maruah

Unpublished letter that was sent to Forum Page of The Straits Times

[spacer style=”1″ icon=”none”]

Dear Sir

MARUAH is deeply concerned at the closure of Breakfast Network’s website as a result of their decision not to submit the registration forms required by the Media Development Authority (MDA).

MDA had, in a statement to The Independent published on Dec 4 2013, responded to MARUAH’s earlier statement about MDA’s move to require Breakfast Network and The Independent to register, as well as the pending contempt of court charge against Mr Alex Au. In that response, MDA stated that foreign entities may not be allowed to control local media platforms; registration does not “seek to affect what The Independent and Breakfast Network can publish on their site”, similar to how MARUAH — who have also registered with MDA as a political website — has been able to freely comment on issues and policies; and registration does not prevent the two sites from receiving “bona fide commercial revenue, foreign advertisers included” and does not require the two sites to “provide detailed information of their subscriber base”.

The closure of Breakfast Network’s website demonstrates that regardless of MDA’s stated intent, the registration requirement has chilled and reduced the space for free expression in Singapore. As a regulator tasked with developing the media landscape in Singapore, MDA should consider the substantive impact of its decisions, not just its own subjective intent. Registration requirements can operate to censor free expression as effectively as, and more insidiously than, outright demands to remove content.

The forms published by Breakfast Network also show that MDA has asked them, if not The Independent, to identify every person who has provided funding to them, as well as every subscriber and advertiser who contributes 5% or more of their subscription or advertising revenue. As we stated previously, these requirements, in particular the former, are overly-intrusive and go far beyond what is necessary to satisfy the stated objective of preventing foreign influence over the media. Even the Political Donations Act, under which MARUAH has been gazetted as a political association and which also regulates political parties, does not require every person who has provided funding to be specifically identified.

Finally, MDA’s statement raises questions about its inconsistent application of policy on foreign entities in local media, given that Yahoo! Singapore, which is individually licensed by MDA, is a US-owned operation.

We again call on MDA to reverse its actions against Breakfast Network and The Independent. A thriving online media environment benefits Singapore and Singaporeans, and those actions are clearly regressive moves.

Braema Mathi (Ms)

President

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

探讨异议课程遭耶鲁-国大学院腰斩 亚菲言:异议就是说不的艺术

“如果我们就连腾出空间去倾听那些说不的人,也做不到,那么民主已死。” 据报导,耶鲁—国大学院临时取消一门名为《新加坡的异议与抵抗》的课程。有关课程将由新加坡知名剧作家亚菲言(Alfian Sa’at),与参与学生探讨本土的公民抗命模式。 有关课程原本计划在本月27日至10月5日进行,结果在开课前两周就被喊停。耶鲁—国大学院校长陈大荣教授,则在受询时向媒体解释,课程“未批判性地接触多元观点,这对于探讨围绕在异议周边的政治、社会和伦理议题,去做作妥当的学术检视是需要的”。 他续指,有关课程建议的活动和选取的讲员,也有损该校不把政党政治利益带入校园的承诺。 他也指出一些活动建议包括“可能使学生面临违法风险、或面对法律责任的元素”。 课程原本由本地剧作家亚菲言和课程经理Tan Yock Theng负责。 亚菲言对于本地时政课题向来有话直说,他著作的诗歌、剧作和短片等,也常触碰诸如政治、性别和族群等议题。 课程活动之一,包括观看独立制片人苏德祥制作“光谱行动”纪录片《1987解开阴谋》(1987: Untracing…

外交部:我国立场一致 马国已失检讨水价权利

马国外交部长赛夫丁昨日指出,根据1962年新马水供协议第14条阐明,协定在25年后应获得检討,而不是25年之內。 不过,我国外交部针对媒体提问,发文告表示,新加坡的立场始终明确、一致,即马国已经失去了检讨水价的权利。 文告也解释,目前并没有检讨水价。在去年11月12日,马国首相敦马到访,与总理针对水供协议有不同观点,他们也表示有意由两国官员进行进一步的商议,以更好地理解两国在检讨水价一事上的立场。 去年12月,两国总检察长也曾会面一事,不过因为柔佛港口界限和实里达机场ILS系统风波,讨论未取得进展。双方接下来会再次会晤,继续磋商。 “我国理解马外长赛夫丁表示,如果我国不愿谈判,马国会将此事带上国际仲裁。”较早前,马国首相马哈迪也曾说,我国不愿意这么做,是因为我国知道会败诉。 对此,外交部指出,新加坡一直以来都准好好,在双方同意的调解条件和基础上,通过合适的国际第三方来厘清纠纷。实际上,早在2003年,时任外长贾古玛就表示,我国愿意把有关纠纷交由国际仲裁庭解决。 马外长:维文言论“鲁莽” 马国外长赛夫丁是在昨日与国会驳斥维文的说法,表示对后者在国会针对水供协议作出“鲁莽”(马来语melulu)的评述,感到惊讶。 他驳斥维文指马国不尊重1962年水供协议,指马国无权在25年后检討。 他指出,水供协定第14条阐明,协定在25年后应获得检討,而不是25年之內。 “不明白维文如何诠释” “鉴于此,我不明白维文是用何种英语来诠释此事。正是因为我们尊重协定,所以我们才说马国可以在25年后检討该协定。”…

Community tribute sites for Lee Kuan Yew

Singapore residents wishing to pay their last respects to former Prime Minister Lee…

More people apply but less people get help?

Numbers do not tally. What’s going on? Leong Sze Hian.