Academics and activists agree on progress, but more focus needed on fundamental issues, says Law Minister

By Howard Lee

Civil society has progressed much in Singapore, with greater diversity of interests and willingness among groups to voice out their ideals.

This was the main message shared by speakers and participants at the Civil Society Conference yesterday organised by the Institute of Policy Studies, the first in 15 years since such a session was held.

IPS CSC 2013 pic2References were made to the comments by former Minister George Yeo, who at the first conference lamented that Singapore’s civil society landscape risked being like a banyan tree, where the shade offered by the state denies the growth of anything else beneath it.

Contrasting Yeo’s views to the situation today, participants were of the view that the government has grown more willing to engage civil society members and give space for them to grow.

Prof Walter Woon, Deputy Chairman of the Centre for International Law at the National University of Singapore, opined that there are more among the current generation of Ministers and top civil servants who have “a greater sense of fairness”, even if they cannot give in to everyone’s wishes.

The ideal of a fair society is also what most civil society groups are advocating.

IPS CSC 2013 pic5Faizah Jamal, Nominated Member of Parliament and nature advocate, also believed that it was through continued engagement with the government, speaking in a language that they are familiar with, that civil society has progressed in their causes over the years.

But speakers were also wary that this willingness to engage the government does not degenerate into the destruction of the common good for the nation.

Prof Kishore Mahbubani, Dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, cautioned that “democracies can become dysfunctional when civil society goes on a rampage”, when “civil society becomes uncivil society”. Prof Kishore did not cite any specific local examples.

Nevertheless, civil society advocates believed that continual dialogue, and faith in the civil service’s willingness to listen, is the best way to keep civil society relevant and engaged.

Alvin Tan, Artisitc Director of The Necessary Stage listed many examples where he was able to find workable solutions with government authorities, despite the sensitivities of artistic creativity.

IPS CSC 2013 pic4

Advocates also deliberated on Tan’s outline of conflict between the extreme positions of the dominant – meaning the state – and the oppositional, and how those who can give-and-take with the authorities are seen as “selling out” the cause.

But advocates present suggested that the work of civil society is a slow evolutionary process that takes time to reach maturity, and give-and-take is a necessary part of that process.

Law Minister K Shanmugam was present at the last session of the conference, and took questions about what the government is doing to assist civil society.

The Minister insisted that, despite concerns by activists, by and large, the government works well with civil society, but not every positive engagement is sexy enough to hit the newspapers. Many activities led by civil society, such as for the disadvantaged in society, receive funding from the government.

He also expressed concern that there is currently “too much naval gazing” among Singaporeans, instead of looking at more fundamental issues, such as our ageing population.

IPS CSC 2013 pic3

The Minister also reiterated that the government’s role is essentially to move the country forward economically, without which society will regress.

About 250 attended the conference, including members of civil society, academia and government officials.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

网友控诉钥匙拿不到一个月 新家墙上黑斑点点

有一名网友在社交媒体上贴文诉苦,拿到新家的锁匙入屋,但不到一个月新家墙壁既然出现黑色斑点,显然是发霉了,求解释。 建屋发展局受询及此事件时表示,可能是因为在清洗组屋单位时,墙壁上接触水分过多而导致的。 网友Newme Joyce于3月30日,在脸书账号中发文表示拿到新家锁匙,但是看到墙壁出现黑色斑点的情况,感到非常惊讶。“我都还没有开始装修”。 她在贴文中附上了照片,并且要求当局给予解释。 照片中,可以看到一部分的墙壁有水渍出现,而大部分照片都有大小不一,密集的黑色斑点出现在墙壁的下半部。 文章贴出至今已经吸引了逾700个评论,已经超过2500人转发。 质疑水管破损漏水 网友在看到有水渍的墙面时,就问到是否承包商用错了材料来上色。 有的网友则贴心的发出专业看法,表示内部浮现水渍,要看看是靠近哪里的墙壁出现水渍。如果是和厨房或浴室的,或许是水管损坏了,没有修复;但是如果不是就有可能是外墙接缝有裂痕,或者来自楼上的水渍。 网友也分享了自己的经验,并且表示一定是那里附近的水管漏水了。 他们也表示建屋发展局的官员回来调查,而屋主最终都要求他们维修受影响的部分。…

