Almost 3 months after Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong queued up at a hawker centre to buy chicken wings for his family, his deputy has done the same.
According to the Chinese newspapers, Deputy Prime Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam was seen at the Tiong Bahru hawker centre buying bak chor mee (minced meat noodle).**
A member of the public had seen the DPM, took photo of him at the stall and uploaded it online.
queuing1
Apparently, Mr Tharman was having lunch at about 12 noon, the newspaper says. It added that Mr Tharman “queued up with the members of the public”.
But Mr Tharman was not the only parliamentarian who was there at the hawker centre that day.
Nine other Members of Parliament, such as Jospehine Teo, Hri Kumar, Vikram Nair, and Zaqy Mohamed, were with the DPM.
MPs hawker
The newspaper said Mr Tharman had gone to the hawker centre with the MPs for lunch. A spokesman for the DPM said, “After they had finished their lunch, they stayed on and chit chatted for about half an hour.”
The bak chor mee hawker said he was surprised to see Mr Tharman at his stall, especially since it was raining that day. He said the DPM ordered two bowls of bak chor mee, and also enquired how his business was doing.
But being seen eating at the hawker centre is not new, at least when it comes to the PAP.
Some years ago, PM Lee was spotted, along with his family, at a hawker centre, enjoying common fare.
queuing2
And in June this year, PM Lee was seen queuing up at a Redhill hawker centre to buy chicken wings for his family. The photo of him at the food outlet went viral online, with some surprised that he would hunker down, as it were, with the ordinary folks, while others questioned if it was a publicity stunt.
queuing3
The person who apparently took a photo of Mr Lee said the PM was “swarmed with guards” while he lined up to place his order.
Mr Lee himself later confirmed on his Facebook page that it was indeed him at Redhill.
What do Singaporeans make of these queuing up at the hawker centres, eating “common food” as the common folk, taking selfies of themselves and uploading these online, etc?
The People’s Action Party (PAP) has always been seen as elitist, as being from the so-called “ivory tower” where they are out of touch with the common people.
In fact, after his very first general election contest in 1984, Mr Lee concluded in a post-mortem of the results – where the PAP had lost almost 13 per cent of the vote compared to the previous election – that “people had come to see it as arrogant and unfeeling.”
Mr Lee said then that “people needed to be engaged emotionally.”
30 years later, the perception, real or otherwise, that the PAP is a detached party from the people remains, even in the last general election in May 2011.
Even civil servants felt the PAP was “indifferent.”
“They keep things running,” civil servant Jeremy Tay was quoted by the media as saying, “I’m not sure there ever was much emotional connection to begin with.”
Its party member and former Minister of Foreign Affairs, George Yeo, said during the 2011 hustings that it was “time for PAP to change”, following the deep unhappiness the people had with the party.
queuing4
Three years later, in March 2014, PAP MP Stioh Yihpin, cautioned against being out of touch.
“Once a politician is seen to be elitist and lacking in empathy, people cannot see themselves having an engaging relationship with him which is based on mutual understanding and respect,” he said in Parliament. “Once successfully labelled ‘out of touch’, you are so far away, you are practically a lost cause, because no real relationship is possible.”
Do Singaporeans see these recent apparent attempts by members of the PAP to be “one with the people” as genuine and sincere, or would they be cynical and see these as politicians being politicians, doing whatever is necessary to win votes and support?
—————–
*In 1984, the PAP lost almost 13 per cent of the votes because it was seen as “elitist”. In the last two general elections under Mr Lee, it has lost a total of 15 per cent of the votes.
**Incidentally, in 2006, blogger Lee Kin Mun, aka Mr Brown, created a “persistently non-political podcast” in which a fictitious Jeff Lopez went to the hawker centre to order a bowl of bak chor mee – without ter kwa (pig’s liver). The podcast was a satirical take on the then Workers’ Party candidate James Gomes incident in the 2006 General Election where the PAP accused him of lying in claiming he had submitted some election forms.
In his National Day Rally speech that year, PM Lee used Lee Kin Mun’s podcast as an example to show that politics “is not all fun and games”.
“You put out a funny podcast, you talk about bak chor mee,” PM Lee said. “I will say mee siam mai hum.” (Hear it here.)
His last remark soon became a running joke – mee siam (a local dish) does not in fact contain “hum” (cockles).
Thus, PM Lee saying he would ask for “mee siam mai hum” (mee siam without cockles) showed that he was out of touch with the ordinary folk and their way of life.
You can still hear Mr Brown’s podcast here.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

连氏基金长期护理研究(2)– 终身护保索赔条件严苛 学者:依级别赔付扩大安全网

连氏基金会和国立大学社会科学研究所两位助理教授何琳贻和黄瑞莲,针对我国长期护理前景进行研究。 除了昨日《海峡时报》所报导,强调更多年长者选择居家或中心式看护服务,且成本高昂,显示有必要提升现有社会保障机制。有关研究报告也针对现有医疗保健政策提供建议,特别呼吁应改善终身护保计划(CareShield Life)的受保赔付条件,让保户获得较广泛的保障。 报告列举出一些新的看护政策或计划逐步涌现,例如整合式居家和日顾计划(IHDC),让那些无法离开住家的年长者,中心能暂时派看护人员到家服务,至于那些在家护理者,则被鼓励在行动便利下能转移到中心接受看护。 至于“活跃乐龄中心”也在新的公共组屋区提供整合式乐龄看护服务,例如日顾、复健和代送日用品等。 “近年来,私人领域填补了乐龄看护领域的空洞,特别是针对想获得更多元和专属服务的中产和中上阶级。自愿福利组织也开始与私人业者合作。” 该研究发现,缔造获颁关系是实现规模经济和专业化的有效手段,同时也能落实提供全方位和持续性服务的目标。研究也认为,社会与家庭发展部把社会关怀任务,转交给卫生声部,使得看护领域获得更集中的规划和精简化,有望使该领域受惠。 研究报告欢迎政府推出终身护保计划,在应对长期护理成本日益攀升,提供民众保障。然而研究也点出其问题,包括终身健保符合赔付的条件严苛、相对较低的保赔和妇女需支付出更高保费。 去年仅6.6巴仙长者严重伤残 保户需符合严重伤残资格,即日常起居至少三项无法自理,才能领取每月600新元的赔付。然而,报告指出在2017年,只有6.6巴仙长者—约3万4千人面临严重伤残情况。这意味着,有大部分人都在符合申请赔付的范围外。 Elaine Ho指出,许多新加坡人的长期护理可能面对保障不足。在2017年,有三分之一年龄介于40至84岁人士,仍未购买基础乐龄健保(ElderShield)。…

Expat returns from India and tested positive for COVID-19 after serving 21 days of SHN

Last Friday, the Ministry of Health (MOH) revealed that an Indian expat…

191 new cases of COVID-19 infection in S’pore; 186 locally transmitted cases, 90 unlinked

As of Sunday noon (5 Sep), the Ministry of Health (MOH) has…

BG Kelvin Khong Boon Leong to take over as Chief of Air Force

Brigadier-General (BG) Kelvin Khong Boon Leong, currently Chief of Staff-Joint Staff (COS-JS),…