~ by Atticus ~

Photo credit: The Straits Times, Lua Jiamin

The Attorney-General’s Chambers (AGC) has denied any link between the politically charged academic publications of NUS Law Faculty’s Associate Professor Tey Tsun Hang and the prosecution against him for corruption for allegedly sleeping with law student Darinne Ko in return for improving her grades. 

In response to media queries, the AGC said in an emailed statement:

“There is no link between these charges and Mr. Tey’s academic publications and writing,”.

Speculation started after Prof Tey said in a statement to the press:

“I am known to speak up, amongst other things on the Singapore legal system”. He further went on to state that his writings are in good faith with no ill intent and his defense will be in a similar vein.

Despite being mainly an academic specializing in equity and trusts, Prof Tey has also been known to publish articles containing critiques of the Singapore political system.

Recently, a blog has been started that has republished some of Professor Tey’s more politically charged articles. 

Prof Tey obtained first class honours from Oxford University and practised law in Malaysia before being hired by then Dean of the Faculty of Law Professor Chin Tet Yung to teach at NUS Law faculty. 

Subsequently, Prof Tey left academia to enter the legal service in the Supreme Court as a Justice Law Clerk during the tenure of the then Chief Justice Yong Pung How. 

Prof Tey subsequently left to practice in the top litigation firm in Singapore, attaining the rank of Associate Director. 

Prof Tey then went on to become a District Judge, after which he returned to academia at NUS Law Faculty. 

The recently started blog, entitled “Singapore Consensus”, collates the writings of Prof Tey, a Malaysian citizen, that are directly critical of the Singaporean legal system. 

In a 2010 article entitled “Judicial Internalising of Singapore’s Supreme Political Ideology” published in the Hong Kong Law Journal, Tey argued that “Right from the beginning of Singapore’s nationhood, an obvious and unbridgeable disconnect appeared – between its leadership’s political ideology and the aspirations on human rights and constitutionalism of its legal community. 

In another article published in 2010 in the Hong Kong Law Journal entitled “Criminalising Critique of the Singapore Judiciary”, Tey argued:

“The ruling People’s Action Party (PAP) of Singapore legitimises its authoritarian political regime – and insulates it from substantive scrutiny – via a three-pronged strategy: first, through its tightly controlled media and communications channels; secondly, by delivering an admirable economic performance and, creating and maintaining an awe-inspiring standard of living; and thirdly – and most importantly – through its legal institutions. However, there are profound logical flaws and stark absences of consistency in the judgments that help secure this legal state of affairs”. 

The other articles Professor Tey has written in a similar vein are likewise equally critical of the Singaporean political and judicial system. 

One of his articles is titled “Death Penalty Singapore-Style: Clinical and Carefree”.

In this article, Prof Tey argues that “Singapore has developed a jurisprudence that death penalty and capital proceedings are no different from other minor criminal proceedings. Instead of scrutinising criminal legislation on their substantive fairness, the courts have instead consistently restricted their adjudicative function to one of procedural assessment. In so doing, formalistic and textualist techniques are employed to achieve crime control ends at considerable expense of due process”.

In another article dealing more directly with the political system in Singapore titled “Singapore’s electoral system: government by the people?”, Prof Tey critiques the Singapore deviation from the Westminster political model as follows: 

“In its post-independence constitutional development, the dominant People’s Action Party political leadership had made a series of constitutional amendments to its original electoral system, introducing innovative schemes such as Group Representation Constituencies, Non-Constituency Members of Parliament, Nominated Members of Parliament and the Elected Presidency.

These changes have resulted in an electoral system that is so different and divergent from the Westminster model that it should be regarded a unique regime of its own. This paper advances the view that the constitutional evolution of its electoral system is reflective of a political vision structured along elitist lines – underscored by a desire to restructure the voting behaviour of its citizens, and ensure predictability and the preservation of the status quo. It has been driven by paternalistic assumptions about what is beneficial for its citizens.”

