The following is an extract of the transcripts of an interview held by Dr Toh Han Chong (THC) of the Singapore Medical Association News (SMA News) newsletter, with former head of the Civil Service, Mr Ngiam Tong Dow (NTD).

Read the full interview here.

THC: Lee Kuan Yew, Goh Keng Swee, Hon Sui Sen, Lim Kim San, etc, are all different in strengths and personality, what were the key qualities they possessed that helped to build this country in those early years?

NTD: Lee Kuan Yew has the ability to attract the best people in the country – Goh Keng Swee, S Rajaratnam, Toh Chin Chye, Hon Sui Sen and Lim Kim San.

Goh Keng Swee is a real thinker and very innovative. Hon Sui Sen is the perfect Permanent Secretary; he once told me, “When I look at you, I never think of your weak points. I always think of your strong points, and I use your strong points to do my work for me rather than spend day and night on your weak points.”

Of course, we need to be aware of the weak points of a person but we should always identify the strong points and develop them.

Lee Kuan Yew is the political messiah, Goh Keng Swee is the architect, Hon Sui Sen is the builder, and Lim Kim San provides business insights.

In a way, Singapore and Lee Kuan Yew were lucky to have such a team then. Sorry to say, but I don’t see such a team today.

THC: You have been very outspoken after your retirement. Is the perception that you are more outspoken now in retirement than before while in the civil service accurate?

NTD: I have always been outspoken. When I was Permanent Secretary to then Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew, he invited me for lunch twice a year, only the two of us. He was always a perfect gentleman.

He once said, “Ngiam, we’re not having lunch today as Prime Minister and Permanent Secretary. We’re both intellectual equals. You can tell me what you think, and I’ll tell you what I think.”

Those were very robust conversations.

One of these conversations involved the Certificate of Entitlement (COE) scheme. I had a big fight with him over this because the implementation of the COE scheme meant that we were taxing every man, woman and child in Singapore, from the day of his birth till the day of his death.

As COE taxes transportation, nobody can avoid it. You can avoid eating good durians, but you cannot avoid using transportation.

He saw that I was right, but he was a charmer. Looking at me, he asked, “Ngiam, are you the Permanent Secretary of the Budget and Revenue Divisions at MOF?” I said yes, to which he replied, “What’s wrong with collecting more money?”

THC: You have said that you were worried that some of the politicians today do not have the same qualities as the pioneer generation. What are you hoping to see in the newer and younger politicians today?

NTD: In the early days, Lim Kim San and Goh Keng Swee worked night and day, and they were truly dedicated. I don’t know whether Lee Kuan Yew will agree but it started going downhill when we started to raise ministers’ salaries, not even pegging them to the national salary but aligning them with the top ten.

When you raise ministers’ salaries to the point that they’re earning millions of dollar, every minister – no matter how much he wants to turn up and tell Hsien Loong off or whatever – will hesitate when he thinks of his million-dollar salary. Even if he wants to do it, his wife will stop him.

Lim Kim San used to tell me, “Ngiam, if you want to leave your job, make sure you have enough walkaway money.”

When the salary is so high, which minister dares to leave, unless they decide to become the opposition party? As a result, the entire political arena has become a civil service, and I don’t see anyone speaking up anymore.

THC: You said that there were many exchanges of ideas and even criticisms in the pioneer years of the civil service. Do you see this happening much today?

NTD: The civil service has definitely become tamer, which is not good because we need a contest of ideas. The difference is that no one wants to make a sacrifice anymore. The first generation of PAP was purely grassroots, but the problem today is that PAP is a bit too elitist.

THC: In what way do you mean are they elitist?

NTD: I think that they don’t feel for the people; overall, there is a lack of empathy.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

ICT make-up pay: Part-time workers shortchanged?

Leong Sze Hian Full-time workers who are called up for In-camp training…

“用第三世界方式对待” 许通美:一房12客工如挤沙丁鱼

昨日(5日),本地单日新增确诊暴增120例创下新高,客工宿舍感染群也引起新的隐忧。其中S11榜鹅宿舍感染群,昨日单日就新增22例,累计感染的工友多达63人。卓源东路Westlite宿舍则累计28人感染。 新加坡巡回大使许通美教授,在脸书斥责我国“以第三世界的方式”对待这些外籍客工。 “政府允许雇主以没有座位的平板罗厘载送他们。客工们住在过于拥挤的宿舍,12个人如挤沙丁鱼般住一间房。”加之卫生等问题,许通美指这些客工宿舍如同待爆发的计时炸弹。 许通美指曾见过这些客工就坐在地上吃午餐、或是精疲力竭的客工躺在地上休息,认为我国不应以可耻的方式对打他们。 至于其他新增客工宿舍感染群还包括双溪登加客工宿舍(累计四例)、回利阁感染群(八例)、高琳二号宿舍(四例)、双溪加株环道客工宿舍(三例)、淡滨尼客工宿舍(五例)以及郜林一号宿舍(二例)。 今日《海峡时报》一篇报导,指有来自S11榜鹅宿舍的客工,反映他们缺乏口罩,也住在卫生条件欠佳和过于拥挤的环境。S11榜鹅宿舍住着逾万员工。 据了解,人力部长杨莉明昨日发文表示,在员工宿舍将落实更严谨防疫措施,加强社交距离,同时计划把必要服务领域的客工转移到更合适的住宿。

此前每日越长提上班 陆交局证实一职员在马国确诊

陆路交通管理局证实,当局一名居住在马来西亚柔佛州的职员确诊感染武汉冠状病毒(COVID-19)。 《8视界》报导,该名男职员每天往返陆交局上班,而日前他的家人在马国确诊,尽管他没有出现症状,马国当局也在上周五(6日)向他发出居家通知的指令,自此后就不曾上班。 随后他也在马国确诊,目前正在柔佛州实施隔离治疗,情况良好。 目前当局已对他所在的工作地点进行彻底清理与消毒,并要求曾跟上述职员接触过的员工在家办公。目前暂未有人出现呼吸道疾病症状。