~by Atticus ~

The Government has proposed amendments to abolish certain mandatory provisions in the Misuse of Drugs Act.

The proposals will make drug trafficking offenses by drug mules no longer punishable with a mandatory death penalty, but will instead provide discretion for the courts to provide a term of life imprisonment with caning provided that the drug mule cooperates substantively with the Central Narcotics Bureau.

The exception will only apply if the drug mule is not involved in the supply or distribution of the drugs, but only acted as the courier.

The amendments will also provide for discretion in cases where the courier has a mental disability which substantively impairs his appreciation of the gravity of the act.

Under the current regime it is mandatory for Courts to sentence a drug courier caught with specified amounts of Class A drugs to death regardless of his personal circumstances.

This has been criticised by activists and opposition political parties as unduly binding the hands of the judiciary, and has been the subject of several constitutional challenges by constitutional lawyer M Ravi.

TOC has previously, in several editorials, called for the abolition of the mandatory death penalty and highlighted the case of young drug mule Yong Vui Kong.

In an editorial of 24 February 2010, we wrote:

The mandatory death penalty for drug trafficking is particularly egregious for several reasons.  First, it lacks a sense of proportionality. A young unwitting drug mule (a typical profile of those arrested for trafficking) caught with 30 grams of morphine, for example, gets no more sentencing consideration than a serial killer, while this does nothing to deter the real traffickers who put him up to it.  Second, the defendant is saddled with an unusually onerous burden of proof: if caught in possession of a drug, he is automatically presumed to be responsible for it and to know its nature, and if caught with a certain amount he is alleged to be trafficking.

Anti-death penalty activists TOC spoke to were happy but indicated that further dialogue on the issue of the death penalty was necessary.

Rachel Zeng of the Singapore anti-death Penalty Campaign told TOC:

“Whatever the reasons the government has, I thank them for making this step and would like to extend an invitation to the relevant authorities to consider engaging with us in dialogue or discussions over the possibilities of replacing the death penalty with alternative methods of persucution which may be more humane.”

Activist and film-maker Lynn Lee, who has extensively covered the case of Yong Vui Kong, said that she was pleased but many questions remained for the government to answer.

Once legislation has been put in place, all accused persons who meet the requirements can elect to be considered for resentencing under the new law. This will include accused persons in ongoing cases, as well as convicted persons who have already exhausted their appeals and are currently awaiting execution.

 

You May Also Like

新邮政下周三起发售鼠年肖像邮票

集邮迷看过来!为了迎接鼠年,鼠年肖像邮票即将在下周三(8日)开始发售。 新邮政于今日(2日)发文告表示,自8日起,即将开始售出鼠年的邮票,其生肖邮票系列中含两种不同的鼠型插图,价格约0.30元吉1.40元。 新邮政表示,将会特别印制预销首日生肖鼠邮戳(Pre-cancelled First Day Cover)全套邮票,其售价为3.10元,包含两枚邮票的展示包则售价为4.15元。 生肖邮票系列意味着新邮政的12年周期的结束与开始,标志着新邮政迎接未来12年的象征,未来将以生肖作为设计风格。新邮政也表示在接下来的日子直至2031年,均将沿用十二生肖的邮票。 该系列邀请动画师兼插画家Lim An-Ling设计,她也曾为2019年新加坡开埠两百年设计纪念邮票。 此外,新邮政也发行了一系列纪念邮票,包括10元的集邮品,其风格以中国传统剪纸风格呈现,并连同红包与MyStamp鼠主题的产品,放入充满中国色彩的文件夹内,内有8个红包内,售价为18.80元。 为了能早日迎接农历新年,新邮政也以出席团圆晚餐作为其特色,发行限量版微型邮票,价格为8.55元,于1月24日开始发售。 同时新邮政也将在1月23日至2月1日“春到河畔2020”间,于…

警方对辣玉莎贴文给予严重警告 惟不对网红“夏雪”采取行动

因两年前评论城市丰收教会判决,工人党盛港集选区议员辣玉莎在本届大选竞选期间,被举报言论涉种族主义,结果被警方调查。 警方今日(17日)发表声明,指出经过调查,辣玉莎在2018年2月2日和今年5月17日发表的网络评论,“有意挑起不同族群间敌意”,抵触触刑事法典第298A(a)条文。 而有关评论城市丰收教会判决的贴文,也因藐视法庭而抵触司法维护法令(Administration of Justice(Protection)Act)。 警方称经过于总检察署商讨后,决定给予辣玉莎严厉警告。 针对城市丰收教会判决,辣玉莎曾批评新加坡无情监禁少数群体、骚扰清真寺领袖,但容许涉贪教会领袖逍遥法外。同时,在社媒也评论新加坡执法机构,涉歧视公民,指富有华人和白人有不同待遇。 然而,在选举期间,遭民众举报涉族群言论的并不仅是辣玉莎一人。本地网红“下雪”也同样被人“翻旧账”,十年前的推特(Twitter)贴文,也被人举报而被警方调查。 事实上,当辣玉莎在选举期间卷入族群言论风波,原名郑彦彦的“下雪”。还曾在社交媒体Instagram抨击辣玉莎的言论,是指控大部分华人在法律上会选边站,也似乎意指本地执法机构由华人掌控。她质问辣玉莎是否适合成为候选人: 郑彦彦被一名网民Vignesh Sankar Iyer,找到她在2010年发布于Twitter的推文,指她的言论也涉嫌种族歧视,向警方报案。…

Ex-Reform Party chairman denies ouster

Ng Teck Siong said he resigned voluntarily. Report by Andrew Loh.

Worker’s Party seeks feedback on Redundancy Insurance scheme to help workers made redundant

The Worker’s Party (WP) proposes its Redundancy Insurance (RI) scheme to ease the…