch
    • NGO
    • Lifestyle
    • Travel
  • Politics
    • Civil Society
    • Parliament
    • Transport
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
  • Law & Order
    • Legislation
    • Court Cases
No Result
View All Result
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Commentaries
    • Letters
    • Comments
  • Current Affairs
    • Singapore
    • Malaysia
    • Indonesia
    • China
    • ASEAN
    • Asia
    • International
  • Finance
    • Economics
    • Labour
    • Property
    • Business
  • Community
    • Arts & Culture
    • Consumer Watch
    • NGO
    • Lifestyle
    • Travel
  • Politics
    • Civil Society
    • Parliament
    • Transport
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
  • Law & Order
    • Legislation
    • Court Cases
No Result
View All Result
The Online Citizen Asia
No Result
View All Result

Why I am unsympathetic towards residents affected by the Cross Island Line

by onlinecitizen
01/03/2016
in Opinion
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0

By Victor Goh
The planned construction of the new Cross Island Line across the Central Catchment Nature Reserve has triggered concerns from environmental organizations.
Calling for zero impact on the nature reserve, these groups have suggested an alternative route along Lornie Road. In response, the president of Yew Lian Park Residents’ Association, as the representative of affected residents in the area, opposed this suggestion on the grounds that these residents would lose their homes. [1] As long as we subscribe to pragmatism as a nation, this reasoning is unjustified.
Pragmatism often works in conjunction with utilitarianism. The former says that whatever works should be considered good. But this begs the question: to whom is this good for? As there will inevitably be winners and losers in a particular proposal, it is considered good if it generates the greatest good for the greatest number of people, à la utilitarianism.
Since it has already been decided that the Cross Island Line will play a crucial role in relieving the load on existing lines, the construction of the line is in accordance with the principle of pragmatism. Although some individuals might be disadvantaged by the plan, the plan will alleviate the existing load on our MRT lines and hence, is a plan that works for Singaporeans. The objection of a line through the estate because ‘it inconveniences me’ appears to be insufficient as long as we choose to be pragmatic.

Image from "Love our MacRitchie Forest"
Image from “Love our MacRitchie Forest”
Instead of opposing the alternative path as proposed by environmental organizations, one should perhaps question the government’s role in acquiring land for public projects, especially if the homeowners are unwilling to give up their homes. On a deeper level, we might be better off reconsidering the notion of pragmatism as an indisputable value of our society and alter it according to the circumstances of a particular issue.
There is no doubt that some people will apply this idea to the original plan: by constructing the line through the nature reserve, fewer people would be affected, as residents no longer need to relocate. Indeed, this will be the case in the short run. However, in the long run, the ecological impacts of the line will be irreversible, ultimately reducing the naturally endowed wealth of our nation.
According to the Parks and Trees Act, “No person shall, except with the approval of the Commissioner granted under section 12 and in accordance with the terms and conditions of such approval, carry out any of the following activities within any national park or nature reserve”, where one of these activities include clearing, breaking up, digging or cultivating any land. [2]
The original plan for the Cross Island Line to go through the Central Catchment Nature Reserve assumes that the Commissioner would grant an approval for the construction to take place within the reserve. This assumption should have been unfounded given that the Environmental Impact Assessment (part one) was only released this year, since an exception of the particular clause can only be reasonably granted in agreement with the findings of the assessment. The concerns raised by the community are the direct consequences of the decision made to place the Cross Island Line across the nature reserve in the original blueprint before having conducted any investigation.
As long as the law creates an exception for the Commissioner to approve such projects, our nature reserves will be in danger of protecting its integrity as a reserve. A law that purportedly protects a reserve should not have allowed for such exceptions under any circumstance, especially if our lawmakers are determined to keep the space as a reserve. Even if such a provision needs to be in place, it should not have been activated, unless it concerns issues of the utmost importance. In this issue, preserving the reserves would be considered secondary to projects like the Cross Island Line, subjugating our environmental values to the perceived convenience of a shortened traveling time and the associated economic savings.
Given a strict interpretation of the Parks and Trees Act, the law should have unreservedly protected our nature reserves without concerns of additional traveling time of future commuters and the $2 billion in rerouting costs. [3] One would not question the additional costs of adhering to building codes if one were to plan on building an apartment governed by such codes. Indeed, the relevant authorities should have factored in these costs in the initial decision before green lighting the proposal. If that is the case, the line should have been approved only if a proposal that does not cut through the reserve makes economic sense. The ‘additional’ costs of the alternative line should not have been relevant to the issue.
Ex-Minister of Transport Lui Tuck Yew presented a vision for land transport that includes the support of an inclusive, liveable community. [4] However, such a community should not exclude the environment as a non-human stakeholder. The Commissioner should exercise restraint in granting exceptions to state law that undermines the natural reserves that constitutes part of our natural wealth. Such a restraint would necessitate the route around the natural reserve as a default, not as an alternative option. As long as we remain grounded by pragmatic principles as a nation, communities should not oppose a plan just because they are disproportionately affected by proposed projects. Perhaps after having benefitted from so many other state projects, people ignore the plight of affected individuals in the past and refuse to consider the possibility that they too, might find themselves in similar situations of inconvenience.
 

