The FreeMyInternet group (FMI) has issued a media statement in response to the Media Development Authority’s MDA’s orders for The Real Singapore (TRS) to cease its operations yesterday on 3 May.

FMI states that the “disproportionate power vested in a statutory board” gave MDA too much discretion in censoring online content, and that the basis for censoring TRS remains unclear.

The group also indicated that MDA’s action “runs the risk of sub-judice” as TRS is currently facing a court case for articles that MDA alluded to, and that “as a statutory board, MDA should have known better than to take actions that can potentially pre-judge the court case.”

The full statement is appended below in full.


FMI thumbnailThe FreeMyInternet group expresses our complete and utter disappointment at the Media Development Authority’s (MDA) action in censoring The Real Singapore (TRS), call for this arbitrary and unsubstantiated action to be revoked immediately, and for MDA to come clean on its processes and standards as a regulatory body.

While not all of us might necessarily agree with TRS’s editorial direction or content, what TRS is alleged to have done is no reason for MDA to force a shutdown on the site. MDA’s actions exhibited two key problems: Disproportionate power vested in a statutory board, and unclear guidelines on actions to be taken against objectionable content.

The unfettered power given to MDA is disproportionate in that it gives a statutory board the the sole discretion to close down a website without due process, judiciary or otherwise. This is inconsistent with Singapore’s position as a state that is ruled by law, transparency and accountability.

Furthermore, MDA claimed TRS has “published prohibited material as defined by the Code to be objectionable on the grounds of public interest, public order and national harmony” and “responsible for several articles that sought to incite anti-foreigner sentiments in Singapore”. In relation to the current court case against TRS, this runs the risk of sub-judice. As a statutory board, MDA should have known better than to take actions that can potentially pre-judge the court case.

MDA has also clearly exhibited inconsistency in how it approaches “objectionable content”, be it online or in traditional media. MDA has claimed that “TRS has deliberately fabricated articles and falsely attributed them to innocent parties. TRS has also inserted falsehoods in articles that were either plagiarised from local news sources or sent in by contributors so as to make the articles more inflammatory.”

Objectionable, fabricated and plagiarised content is a regular practice in both mainstream and online media, and most certainly undesirable. But what gives MDA the right to stop the operation of a website on this basis? Websites managed by traditional news outlets have also been known to have fabricated content. Does MDA intend to take action against any website that plagiarises or fabricates content? What is MDA’s basis and standards for taking action, and what are the specific examples cited for TRS? Would it not be sufficient to request for the removal of specific articles rather than the termination of an entire website?

Ai Takagi and Yang Kaiheng with lawyer Choo Zheng Xi (image - CNA)
Ai Takagi and Yang Kaiheng with lawyer Choo Zheng Xi (image – CNA)

Without such clarity and accountability, we are left with no choice but to once again call doubt on MDA’s ability to be a fair and effective media regulator. The unsubstantiated and extraordinary actions taken by MDA against TRS cannot be seen as rules-based, transparent, and fair; only arbitrary and selective. As it is, we can only view MDA’s action against TRS as nothing short of a poorly-conceived and brutal attempt at censorship.

We also wish to highlight that MDA has chosen to take such action on 3 May, World Press Freedom Day. This is an affront to an international movement championed by the United Nations.

The FreeMyInternet group reaffirms our position that the right way to deal with any content deemed objectionable and offensive is with open discussion and reasoned debate. Such has also been the position championed by the Media Literacy Council. Shutting anyone down for disagreeable content, by anyone’s standard much less that of a regulator that has been inconsistent in its standards, is a trigger happy approach that reeks of blatant censorship and does not speak well of Singapore as a democratic country.

The above statement was made in exclusion of Mr Choo Zheng Xi, who is currently representing the editors of TRS in their court case.

* * * * *

People walk past mock gravestone during protest against new licensing regulations in SingaporeAbout FreeMyInternet

The FreeMyInternet movement was founded by a collective of bloggers who are against the licensing requirements imposed by the Singapore government on 1 June 2013, which requires online news sites to put up a performance bond of S$50,000 and comply within 24 hours to remove content that is found to be in breach of content standards. The group believes this to be an attempt at censorship and an infringement on the rights of Singaporeans to access information online and calls for a withdrawal of this licensing regime.

Subscribe
Notify of
76 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

确诊患者曾到过的地点再增三地!

冠病19确诊患者曾到过的地点再增三个,其中包括樟宜村、芽笼路3巷、白沙西厦。 据卫生部所发布的文告,曾有确诊患者在16日和17日出现在不同地点,其中包括樟宜村熟食中心,患者到访时间为7月17日早上9点55分至10点25分曾到访樟宜村熟食中心。 此外,也有患者也到访芽笼路3巷的G7田鸡粥活海鲜,时间则是7月16日晚上6点05分至7点40分;以及白沙西厦(Pasir Ris West Plaza),时间是7月17日早上9点50分至10点20分。 当局目前已和与确诊病例密切接触的人接触,若民众曾在上述时间地点内出现,则必须留意自己的身体状况,若出现急性呼吸道感染症状,或有发烧或失去味觉或嗅觉,应尽快就医,并向医生表明曾到访的地点。

三年來首度放宽货币政策,避免技术性经济衰退

由于中美贸易战仍在继续,我国于今日(14日)放宽了货币政策,亦是三年来首度放宽货币,而对于出口经济的国家而言,可以在第三季度勉强度过了技术性经济衰退。 随着全球经济放缓的情况加剧,我国金管局亦跟随其他国家的脚步,放宽货币政策。事实上,我国向来以出口主导的国家,一般而言,若遇上经济低迷时期,很有可能成为首个受到冲击的国家。 近数月以来,在制造业疲软的拖累下,经济增长与出口也受到沉重打击,大幅度下滑。金融管理局(MAS)表示,将货币“略微降低”允许其货币有所浮动,从而有效使美元走软。 与其调整其利率,我国使用货币政策限制新元升值幅度,为三年来首次,惟汇率区间及中位数维持不变。 金管局表示,“过去半年中,制造业的疲软加剧,影响了GDP增长,这也反映了全球电子产品周期持续低迷,以及投资支出的缩减,其部分原因在于中美关系的不确定性。” 贸工部公布我国第三季经济的初步预估数据,整体国内生产总值(GDP)增长了仅0.1巴仙,与第二季度持平,而据7月份所公布的预估数据,第二季度的表现并不如预期。 日前贸工部曾公布我国第三季整体国内生产总值(GDP)增长0.6%,从第二季度的2.7巴仙中反弹,增长了0.1巴仙。 由于受到中美贸易关税影响,我国亦遭受打击,亦是自2008年全球金融危机爆发后,再次进入经济衰退,而作为我国重要出口之一的制造业则是下滑3.5巴仙,连续三个季度萎缩;建筑业增长2.7巴仙,服务业增长从上个季度的1.1巴仙,进一步放缓至0.9巴仙。  

S$200,000 scam attempt foiled by alert staff of Maybank

Police stated on Monday (8 August) that an attempt to scam a…

Thaipusam 2011 – A photo story

by Joshua Chiang Sometimes, it’s best to let the pictures do the…