Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance, Tharman Shanmugaratnam made the Budget Speech 2014 in Parliament lat Friday, which was broadcast live.
The summary of the Budget statement that has been delivered in Parliament can be found here.
CPF and Medisave contribution rate increases – boon or bane?
In the speech made by the Minister, he said: “We will raise CPF contribution rates for those aged above 50 to 55 by 1.5 percentage points – 1 percentage point from the employer and 0.5 percentage points from the employee.”
While this would mean an increase of CPF contribution to build own one’s retirement fund, it also means that the take-home pay of this group of workers will be reduced by 0.5%. 
With the statistics indicating widespread age discrimination as workers age, their real pay increase decreases, particularly for lower-income workers. This may contribute further to their financial stress.
Minister also announced that Medisave contribution rate will increase by 1% for all workers, to be borne by the employer.
The above CPF contribution rate increases may add further wage pressures to employers and may translate into lower real wage increase.
Combined annual healthcare cash outflows still less than inflows
With the 1% increase in the Medisave contribution rate, the Government may continue to, from a cashflow perspective, not need to spend a single cent on healthcare, as the total annual Medisave contributions and interest credited on the the Medisave accounts’ balance of $60 billion (FY2012), is estimated to be about $10 billion.
Indeed, if we compare this to the combined total government operating and development expenditure on healthcare:

  • Medisave Scheme – $798.5 million
  • Private Medical Scheme- $484.1 million
  • Medifund payouts – $102 million
  • Recently announced annual increase in Government healthcare spending on the Pioneer Generation Package subsidies for MediShield Life
  • Expanded subsidies at Specialist Outpatient Clinics (SOCs)
  • Additional bills at polyclinics, Community Health Assist Scheme (CHAS) benefits, Disability Assistance and Medisave top-ups of $200 to $800
  • Medisave top-ups of $100 to $200 annually to those not eligible for the Pioneer Generation

It is highly doubtful if the the total sum of these expenditures will even add up to the estimated $10 billion annual Medisave inflow.
The disproportionate values on inflow versus outflow prompts an important question: Even with the enhanced subsidies (more for the older ones) for MediShield Life, SOC, etc for the pioneer generation, what happens if one is still unable to pay? With no clear indication, they would likely have to apply under Medifund Silver as per current practice. This would mean that the entire family will have to be subjected to vigorous means testing.
$1.16 Budget deficit or $6.84b Budget surplus?
Singapore is expected to have an overall surplus of S$3.9 billion, or 1.1% of GDP, for FY2013.
The overall Budget balance is reportedly a deficit of $1.2 billion for FY2014, or about 0.3% of GDP, with a $8 billion one-time transfer to the newly created Pioneer Fund.
Does this mean that if not for this new transfer, the overall Budget balance in FY2014 is actually projected to be a whopping $6.84 billion? Yet another year of “under-reporting” of the Budget surplus through transfers to endowment funds being treated as an expenditure item?
Median wages increased 9% last 5 years?
The Minister also said that “median wages for citizens increased by about 9% in real terms in the last 5 years”.
As this is, I believe, based on wages including employer CPF contribution for full-time workers, what are the statistics for full-time and all workers (full-time and part-time) excluding employer CPF contribution?
Billions well spent on PIC?
On improving productivity, the Minister announced: “The Productivity and Innovation Credit (PIC) scheme is due to expire in Year of Assessment (YA) 2015. There have been many calls for its extension. We have decided to extend the PIC scheme for another three years until YA2018. This extension will cost the Government a total of $3.6 billion.”
Minister also mentioned that “productivity has increased by 11% since we began the restructuring journey four years ago.”
According to the Department of Statistics (DOS) Yearbook of Statistics 2013 – labour productivity growth was 0%, -2.6%, 1.3%, 11.1% and -3.4% for 2013, 2012, 2011, 2010 and 2009 respectively. So, how did we conclude that productivity has increased by 11% since we began the restructuring journey four years ago? In averages, should it not be 9.8% and 6.4% for the last 4 and 5 years, respectively?
Also, since PIC was introduced in Budget 2010, productivity growth following its introduction was a miserable 1.3%, -2.6% and 0%, in 2011, 2012 and 2013 respectively!
In this connection, according to former NTUC Income CEO, Mr Tan Kin Lian who spoke at the Pre-Budget 2014 Public Forum on 15 February, said: “In year of assessment 2011, a total of 57,000 companies reported a total profit of $90.4 billion, while 106,000 companies reported a total loss of $63.8 billion.”
He also said, “The number of loss making companies increased from 104,000 in 2003 to 165,000 in 2011. The average loss per company increased from $210,000 to $600,000″.
Effectiveness of Workfare
The Minister also claimed that “we are mitigating wage disparities, by using tax revenues to top up the wages in the lowest 20% through Workfare.”
Workfare only helps lower-income workers age 35 and above. Moreover, the bulk of it goes to CPF and is not paid in cash. For example, when I used the Workfare calculator for a 61 year old worker earning $1,800 – what I got was only $177 in cash for the whole year of 2013, and $261 to CPF. Can this constitute a top-up in wages?
Leong Sze Hian