[1] Cross Island Line sparks residents’ fears 
[2] http://statutes.agc.gov.sg/aol/search/display/view.w3p;query=DocId%3Ac6871e24-cb16-417e-8dd5-81bdd6c1ff3c%20Depth%3A0%20Status%3Ainforce;rec=0
https://www.nparks.gov.sg/~/media/nparks-real-content/about-us/legislation/parks-and-trees-act.pdf?la=en
[3] $2b extra cost if Cross Island Line skirts Central Catchment Nature Reserve
[4] Speech by Mr Lui Tuck Yew at visit to DTL1 Chinatown Station on 17 January 2013
For just US$7.50 a month, sign up as a subscriber on The Online Citizen Asia (and enjoy ads-free experience on our site) to support our mission to transform TOC into an alternative mainstream press.

Related Posts

Singapore warns slower economic growth in 2023
Labour

Less than 1 in 10 jobs created in first three quarters of 2022 went to Singaporeans?

28/01/2023
Peru Congress rejects president’s plan for early elections
AFP

Peru Congress rejects president’s plan for early elections

28/01/2023
UMNO purging members as it sacks former health minister Khairy and suspended ex-defence minister Hishammuddin
Malaysia

UMNO purging members as it sacks former health minister Khairy and suspended ex-defence minister Hishammuddin

28/01/2023
WHO panel in talks on COVID emergency status
AFP

WHO panel in talks on COVID emergency status

27/01/2023
AFP

Two years after Myanmar coup, UN says situation ‘catastrophic’

27/01/2023
Grab driver supposedly earned $5,227.82 in a week prior CNY, netizens voice worries over his health
Community

Grab driver supposedly earned $5,227.82 in a week prior CNY, netizens voice worries over his health

27/01/2023
Subscribe
Connect withD
Login
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
Notify of
Connect withD
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Latest posts

Singapore warns slower economic growth in 2023

Less than 1 in 10 jobs created in first three quarters of 2022 went to Singaporeans?

28/01/2023
Peru Congress rejects president’s plan for early elections

Peru Congress rejects president’s plan for early elections

28/01/2023
UMNO purging members as it sacks former health minister Khairy and suspended ex-defence minister Hishammuddin

UMNO purging members as it sacks former health minister Khairy and suspended ex-defence minister Hishammuddin

28/01/2023
WHO panel in talks on COVID emergency status

WHO panel in talks on COVID emergency status

27/01/2023

Two years after Myanmar coup, UN says situation ‘catastrophic’

27/01/2023
Grab driver supposedly earned $5,227.82 in a week prior CNY, netizens voice worries over his health

Grab driver supposedly earned $5,227.82 in a week prior CNY, netizens voice worries over his health

27/01/2023
Philippines to appeal ICC resumption of drug war probe

ICC grants new inquiry into Manila’s deadly ‘war on drugs’

27/01/2023
Minister refutes claims of Malaysia consulting Singapore on housing policy due to its inefficient civil service

Minister refutes claims of Malaysia consulting Singapore on housing policy due to its inefficient civil service

27/01/2023

Trending posts

Two Indian nationals paid about S$330 and S$730 respectively for forged certificates submitted in their S-Pass application

MOM found issuing EPs meant for foreign PMETs to PRC waitress and general worker

by Correspondent
26/01/2023
36

...

Earning only S$400 a month, delivery-rider turned hawker threw in the towel after two years of running a rojak stall

Earning only S$400 a month, delivery-rider turned hawker threw in the towel after two years of running a rojak stall

by Yee Loon
26/01/2023
24

...

Ho Ching breaks silence over Temasek’s write down of its US$275 million investment in FTX, says it “can afford to be contrarian”

US regulator questions VCs’ due diligence work prior to investing in FTX; Ho Ching says Temasek can afford to be contrarian

by The Online Citizen
24/01/2023
28

...

Indian rupee falls 60% since signing of CECA while Singapore becomes top investor in India

by Correspondent
25/01/2023
55

...

Temasek and GIC reportedly in talks with Adani Group accused of “brazen” market manipulation and accounting fraud

Temasek and GIC reportedly in talks with Adani Group accused of “brazen” market manipulation and accounting fraud

by The Online Citizen
26/01/2023
46

...

Why I am unsympathetic towards residents affected by the Cross Island Line

by onlinecitizen
01/03/2016
0

...

March 2016
M T W T F S S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  
« Feb   Apr »
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
  • Letter submission
  • Contact Us

© 2006 - 2021 The Online Citizen

No Result
View All Result
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Commentaries
    • Comments
  • Current Affairs
    • Malaysia
    • Indonesia
    • China
    • ASEAN
    • Asia
    • International
  • Finance
    • Economics
    • Labour
    • Property
    • Business
  • Community
    • Civil Society
    • Arts & Culture
    • Consumer Watch
    • NGO
  • Politics
    • Parliament
    • Transport
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
  • Law & Order
    • Legislation
    • Court Cases
  • Lifestyle
    • Travel
  • Subscribers login

© 2006 - 2021 The Online Citizen

wpDiscuz