The following is a statement by Jolovan Wham and Rachel Zeng, organisers of Democracy Now! Singapore in Solidarity with Hong Kong, in response to Singapore Law Minister, Mr K Shanmugam’s remarks about Occupy Central protest in Hong Kong.
candlelight vigil

In an interview with the Chinese daily, Lianhe Zaobao, Minister for Foreign Affairs Mr K Shanmugam said that Hong Kongers should be happy with Beijing’s offer since the territory never had democracy under British rule. Moreover, what Beijing was offering was more than what the British had ever granted. Prior to the handover, neither the British rulers nor the Hong Kong media clamoured for democracy. Further remarks were made that there has been a lot of anti-China bias in Western media reporting on the issue.

Just because mass protests and widespread media support for universal suffrage did not happen under British rule does not make current calls for freedom any less legitimate. Freedom and justice does not have an expiry date and there is never a right or wrong time to fight for freedom. In addition, any suggestion that the Western media is biased in its account of the protests needs to be seen in light of how Hong Kong’s media and reporters are under assault by China’s central government.

The argument that universal suffrage was not included in the Sino-British Joint Declaration does not take into account the point that the Declaration itself promised Hong Kong a ‘high degree of autonomy’ and it was only in areas of diplomacy and defence that Hong Kong would not have any control over. In fact, the Basic Law states that Hong Kong’s Chief Executive should be selected via universal suffrage. Therefore, any assertion that China has acted according to Basic Law is not necessarily accurate.

Unity and progress, prosperity and democracy are not concepts which are diametrically opposed to each other. In the face of rising inequality, where the majority of a country’s wealth is concentrated in the hands of a few, there are legitimate fears that the lack of genuine democracy in Hong Kong may further entrench plutocracy and crony capitalism. Moreover, Beijing’s pre-screened candidates could continue to erode Hong Kong’s fundamental freedoms such as its judicial independence. Freedom of speech will most likely be curtailed, leading to newspapers and media outlets turning into mouthpieces of the government. Civil servants of government departments will be told to be ‘patriotic’ to China.

The Foreign Affairs Minister argues that Hong Kong should not emulate the partisan politics of countries such as the United States as it may lead to gridlocks which hinder growth and decision making. It is correct that Hong Kong should chart its own path to democratic reform. But it has to be remembered that a diminished democracy will cause more harm to its people in the long run. When institutions do not have independent processes, it is vulnerable to abuse, no matter how noble or genuine the intentions of politicians. Without the right to elect our own leaders, those who are incompetent, or who do not act in the interests of the people can remain in power for as long as they desire.

Subscribe
Notify of
16 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Another potential problem with the GRC

Andy Loh/ Much has been said about how the GRC system has…

Rental flats in S’pore

How do our poorest Singaporeans live? When was the last time the town council painted or washed the block? Take a look at this video.

Josephine Teo says she faced discrimination in her job last time but Lee Yi Shyan helped her

The Manpower Ministry (MOM) will impose new licence conditions on all employment…

经济基本面良好 陈振声:我国有能力应对全球不明朗

贸工部长陈振声今日在国会回答议员针对新加坡经济现况的提问,指我国能凭借良好基本面、稳健财政状况和经济结构调整的良好进展,应对眼前中美贸易冲突下的乌云。 不过,他表示政府仍会继续观察经济状况,并随时准备介入给予企业和劳动者必要的支持。 陈振声指出,全球经济走弱,美中争端​​已超越了报复性贸易关税,超出了技术准入和销售限制等其他领域,这是一个关键的不确定因素。加上中国经济比预期大幅度放缓、英国脱欧失序、部分经济体和区域正职不稳定,消费者和商企信心受抑制。 再者,我国关键出口市场需求降低,也使我国外向导向行业如电子、精密工程和批发贸易受影响。 他说,经济发展局(EDB)对外投资,在固定资产投资上放眼达到80-100亿美元,惟他强调我国仍密切关注这些投资决策。 他补充,考量第二季度的所有经济数据和最新的外部经济状况,当局将审查8月份的全年增长预测。 由于新加坡的开放和贸易依赖型经济在第一季度出现了近十年来的最慢增长,因此5月份的增长预测首先缩小至1.5巴仙至2.5巴仙。 对于劳动市场,他表示仍保持“弹性”(resilient),第一季度就业率仍持续增长、失业率约为2.2巴仙。 他认为全球经济可能发生根本性转变,影响我国中长期前景。他也提及多边贸易体制的未来,例如出现新的全球秩序,各国直接推介最低有效税率,这可能影响我国作为全球枢纽的地位;以及利用新技术和数码经济创造新机会。 三管齐下:稳定政治环境 陈振声在国会提出三管齐下策略,克服目前挑战,其一继续加强新加坡在竞争中的基础,例如稳定政治环境、有能力和一致的领导、亲善环境、供需链的链接便利、熟练劳动力等等。 其二,不断更新为商企和投资者抓住新机遇,他说工业转型“取得令人鼓舞的进展”,在先进制造领域如何创造新的利基产品,如增材制造(additive…