In light of questions Yale University faculty have raised about academic freedom in Singapore, the AGC’s next steps to ensure that the case of PP v Tey Tsun Hang is not perceived as political persecution will probably be almost as important as securing a conviction against Prof Tey.  

 

You May Also Like

网友社媒揭妹妹遭同学霸凌 王乙康促校方采取适当行动

一名姐姐在社媒上揭发妹妹遭到学校霸凌,在生日当天收到同学们丢来语带讽刺的纸条,并表示这并非其妹妹首次受到霸凌,引起教育部长的关注,要求校方采取行动。 署名batakab的网友于本月6日,在推特帖文指出其妹妹在生日当天,收到来自同学们写着讥讽话语的字条,更声称那是给妹妹的生日礼物。 my heart broke today, it was my sister’s birthday yesterday…

Minister of Finance rejects TOC's application to cancel POFMA correction direction on its article that reported on Taiwan news coverage of Ho Ching's pay

The Ministry for Finance in an email to TOC on Tuesday late…

AWARE:老年照顾均有女性承担 经济负担庞大

随着我国迈入老化社会,老人长期照护工作成社会必须正视的问题。本地性别平权组织,妇女行动与研究协会(AWARE)表示,大部分老人长期照护工作全交由家中女性照顾者负责,主要原因包括外劳对医疗照护知识的限制,加之正式照护系统未充分善用,造成女性负担增加。 AWARE 近日释出一项报告,其报告邀请22个家庭中的老年照顾者与22位来自学界、医疗专业、照护系统工作人员、以及家居与社区资源服务工作者进行深度质性访谈。 报告指出,大部分老年照顾工作落在女性身上,据2016至2018年的劳动力调查,因家庭责任而离职的女性,增长了9巴仙,从26万3000增长至28万6500。 杜克-国大医学院资深研究员Rahul Malhotra博士也指出,2011年的一项相关调查发现,大部分75以上的老年人均由女性照顾,其中大多数为老年人的女儿、媳妇或妻子。 他表示,“根据研究所显示,我认为在照顾系统方面仍存在性别偏见”。Malhotra博士解释,这是因为亚洲社会包括新加坡所存在的传统价值观,在亚洲社会,无论是小孩或是老年人的照护工作通常都交由女性进行。 他也指出,目前正在进行一项相关议题的大范围量化调查,其初步结果显示老年人的主要照顾者仍以女性居多。 长期照护工作影响女性就职与经济状况 据报告指出,照顾者一旦增加其照护工作的时间,对照顾者的职业状态产生若干影响,而且由减少工作时数逐渐变成完全退出工作,因此也影响了照顾者的经济状况。 由此而言,很多女性在失去工作后,等同失去收入与贡献公积金的能力,许多受访者认为他们至少损失了63巴仙的收入,意味着每年约损失5万6877新元。 另外,高额医疗费用增加每月开销,根据报告指出,要照顾一个三项日常生活活动无法自理人士(Activities…

闯幼园彩排现场 男子持刀与警对峙被捕

本周一,网民Muhammad Raihan在脸书分享视频,指一名身穿灰衣的小偷,手持小刀闯入组屋的综合亭中,与七名便衣警员对峙,最终被逮捕。 网民莱罕指事件发生兀兰坡组屋,从视频中可见综合亭内还设置了投影银幕和扩音器,因为当时还有一群幼稚园孩童在那里进行国庆日活动彩排。 莱罕指所幸幼园老师把孩童们都待会校园,也没有人被挟持为人质和伤亡。 视频中显示七名相信是便衣警员的男子,将一名手持小刀的男子包围,可见他其中熟人手持警棍。在对峙了片刻后,灰衣男子最终被劝服扔掉了小刀,其中一人赶紧把掉落在地上的小刀踢开,另两人则趋前逮捕已趴在地上的灰衣男。 而警方较后也向媒体证实,在本周一(29日)上午11时许在兀兰坡展开执法行动,逮捕一名涉嫌偷窃的55岁男子,目前案件仍在调查中。