PRESS RELEASE

Private Citizen Could be Ordered to Absorb Substantial Court Costs in Public Interest Litigation

SINGAPORE, October 8, 2012– At the cost hearing today, which was heard by Justice Pillai in chambers, the Attorney General represented by David Cheong, senior counsel, pressed for legal costs to be ordered against Vellama d/o Marie Muthu.

Madam Vellama, represented by Mr M. Ravi, vigorously defended that no order should be made against the applicant on the following grounds:

I. Madam Vellama had won two out of the four applications filed when her Judicial Review application at the leave stage was a success.

II. She also succeeded in getting the Attorney General’s striking out application dismissed when the Attorney General had taken out a strike application against Justice Pillai’s decision to allow Vellama to proceed with the open court hearing.

III. It was further submitted by Mr M. Ravi that Madame Vellama should be granted a Protective Cost Order to prevent a lay-litigant from being stifled by punitive costs in cases where Constitutional Rights are at stake.

This notion of a Protective Cost Order has found its passage in South Africa; however, it is less likely to surface in countries such as the United Kingdom, New Zealand or Australia. This is because these countries not only have institutional safeguards in place but also have a culture of individual civic activism wherein the cost of a public interest litigation, such as Madame Vellema’s case, that effects the realization of rights by all citizens, are sponsored by donations from citizen philanthropists.

Justice Pillai directed both parties to submit their findings on whether there are exceptions to the general rule that the losing party pays the winning party in such cases. The justice further instructed both counsels to research Australia, New Zealand and United Kingdom judicial precedents to learn if there are common law principals developed towards such an exception.

The matter is now fixed for further hearing on Tuesday, 16 October 2012, at 10:00am.

 

M/s L F Violet Netto

You May Also Like

ST says close fight at Hong Kong polls but pro-democracy camp actually wins by landslide

On the front page of the print edition of Straits Times today…

【冠状病毒19】4月15日新增447起病例

根据卫生部文告,截至本月15日中午12时,本地新增447起病例再次创下单日新高,其中多达404新增确诊患者,都是来自客工宿舍的工作准证持有者。 工作准证持有者患者从前一周的平均48例,上周飙升至每日平均260例。 此外,本地已连续五天没有入境病例。另有38例属于本地社区感染病例,以及五名没有住宿舍的工作准证持有者。 从本月1日至14日,来自客工宿舍的确诊患者已累计1千608例。本地累计确诊病例增至3699例。 累计康复病例增至652例,目前仍有1千496例需留院治疗,大多情况稳定或有起色,其中26病重病患需待在加护病房。1千540例康复良好、惟冠毒测试呈阳性反应者,则转移到本地社区隔离设施。迄今本地已有10起死亡病例。 另一方面,一名80岁马来西亚籍男子(第3381例),在本月14日逝世后,经冠毒检测结果呈阳性。

China cannot be absent: Xi Jinping, in new year message

“The world is so big, and the problems are so many,” China’s…

Senior citizens’ return to workforce becoming “a norm” in Singapore’s ageing population: Reuters

In order to cope with rising living costs, an increasing number of…