在台跳伞训练受伤全职国民服役人员,已返国接受治疗

此前因在台湾进行跳伞训练受伤的全职国民服役人员郭守杰,昨日(16日)已经由我国空军部队载送返新,在抵达我国后即送入本地医院进行治疗与复健。 新加坡武装部队发表文告,经医生鉴定后,郭守杰的伤势稳定,允许搭乘飞机返新,而新加坡空军部队在接到消息后,出动经改装的A330多用途添油运输机,将郭守杰载送回国。 郭守杰于昨日下午3点,从高雄起飞,飞行时间约4小时左右。在途中由武装部队的医疗部队伴随,密切关注郭守杰的情况。期间也未曾出现任何并发症,最后也顺利抵达我国并入院持续接受治疗。 郭守杰的家属也证实他已返回新加坡,也要求外界能够尊重他们的隐私,希望能够让国防部专注在帮助他复原。 21岁的郭守杰于年12月18日,在台湾进行一项跳伞训练时遭受颈椎受伤。事故后立即被送到当地医院,并进行手术直至隔日早晨。据了解,当天是他第五次,亦是最后一次的跳伞训练。 截至目前,郭守杰已接受了两次手术,已逐步恢复局部活动机能,意识清醒并能够与亲人对话。虽然已经恢复意识,但他还需继续接受长时间复健和物理治疗。 初步调查显示,连接飞机和降落伞的固定拉绳没拉紧,指示伤者颈部被固定拉绳打伤,惟具体原因有待进一步调查。目前已暂停所有固定拉绳式跳伞训练,待实质建议提出并落实后才得以恢复。

S11资本投资运营管理 S11榜鹅宿舍累计逾两千确诊

截至昨日(23日)中午12时,新加坡累计冠状病毒19确诊病例已破万,达1万1178例。住在宿舍的32万3000名客工中,就有9076人染病,感染率达2.81巴仙。 如今,被宪报为隔离区的客工宿舍多达25座。 其中,在本月6日被列为隔离区的实里达北连路的S11榜鹅宿舍( S11 Dormitory@Punggol)感染群,如今累计确诊客工人数已增至2千234例。 该宿舍是由S11资本投资(S11 Capital Investments)管理。回溯2016年11月份《联合早报》的报导,打着标题《照顾客工安全与福利——S11资本投资》。 内容称“一名快乐的员工,就是一名有效率的员工。客工宿舍运营公司S11资本投资秉持着这个理念,为本地客工打造完善的住宿。” S11资本投资执行董事谢志光( Jonathan Cheah),在职场人才社群网络“领英”(LinkedIn)中,形容自己具有“冒险家的内心、天生的技术怪杰、有奋斗精神”。 预计旗下两座宿舍合计带来近7千万元营收 他在2015年接受《商业时报》采访,忆述自己在2010年与商业伙伴李德强竞标政府招标Changi…

【选举】主动联系徐顺全 陈如斯有意重返民主党

原国民为先党党魁陈如斯在脸书发帖,表示已主动联系新加坡民主党秘书长徐顺全,愿意重新入党。 由陈如斯引领的国民为先党于上周四(6月25日)宣布解散后,今日(29日)在脸书上发帖,表示他愿意重新加入民主党。 他指出,我国的政府需要强而有力的反对党进行监督,并为人民发出声音。“民主党以民为主的价值观和信念,且党领导层充满活力,我在这些年也目睹了党的壮大发展,它所提供的声音正是国人所需。” 他指出,能够重新加入民主党,与他们共事并为民服务,感到非常荣幸。