Jason Blair UngerBy Gangasudhan

It was reported this week that Jason Blair Unger, a cyclist who was captured on film throwing his bicycle onto the bonnet of a car, had been charged for the offence of Mischief.

In the footage from the car’s camera that was posted online (which can be viewed here, here and here) by the driver, Woo Wing Onn, it is clear that the cyclist was unhappy with the driver and was attempting to confront the latter. In the video, we can hear the shocked car occupants express surprise at the reaction of the cyclist, and see him walk over to the driver’s side of the vehicle in a threatening manner.

The offence of Mischief falls under Section 425 of the Penal Code (Chapter 224), and is premised on the intent to cause wrongful loss or damage to someone. However, it is clear (or at least reasonable to believe) that the cyclist in this case was not planning to cause damage for the sake of causing damage but to confront or even attack the driver – for whatever reason, assumed or justified.

Under those conditions, the elements fit the criteria of Criminal Intimidation under Section 503 of the Penal Code (Chapter 224) which outlines a threat of harm to cause alarm or prevent a person from his legal right (which in this case, would be travelling on the road).

mischief Sg law

criminal intimidation Sg law

The punishment for Mischief is “imprisonment for a term which may extend to 3 months, or with fine, or with both” while the offence of Criminal Intimidation carries a punishment of “imprisonment for a term which may extend to 2 years, or with fine, or with both”. In addition, the offence of Criminal Intimidation falls under the schedule of ‘arrestable’ offences which “the State deems generally to be more serious”, but mischief does not – meaning, an arrest cannot be made without a warrant and the case cannot be investigated before directions from the magistrate or public prosecutor.

Since road rage is taken seriously in Singapore, it seems to make more sense – not to mention, more aligned with the violence of the incident – to prosecute offenders for Criminal Intimidation. Furthermore, the range for the punishment allows for harsher sentences to be meted out if necessary, especially with more instances of road rage being witnessed across the nation.

In a case of road rage handled by the courts in June 2013, the presiding judge suggested that custodial sentences were the norm and imprisoned the offender for a week for mischief. However, other cases that appeared before the court on later dates (e.g. this and this) only involved fines for the offence of Mischief. While Criminal Intimidation does not automatically mean incarceration for the perpetrator, with mostly fines being served, it seems more appropriate to proceed along that course of action, especially when a man who sent an email threatening to tarnish the reputation of the CEO of Gardens by The Bay, was charged under this offence.

Note: In the interests of full disclosure, this author personally knows the perpetrator through a common friend.

Subscribe
Notify of
10 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

SPF: No checks done at residential units to enforce elevated COVID-19 safe distancing measures

The Singapore Police Force (SPF) said that it does not conduct checks…

【冠状病毒19】73岁病患因并发症逝世

本地第4689起冠状病毒患者昨日因冠毒并发症,宣告病逝,为73岁的本地人。 卫生部指出,病患生前有高血压、高脂血和甲状腺机能减退症(hypothyroidism)的病历,基于是因冠毒并发症逝世,所以被纳入冠毒死亡病例中,属本地第23起死亡病例。 依据病患纪录,患者于4月17日确诊,在5月21日逝世,病患家属也获得国家传染病中心联系,确保他们获得所需要的帮助。 在我国自冠毒爆发至今所累积的22起死亡病例中,年龄介于58至97岁的死者,大部分生前都患有慢性疾病。

AWARE’s report to the UN highlights the urgent need to protect children in Singapore from discrimination and inequality

Leading gender rights organisation, AWARE has called for policies to level the…

【冠状病毒19】报导指商场人挤人 孙雪玲忧防疫前功尽弃

内政部兼国家发展部高级政务次长孙雪玲呼吁民众,要做好防疫措施,在购物商场也要保持安全社交距离。 孙雪玲在脸书上发帖,分享了于上周在《海峡时报》刊登的周末水滨坊购物商场(Waterway Point Mall)之景,照片中只见购物商场内人挤人,虽然大家都戴着口罩,但是却没有保持安全社交距离。 帖文中,孙雪玲表示她对有关的情况感到担忧,“我了解你们想和家人一起共度时光,但我很担忧”。 她促请民众避免到人潮拥挤的地方,并且和家人以外的人保持良好社交距离,更提醒到,“你虽然戴着口罩,但是别以为它能做完善防护”。 “我只希望你们安全……不要因为一时大意,而荒废了之前的努力。”