By Terry Xu

Secretary General of the Workers’ Party and Member of Parliament for Alujined GRC, Low Thia Khiang asked two questions in Parliament during the supplementary question segment on Tuesday regarding the Central Provident Fund (CPF) and how it was invested, but got an answer that was hardly satisfactory.

Mr Low sought clarification from Deputy Prime Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam about CPF money being issued as Special Singapore Government Securities (SSGS) and invested in GIC Private Ltd, a sovereign wealth fund, together with other assets of Singapore.

“He say that the CPF money managed and invested as an independent pool, it will not be able to enjoy the same investment returns as GIC,” said Mr Low. “I would like to know why is it so.”

He also pointed that there is about S$300 billion in the CPF funds and asked why this sum of money is not sufficient to be invested separately to provide the same or better returns.

Mr Tharman indicated that CPF money had to be pooled with the money from the government surplus as well as incumbent assets from the Singapore’s reserves to invest long term so as to achieve the high returns to CPF members.

“There is no private sector fund manager that will take up on that task because it is very difficult to the GIC. Because it is a large diversified portfolio that is aimed to invest in the long term and aims to do better than the SGS obligations.
But that is because the GIC is not just managing SGS obligations, not just managing CPF liabilities. If it was managing CPF liabilities and SSGS obligations where you must meet that obligations every year, it will need a conservative portfolio.
Meaning not much equalities, certainly no real estate, alternative assets. It will basically be a simple bond portfolio and it is not going to earn very much. It will aim to just minimise the chance of failure to meet obligations. Not maximise long terms returns. That is what would happen.”

 

However, Mr Tharman did not address Mr Low’s question on whether S$300 billion dollars was sufficient to be invested on its own.

A financial adviser TOC spoke to felt that Mr Tharman’s explanation did little to clarify Mr Low’s question.

“It does not make any difference if the investment amount is $1 million or $1 billion. The investment portfolio can still be set at a similar risk and return portfolio. It is bewildering to think that funds are mingled together to achieve lower investment risk , but yet the different parties are not given the same investment returns.”

Mr Low also asked earlier if the government would consider allowing more flexibility in the withdrawal of CPF money for the CPF member to repay a small amount of housing loans when he reaches the age of 55.

Using the example of small-value withdrawals of about S$20,000, Mr Low said that the lump sum withdrawal could allow CPF members to pay off the outstanding loans of their houses and avoid paying unnecessary interest on their housing loans.

In response to Mr Low’s question, Manpower Minister Tan Chuan Jin expressed his concern about how the Retirement Account (RA) will be depleted if CPF members were to be allowed to withdraw money to pay off housing loans.

He said that the RA needs to be preserved in order to meet growing retirement needs, and promised tweaks to the CPF Act to improve the system. CPF members could also expect help from the Housing Development Board (HDB) on a case by case basis.

 

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Three-term MP Teo Ser Luck makes at least an additional $5m as mayor before saying “bye-bye”

Yesterday (24 Feb), the Leader of the Opposition Pritam Singh told Parliament…

调高退休龄和重雇佣年龄顶限 劳资政小组将呈具体建议

人力部长兼内政部第二部长杨莉明昨日发表劳动节献词时称,人力部为了继续打造亲年长者的职场,将检讨优化职场计划和特别就业补贴计划。 此前国会曾讨论,将延迟退休年龄和提高重新雇佣年龄的幅度和速度,以及55岁以上员工公积金缴交率的课题。今年较迟些时候,年长员工劳资政工作小组将对此提出具体建议。 “年长员工劳资政工作小组于一年前成立至今,经过多次磋商和斟酌,在推迟法定退休年龄和提高重新雇佣年龄方面的商议有了共识。” 她表示,这是一个重要的里程碑,得以提供有意继续工作的年长员工更多保障。 “我相信,推迟退休年龄和提高重新雇佣年龄,将能够激励工友和雇主们在提升技能和重新设计工作方面,做出更大的努力。” 目前,我国的法定退休年龄时62岁,而重新雇佣年龄则是67岁。 盼顶限设在65和70岁 另外,全国职工总会秘书长黄志明在周一(4月25日)也发表了劳动节献词,并表示该会希望退休年龄和重新雇佣年龄的顶限可以设定在65岁和70岁。 他指出,劳资政协作伙伴已经就有关的课题讨论步入后期阶段,并对他们能够听取职工运动意见之举,感到欣慰。“工运官委议员杜莱沙米(Arasu Duraisamy)今年也参加了预算案辩论时,要求把退休年龄和重新雇佣年龄分别上调到65岁和70岁。这是工运的期望。” 在细节方面,黄志明表示劳资政三方还需要时间去厘清和达成共识,随后将逐步落实调整,更给予利益相关者足够的缓冲和调整时间。 在受《联合早报》询及调高退休年龄和重新雇佣年龄时,杜莱沙米表示,虽然很多年长员工都希望能继续工作,但是个别工会和会员都了解到雇主也有实际考量。…

加冷消防局队伍四分钟内赶抵现场 芽笼火警20人自行疏离

昨日在芽笼24A巷一单位住宅发生火警,民防部队出动了7辆救火车和约20名消防员,迅速控制住火势,约20人自行疏离现场,无任何伤亡事件。 民防部队昨晚在脸书上帖文指出,昨日下午2时36分左右,在芽笼24A巷第51A号单位发生火灾,单位的第二层楼被大火吞没。 加冷消防站的官员们在火警发生后的四分钟内,赶抵现场。消防员设置了两支水柱,迅速控制火势,避免毗邻单位遭火势蔓延。 初步证实,处于单位二楼的两间卧室和一间厨房被烧毁。 目前起火原因尚在调查中。 具备内政团队联合设施 这也是加冷消防局自周三(10月9日)开张后,首次参与的灭火行动。 加冷消防局坐落在市中心和国家体育场附近的基里玛弄2号(No. 2 Guillemard Close),可为邻近的加冷区域和国家体育场提供更快速的急救行动。 该消防局也具备内政团队联合设施,时内政团队在重大事件的联合行动指挥处和集合点。…