By TR EMERITUS

You know there was this hooha on Ministry of Manpower and their ergonomic chairs right? [Link to story]

In short, they “spent almost $272,000 to buy a total of 472 Herman Miller chairs for its staff.”

One chair costs $575 – sparking public debate whether the chair is too expensive and excessive.

That was last year (under Gan Kim Yong’s time).

In a recent report, audits by Auditor-General’s Office have shown that “the Ministry of Manpower was found to have given inadequate oversight in awarding a tender for the purchase of office chairs”. [Link to story]

The audit report is online. On pg 32, it states that “the tender approving authority accepted the TER which, without showing cost-effectiveness consideration, recommended the award of tender to the highest bid. This raises doubt on the adequacy of scrutiny by the approving authority in the tender award process.”

But guess what? I was checking GeBIZ, the govt website for tendering and awarding of procurement…

And the Ministry of Manpower is not the only one buying such expensive chairs.

The Attorney-General’s Chambers procured 200 chairs at $597 each, totalling $119,400.

It was awarded on 20 March 2012 to Xtra Office Pte Ltd:

Spring Singapore too:

28 chairs at $650 each, total $18,200.

It is awarded on 1 Aug 2012, to Xtra Office Pte Ltd.

Incidentally, Xtra Office Pte Ltd is the same supplier to Ministry of Manpower in 2011.

To do more comparison, I did more digging:

Prices of office chairs at Ministries and Stat Boards      
    Price /unit Qty Total
Spring Singapore Supply of Chairs to SPRING Singapore at Connexis South $650 28 18,200
Subordinate court High Back Chairs- Supply and delivery $350 20 7,000
  Mid Back Ergonomics Chairs- supply and delivery 195 200 39,000
         
Ministry of Home Affairs-Singapore Civil Defence Force Supply and delivery of Chair Executive, Medium Backrest 165 30 4,950
         
National Environment Agency Mid-back Armchair with mesh-back support backrest 210 20 4,200
  Mid-back Armchair with mesh-back support backrest 350 20 7000
         
Public Utilities Board 4120706/3PN/Provision of Office Chairs and Delivery to Environment Building 150 17 2550
         
Ministry of National Development-Ministry Headquarter Supply and Delivery of Office Chairs 170 100 17,000
         
MCYS – Rehabilitation and Protection General Office Chairs (Corporate Service Unit) 350 13 4550
         
Attorney-General’s Chambers Tender For The Supply And Delivery Of Up To 200 Units Of Ergonomic Office Chairs To Attorney-General’s Chambers 597 200 119,400
Attorney-General’s Chambers Office Chairs (Without armrest) – up to 350 units of office chairs as indicated in Annex A 155 350 54,250

Most chairs procured by ministries and stat boards in the past 6 months are priced from $150 to $350.

All these numbers are obtained from www.gebiz.gov.sg. I just compiled them on an excel spreadsheet.

Granted, I have no idea how these office chairs look like or their differing functions/comfort levels.

But should Govt bodies purchase expensive chairs?

TOC thanks TR EMERITUS for allowing us to republish this article. The article was first published here

You May Also Like

四医生联署 呼吁全民出门戴口罩、避开聚集

本社获悉有四名医生,日前发表联署声明,呼吁全民若离开家门都要经常戴口罩,也应避免在有冷气的地方如商场或饮食中心聚集。 有关声明相信是在本月10日发布,这四名联署医生分别是:科林托马斯(Collen Thomas)、谭浩明(Tham Hoe Meng译音)、茱迪陈(译音)以及林彬彬(译音)医生。本社也成功联系上其中两位医生,也证实上述声明属实。 声明中认为,有别于2003年的SARS病毒,此次2019新冠病毒可能较难追踪,且病况轻微,一些感染者甚至不会出现任何症状,使得病毒可以神不知鬼不觉地传染他人。然而,有特定几率的病例死亡。 “体温检测似乎对于发现感染者成效不大。若他们得以与他人聚集且不戴口罩,可能每日都有人被感染而不自知。”再者,如今已知的新冠病毒死亡病例,已超过2003年的SARS病毒。 健康、感染者戴口罩形成双重保障 声明中建议所有人只要离开家都尽量戴口罩,“如果双方(健康者和感染者)都戴上口罩,可以说会比较安全,至少形成双重保障。” 不过医生们也理解如今不是每个人都买得到口罩,也建议民众可以以可清洗的布制口罩代替,缝入合适的(过滤)纸,或者围围巾包裹脸部,至少比起完全不戴口罩好。 其中一位医生科林托马斯告诉本社,目前已知47宗确诊病例,其中有7人病危,并不是一个很低的比例。“我们知道本地疫情严重程度大约是0.2、0.1,但我们仍需谨慎。” 她指出,她从医学院毕业后,也曾使用过布质口罩,故此不见得布质口罩现今无法使用。她坦言,可以理解一些人不太愿意戴口罩,因为呼吸会变得较不自然,再者此前政府也作出呼吁(即身体不适才戴)。她坦言,上述联署其中一名医生的孩子,就拒绝戴口罩,因为民众都得到这样的信息。…

Government to provide public transport vouchers for low-income households help cope with with 4.3% hike in fare or some say, 11%

Following the latest fare increase by the Public Transport Council (PTC), the…

Jobs aplenty. It’s S’poreans who aren’t “confident” enough!

In the hotel sector, front line jobs, service jobs, quite a lot…

Desmond Lee files Ministerial Motion to affirm commitment on affordable public housing in Singapore

SINGAPORE — The National Development Minister, Mr Desmond Lee, has filed a…