PM Lee and Roy

The High Court today dismissed an application by blogger Roy Ngerng’s for a Queen’s Counsel (QC) to represent him in a hearing on damages he must pay for defaming Singapore’s Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong.

High Court judge Steven Chong also ordered Ngerng to pay S$6,000 in costs, inclusive of disbursements.

Ngerng was found guilty of defaming PM Lee in a blog post he made last year that suggested PM Lee misappropriated pension funds in a similar way to how the City Harvest Church was accused of misusing church funds.

The City Harvest Church is currently still before the courts with no verdict yet to be made.

Ngerng’s lawyer George Hwang had filed the bid on 28 May, and had subsequently cited the precedence of the case as grounds for a QC.

This is the first time a blogger is being sued by the Prime Minister in Singapore.

However, Justice Chong said that “novelty is not to be confused with complexity”, as QCs can only be admitted to argue cases in the Singapore courts if they have special qualifications or experience for the purpose of the case.

He also said that while Ngerng’s choice of QC was well-respected in the field of defamation in the United Kingdom, the subject matter of this case is “local-centric”.

Another factor for considering a QC was whether local senior counsel was available to take the case, and whether there is a need to engage the services of a foreign legal counsel.

In response, Justice Chong called Ngerng’s attempts to seek members of the local bar who are not senior counsels to argue his case “disappointing”.

“If Mr Ravi was suitable at the more complex stage, I fail to see why local non-senior counsels would not be suitable at this less complex stage,” Justice Chong was reported by media as saying.

Human rights lawyer M Ravi had been representing Ngerng until his license to practice has been suspended on medical grounds. Ravi is currently seeking to have his license reinstated.

Adapted from media reports.

Subscribe
Notify of
43 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

马善高称骨痛热症病例已减少

环境及水源部长马善高今日在国会声称,国内骨痛热症病例数量已减少。他指出,截至上月24日,环境局成功把七月创下的最高664宗骨痛热症病例记录,减至八月第三周的478宗。 今年累积出现1021个病例集中区(dengue cluster),而环境局成功消灭了其中的863个,其中兀兰、汤申北、菜市路和巴西立等属范围较大的病例集中区,都已被消除。 马善高解释,今年骨痛热症病例攀高,乃是基于气候会更加湿热,伊蚊的繁殖速度更快,以及本地社群的较低免疫力。 对此,他表示环境局对一些公共地区进行检查,避免成为蚊虫滋生之处,仅在今年在全国的出勤检查高达44万2000次,并发现8200个蚊虫繁殖栖息地。 其中有60巴仙都是在住宅区发现,而在上半年,就有1200户家庭因造就蚊虫繁殖温床,而被罚款。 环境局也在新的组屋区和有地住宅区,投入共1万4000个捕卵器(Gravitrap)。自2017年以来,全国共有五万个捕卵器。 另一方面,他重申释放带沃尔巴克菌(Wolbachia)雄性伊蚊计划,进入第三阶段,尽管研究表现令人鼓舞,惟在大规模投入到社区前环境局仍需审慎评估。

Dr Tan Cheng Bock urges people to wear masks when leaving the house amid COVID-19 outbreak

Progress Singapore Party (PSP) chief Dr Tan Cheng Bock took to Facebook…

Chief of Army: Stopover at Xiamen, a purely commercial decision taken by APL

Chief of Army Major-General (MG) Melvyn Ong stated at a media briefing…

COVID-19 test at HK airport costs S$87 while Changi airport charges S$300

Transport Minister Ong Ye Kung announced yesterday (11 Nov) that the first…