Statement on the current pre-sentencing treatment of Amos Yee Pang Sang

By Think Centre

Think Centre (TC) calls for the State to urgently review its treatment of Amos Yee before his final sentencing is confirmed. The State should immediately allow him to be transferred from his remand location at block 7 to either a suitably equipped private hospital to continue his assessment or at the minimum, to the private wards available in the Institute of Mental Health (IMH), to prevent further deterioration of his mental well-being.

Since his arrest, Yee has faced threats of violence to his person while both in remand and out on bail. To a great extent, this is a manifestation of unrestrained mob behaviour, driven by the siege mentality of those who are eager to participate in punishing Yee. TC strongly condemns this culture of revenge promoted by such actions and thinking, and reaffirms that the justice system is not a tool for individuals, collective or otherwise, to gratify such perverse inclinations.

The physical and verbal attacks Yee has faced and the traumatic consequences should be seriously considered by qualified mental healthcare professionals to determine the kind of treatment that any young persons or individual should receive while awaiting a future court hearing.

As an individual under the care of the IMH, TC understands that Yee’s mental well-being shall be considered as a first priority by the mental healthcare professionals there. The fact that Yee was ordered by the courts to be remanded at the facility to await his next court hearing, and not because of medical grounds should be another serious consideration of his ability to remain there without further risk to his mental well-being.

TC urges the State to respect the call from the United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) on 22 June 2015, requesting the State “to consider the best interests of Amos Yee as a child”.

Singapore as a signatory to the United Nations Convention to the Rights of the Child, is committed under Article 40(1) which states, “Parties recognize the right of every child alleged as, accused of, or recognized as having infringed the penal law to be treated in a manner consistent with the promotion of the child’s sense of dignity and worth, which reinforces the child’s respect for the human rights and fundamental freedoms of others and which takes into account the child’s age and the desirability of promoting the child’s reintegration and the child’s assuming a constructive role in society”

Moreover, no person should be subjected to torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, especially not for someone awaiting sentencing and who is still a child.

TC urges the State to further recognise that the World Health Organization defines the right to health as “the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health”. In addition, within the 1991 UN resolution (A/RES/46/119) on “The protection of persons with mental illness and the improvement of mental health care”, principle 8 states that, “Every patient shall be protected from harm, including unjustified medication, abuse by other patients, staff or others or other acts causing mental distress or physical discomfort.”

TC urges all parties involved, especially the court-appointed healthcare professionals to heed the highest international standards necessary to maintain the health of an individual, applicable to Yee’s situation, and take immediate measures to prevent irrevocable damage to his mental wellbeing. TC further calls for Amos Yee to be released unconditionally when he next appears in court on the 6th July.

Note: This statement is made without prejudice as to whether or not Amos Yee has ASD, if indeed it is
verified after thorough and fair examination.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

疑空气污染学生接连病倒 巴西古当16校关闭四日

疑空气污染导致学生一个接一个地病倒,马来西亚巴西古当玫瑰花园宗教学校(SA Taman Mawar)半径6公里范围内的16所学校,已被指示于今日起关闭四日。 16所学校、69间幼稚园和托儿所,以及苏丹依布拉欣理工学院(Ibrahim Sultan Polytechnic)都被下令关闭,2万180名学生和教师被迫停学。 上周四,来自玫瑰花园宗教学校和巴西古当国小4校的15名学童和两名成年人疑因受空气污染影响,出现呼吸困难和呕吐的症状,随后被送往新山班兰医院(Hospital Sultan Ismail)就医。 上述两间学校和巴西古当国小2校,以及两所幼儿园,Pasti幼儿园和Pintar Bistari幼儿园随后于昨日被下令暂时关闭,约3000名学生和工作人员受到影响。 而昨日(23日)空气污染事件一再恶化,来自另一所学校,努沙达迈国中(SMK…

HOME: Migrant workers continue to be exploited because of their nationality, class and gender

This International Migrants’ Day 2014, we stand in solidarity with workers all…

SPF : Beware of fraudulent purchases charged to mobile phone bills

Singapore Police Force (SPF) alerts members of the public to beware of…

九例入境病例来自印度、菲律宾和日本

本地昨日新增226起新确诊病例,在九例入境病例中,包括一名一岁的印度籍男婴,其余的则是分别来自印度、日本和菲律宾,他们均在入境后开始履行居家通知,并接受冠病检测。 截至目前,我国的累计确诊人数5万3千051例,而出院人数新增253人,总康复人数增至4万7千179人。 至于留院的病患,目前仍有一人情况危急,留在加护病房接受治疗,而我国累计死亡病例27起。 文告也指出,日前被列为感染群的吉宝船厂(Keppel Shipyard)和巴耶利峇中心第二大厦(Paya Lebar Quarter Tower 2),经28天后未发现任何新病例,因此将会从感染群列表中排除。 根据卫生部文告指出,截至昨日(3日)中午12点,共新增226起新病例,其中唯一的社区病例为持短期探访准证的26岁斯里兰卡籍囚犯,他在我国实施边境管制前抵达我国,在他首次犯案后入狱时接受了冠病检测,两次均呈阴性,而在第二次犯案入狱后,再次接受检测,并于2日确诊。