Current Affairs
Competition Commission allows Scoot, Tiger to coordinate fares, flight schedules
By Howard Lee
The Competition Commission Singapore (CCS) has given the green light for what could be an alliance between two Scoot and Tiger Airways, which would see the two budget airlines coming together to decide on scheduling, pricing, sales and marketing, service policies, and other matters.
It is not clear if the partnership would lead to price fixing between the two airlines, both of which are partly or wholly owned by Singapore Airlines.
Nevertheless, CCS maintains that the cooperation would result in “net economic benefits” – which include improvements in scheduling and efficiency on routes, expanded connectivity across the two carriers’ networks and expansion of existing networks – that would not be detrimental to consumers.
CCS noted that the two airlines “operate largely complementary networks of flights”, which is taken to imply that they do not generally compete with each other.
“Although some parts of the Proposed Cooperation would raise competition concerns, these would be offset by a resulting net economic benefit (NEB) to Singapore passengers and therefore the Proposed Cooperation is excluded from the Section 34 Prohibition,” said CCS in a media statement.
Section 34 Prohibitions looks into agreements, decisions and practices which prevent, restrict or distort competition.
The two airlines have applied to CCS in January 2014 for clearance to undertake the cooperation, and CCS has sought feedback in February in relation to the proposal by the two airlines. The two airlines first announced a partnership in October 2012.
CCS also published a study report on 11 February 2014 that examines the NEB of joint ventures in the airline industry.
In its analysis of two airline alliances, the report evaluated that such cooperations, while resulting in economic benefit, might not necessarily result in a reduction in fares. As indicated:
“The main benefit of existing JVs (joint ventures) has been an increase in passenger numbers, both at the market level and for the carriers in the JV. These increases in passenger numbers are likely to have generated significant economic benefits for Singapore. While not quantifiable directly, economic benefits from increased trade and business travel are likely, as are more immediate benefits from increased airport revenue.
On fares, the picture is complex. Any changes following a JV appear to have been driven by what passengers do – which airlines they travel on, the routes they take and the proportion that travel in each fare class. These so-called “mix effects” can mean that average fares change even when fares offered by individual airlines or JVs remain the same.”
The approval from CCS to Scoot and Tiger Airways, however, is by no means a go-ahead for other airlines, as “each airline cooperation agreement would need to be examined on a case-by-case basis,” CCS said.
Scoot and Tiger Airways jointly operate a total of 33 aircraft, serving a total of 46 destinations in 15 countries from Singapore. the two budget carriers offer more than 450 weekly flights and about 169,000 seats every week.
CCS is a statutory board established under the Competition Act, which empowers CCS to investigate alleged anti-competitive activities, determine if such activities infringe the Act and impose suitable remedies, directions and financial penalties.
Images – Tiger Airways Airbus A320-200 by Phil Vabre (GFDL), Wikimedia Commons; Scoot Boeing 777-200ER by Kok Chwee Sim, Wikipedia Creative Commons
-
Singapore3 days ago
Purported resignation message from Li Hongyi as Singpass director goes viral; GovTech yet to confirm authenticity
-
Singapore3 days ago
Lee Hsien Yang alleges rising repression and corruption in Singapore; government calls claims a ‘personal vendetta
-
Community1 day ago
PAP MP Edward Chia: ‘Sanctions on Israel do not work’ when confronted by Holland-Bukit Timah resident
-
Comments1 week ago
8World News anchor Zhang Haijie faces criticism for labelling Lee Hsien Yang as ‘unfilial son’
-
Politics1 week ago
Singapore govt accuses Lee Hsien Yang of creating ‘false urgency’ over 38 Oxley Road demolition
-
Opinion7 days ago
Where does Lee Hsien Loong stand on the future of 38 Oxley Road as the government revisits the issue?
-
Politics5 days ago
Charles Yeo claims Singapore is seeking his extradition from UK; AGC remains silent
-
Opinion1 week ago
Where is the iron in Lawrence Wong? Hiding from direct response to Lee Hsien Yang?