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

【冠状病毒19】马国首相忧疫情再袭 或强制民众公共场合戴口罩

马来西亚的单日冠状病毒19病例重回双位数,马国首相慕尤丁通过电视直播指出,政府考虑强制民众在公共场所戴口罩。 马国当前正在进行复原行管令(PKPP)期间。慕尤丁指出,目前发现许多入境马国人士感染冠病,该国或加强入境管制。凡冠病症状入境或确诊者,都将直接送院,其余入境者也须居家隔离14天。 如有必要,该国政府计划让从国外入境国民,集中送往隔离区观察。 他指出,虽然马国疫情受到控制,但是新增13个感染群的情况,仍然令人担忧,包括在本月7日,由入境病例所引起的四个新增感染群。当天的入境病例分别有三起发生在砂拉越、五起在马六甲、吉隆坡两起及登嘉楼三起。 “此外,确诊病例也在数天前重新回到两位数了,更让我担忧。” 他呼吁民众不要对此掉以轻心,而且若确诊病例暴增,马国政府再度实施行动管制令,那么将影响马国经济和百万人民的收入。“若事情真的发生,那么包括2021年预计的国内生产总值也无法实现。” “我们必须继续疫情所带来的新生活习惯。不要因为国内确诊病例减少了,在公众场合就不戴口罩。” 他促请各领域的雇主或业者都遵守并做好标准作业程序等安全措施,校方和父母们也必须将孩子的健康安全照顾好,而各社区领袖必须照顾地区人民,到市区内如早市或巴刹进行巡逻,提醒人们保持安全社交距离、戴口罩等。“每个人都应该视自己做前线人员。” 他指出,马国民众在政府获准跨州后,已经有很多人回乡或在国内旅游了,两酒店的预订也增加了。“这是个好现象,目前经济领域都在复苏,若这种情况持续,国家经济复苏会很快。” 他补充,马国政府也已经采取各种行动,以帮助国家各阶层人士,包括拨款111.4亿令吉的国家关怀援助金(Bantuan Prihatin Nasional),让1040万人受惠;140万电召车通行证(E-Hailing)持有者获得一次性的500令吉补贴,总值达340万;44万7000名德士司机、旅车司机和把事实及则获得一次性600令吉的补助金等。…

Flat ownership transfers only allowed in certain cases: HDB

The Housing and Development Board (HDB) has implemented new restrictions for the…

Thaipusam scuffle – woman files report alleging police assault

The Singapore Police has confirmed that a police report has been filed…

NUS Campus Crusade for Christ removes insensitive and disrespectful posters

~by: Jewel Philemon~ National University of Singapore's student group NUS Campus Crusade…