The following is a statement by Jolovan Wham and Rachel Zeng, organisers of Democracy Now! Singapore in Solidarity with Hong Kong, in response to Singapore Law Minister, Mr K Shanmugam’s remarks about Occupy Central protest in Hong Kong.
candlelight vigil

In an interview with the Chinese daily, Lianhe Zaobao, Minister for Foreign Affairs Mr K Shanmugam said that Hong Kongers should be happy with Beijing’s offer since the territory never had democracy under British rule. Moreover, what Beijing was offering was more than what the British had ever granted. Prior to the handover, neither the British rulers nor the Hong Kong media clamoured for democracy. Further remarks were made that there has been a lot of anti-China bias in Western media reporting on the issue.

Just because mass protests and widespread media support for universal suffrage did not happen under British rule does not make current calls for freedom any less legitimate. Freedom and justice does not have an expiry date and there is never a right or wrong time to fight for freedom. In addition, any suggestion that the Western media is biased in its account of the protests needs to be seen in light of how Hong Kong’s media and reporters are under assault by China’s central government.

The argument that universal suffrage was not included in the Sino-British Joint Declaration does not take into account the point that the Declaration itself promised Hong Kong a ‘high degree of autonomy’ and it was only in areas of diplomacy and defence that Hong Kong would not have any control over. In fact, the Basic Law states that Hong Kong’s Chief Executive should be selected via universal suffrage. Therefore, any assertion that China has acted according to Basic Law is not necessarily accurate.

Unity and progress, prosperity and democracy are not concepts which are diametrically opposed to each other. In the face of rising inequality, where the majority of a country’s wealth is concentrated in the hands of a few, there are legitimate fears that the lack of genuine democracy in Hong Kong may further entrench plutocracy and crony capitalism. Moreover, Beijing’s pre-screened candidates could continue to erode Hong Kong’s fundamental freedoms such as its judicial independence. Freedom of speech will most likely be curtailed, leading to newspapers and media outlets turning into mouthpieces of the government. Civil servants of government departments will be told to be ‘patriotic’ to China.

The Foreign Affairs Minister argues that Hong Kong should not emulate the partisan politics of countries such as the United States as it may lead to gridlocks which hinder growth and decision making. It is correct that Hong Kong should chart its own path to democratic reform. But it has to be remembered that a diminished democracy will cause more harm to its people in the long run. When institutions do not have independent processes, it is vulnerable to abuse, no matter how noble or genuine the intentions of politicians. Without the right to elect our own leaders, those who are incompetent, or who do not act in the interests of the people can remain in power for as long as they desire.

Subscribe
Notify of
16 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Jolovan Wham: Going to prison to “show the inherent violence and brutality of the State to citizens expressing themselves peacefully”

by Jolovan Wham I was released last Friday after spending 15 days in…

#SGBudget2019: Reduced travellers’ import tax relief to offset GST increase, more returns for lower and middle income S’poreans

The increase in the Goods and Services Tax (GST) from 7% to 9%…

累计骨痛热症病例已破两万大关! 每周病例仍维持千起以上

我国骨痛热症在截至8月1日的一周,增1380起新病例,新增病例有所缓和。不过需注意的是,截至8月4日,我国已累积超过2万2400起骨痛热症病例! 国家环境局发文告指出,我国骨痛热症新增病例出现缓和现象,比之前一周减少了412起。 但是,这也是我国每周新增病例维持在1000起以上的第八周,因此促请我国居民继续保持合作,继续减少黑斑蚊的新增病例。 目前我国仍然有超过60万户住家,住在岛上逾390个骨痛热症黑区的范围内。 当局表示,会和所有市镇会合作,加强为期两周的全岛防蚊疫措施工作,并促请所有居民采取三种预防蚊疫措施,即在住家周围的黑暗角落喷洒杀虫剂、定期使用驱虫剂,并穿上长袖上衣和长裤。 当局也发布了两个教育短片,以指导民众在家中喷洒气雾杀虫剂,以及独居在骨痛热症黑区的居民应该如何应对蚊虫侵扰。 环境局指出,在稽查行动中,在居民住户发现反复的蚊虫繁殖温床,这令当局感到担忧。在首六个月的稽查行动中,展开了约150次行动,有23次都发现,原本地点再次出现蚊虫繁殖温床,因此将会继续并加强有关的稽查。

柔佛王储上载好友合照 吁新马寻双赢方案

“在我左边的,是来自新加坡特别部队的毕孟星,照顾我的个人安全九年;在我右边是马来西亚特种部队军官山沙瓦中校,….我们三人都是好友,在相同领域合作共事。” 柔佛王储东姑伊斯迈昨日在脸书上载的图文,恐怕会令许多为新马争议争吵不休的人士蒙羞。 他上传一张与毕孟星及山沙瓦的合照,两人扣手,而王储居中。 王储介绍,在图中自己就站在新加坡和马来西亚之间,但三人都是好朋友,其中山沙瓦也是他的军校同学,为他效劳了三年。 他呼吁新马两国在近期争议上,都能找到双赢方案,共存共荣,不应纠缠于一些无谓的事件。 王储的贴文一日内就获得近万人按赞,获分享786次。 一些网民赞扬柔佛王储的观点。洪荣强认为,新马两国在经济上的协作更为有利,特别是我国在伊斯干达项目的投资也不少;长提两岸都有我们的亲人和朋友,如果一再挑起课题只会造成不信任,更需要谨慎维持双边关系。