~by Atticus ~

The Government has proposed amendments to abolish certain mandatory provisions in the Misuse of Drugs Act.

The proposals will make drug trafficking offenses by drug mules no longer punishable with a mandatory death penalty, but will instead provide discretion for the courts to provide a term of life imprisonment with caning provided that the drug mule cooperates substantively with the Central Narcotics Bureau.

The exception will only apply if the drug mule is not involved in the supply or distribution of the drugs, but only acted as the courier.

The amendments will also provide for discretion in cases where the courier has a mental disability which substantively impairs his appreciation of the gravity of the act.

Under the current regime it is mandatory for Courts to sentence a drug courier caught with specified amounts of Class A drugs to death regardless of his personal circumstances.

This has been criticised by activists and opposition political parties as unduly binding the hands of the judiciary, and has been the subject of several constitutional challenges by constitutional lawyer M Ravi.

TOC has previously, in several editorials, called for the abolition of the mandatory death penalty and highlighted the case of young drug mule Yong Vui Kong.

In an editorial of 24 February 2010, we wrote:

The mandatory death penalty for drug trafficking is particularly egregious for several reasons.  First, it lacks a sense of proportionality. A young unwitting drug mule (a typical profile of those arrested for trafficking) caught with 30 grams of morphine, for example, gets no more sentencing consideration than a serial killer, while this does nothing to deter the real traffickers who put him up to it.  Second, the defendant is saddled with an unusually onerous burden of proof: if caught in possession of a drug, he is automatically presumed to be responsible for it and to know its nature, and if caught with a certain amount he is alleged to be trafficking.

Anti-death penalty activists TOC spoke to were happy but indicated that further dialogue on the issue of the death penalty was necessary.

Rachel Zeng of the Singapore anti-death Penalty Campaign told TOC:

“Whatever the reasons the government has, I thank them for making this step and would like to extend an invitation to the relevant authorities to consider engaging with us in dialogue or discussions over the possibilities of replacing the death penalty with alternative methods of persucution which may be more humane.”

Activist and film-maker Lynn Lee, who has extensively covered the case of Yong Vui Kong, said that she was pleased but many questions remained for the government to answer.

Once legislation has been put in place, all accused persons who meet the requirements can elect to be considered for resentencing under the new law. This will include accused persons in ongoing cases, as well as convicted persons who have already exhausted their appeals and are currently awaiting execution.

 

You May Also Like

Mixed reactions from public over increase of monthly NS allowance for all NSFs and NSmen

While speaking in Parliament on Monday (2 March), Senior Minister of State…

180 new cases of COVID-19 infection in S’pore; 177 locally transmitted cases, 90 unlinked

As of Wednesday noon (1 Sep), the Ministry of Health (MOH) has…

仅2巴仙公积金存款未提领 公积金局拟推出电子提名

人力部长杨莉明今天(11月4日)在国会上指出,仅有2巴仙的公积金储蓄未被提取;其余过世会员的公积金存款都由中央公积金局或公共信托局(PTO)分发给家属。 截止去年年杪,在公共信托局中类似的2.11亿元无人领取资金中,有1.32亿元是来自公积金局会员。 杨莉明指出,大部分公积金已故会员都有指定受益人,因此他们的资金都会在公积金局获得相关会员死亡通知后,于一个月内完成派发。 她是在受询及无人认领的公积金详情、用于减少相关金额的方法,以及当局是否考虑改变受益人提名手续的相关事宜时,如是指出。 促请合格者尽早申请提款 她指出,就算没有指名受益人,公积金局也能根据《无遗嘱继承法令》或穆斯林的《继承证书》,将死者的剩余公积金分配给其近亲。 “公积金局通常会在接获会员死亡通知后,将已故会员的公积金转入公共信托局,然后追踪和寻找会员的亲属。” 律政部兼卫生部高级政务部长唐振辉在详细说明有关程序时指出,“公共信托局将会联系和已故公积金会员遗产有关的人士,并促请他们进行索取这未指明受益人的款项”。这些人士包括了向公积金局投报会员死亡的知会者,以及移民和关卡局中记录的已故会员家属。 唐振辉指出,为了确保已故会员的“遗产”能够交到对的人手中,公共信托局会要求申请者出示受理证件,以证明其申请和资格。若有必要,当局还会通过代表申请人的方式,想相关单位提出申请或要求有关的资料文件。 他指出,在过去五年来,公共信托局已成功在过去五年,已经将88巴仙无人认领的会员“遗产”分发出去。“当局将会继续寻找具合法资格受益人的工作,包括进行家访。由于没有时间限制,也鼓励具备合法资格的人士进行申请。” 去年受理申请近12万份 为了使公积金局会员更容易进行提名手续,杨莉明指出,当局正探讨着在明年首季推出新的电子提名系统。目前,公积金成员可以到当局的服务柜台,或通过邮寄方式进行受益人提名手续。…