~by: Ghui~

Comments that there is no common identity amongst Singaporeans or that Singaporeans are not patriotic enough are not new. A lack of national unity has been blamed on the influx of foreigners, foreign athletes “imported” by the government to don our national colours at sports meets, the identity card which segregates us by our ethnic races as opposed to a focus on our shared “Singaporeaness” and the list goes on.

Former President SR Nathan has said that “it would take “one or two generations” before a common culture emerged” and I wonder if more effort can be made to reduce that time frame cited by Mr Nathan?

Singapore is a new country and many of its older citizens would have hailed from other countries such as India or China. In that respect, a national identity is not ingrained and needs time to grow. But is that really a justifiable excuse fifty years on? 

Singaporeans of all races have gone through much together. We fought and died side by side in World War II. We went through the racial riots in the 50s and came out on the other side together. We overcame the Sukarno saboteurs unified. We were a part of Malaysia and kicked out as one. Is that not enough to foster a national identity? 

I do not think that Singapore being a young nation has that much to do with a lack of national identity. However, I do believe that there is a factor which contributes much more to its erosion – a lack of memories.

Shared memories hold people together and significant places help to preserve that precious recollection. Take those places away and the remembrance fades. People get caught up with life’s cares and we forget what we have been through together as a people.

The shutdown of the MacDonald’s outlet in East Coast brought back a wave of memories for me and judging by the comments that people have made, they too mourn its demise (see HERE).  

People have lamented that many of their childhood memories were made in that Macdonald’s outlet and that its loss was akin to a destruction of part of their childhood. A couple even commented that their courtship began there. Perhaps, the loss of a MacDonald’s outlet is a small price to pay for development but the point I am trying to make is the destruction of something that built commonality for Singaporeans.

The same can be said of the closing of Clifford Pier in 2006. Many saw that closure as the end of an era and its demise adieu to a romantic past. Perhaps this is melodramatic in the wake of new development and swanky new restaurants but again, this demolition disintegrates the reminiscences of many.

There are many more examples that I can cite but for the sake of brevity, I shall stop at these two.

Ties are formed through shared experiences and those bonds are kept in place by memories. So, if all the fond memories that people have of Singapore are taken away, a feeling of disconnect sets in and with that comes an inability to feel a part of the country.

I am not blaming the government for trying to rebuild. Some rejuvenation is of course always necessary. But is redevelopment on such a massive scale really required? Singapore seems to be constantly under construction!

Is bulldoze and rebuild always the right strategy? While “out with the old and in with the new” may be good for the creation of a sparkling city, is it good for developing common memories? Does it help with building a common national identity?

 

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Seeing Stars: Uniquely Singapore – Progress

Leong Sze Hian takes a look at “progress” on National Day.

亲生父母涉虐死五岁儿 死者头部伤痕或源自猫笼

将一名1.05米的5岁男童,困在放置于住家单位内,只有91厘米长、58厘米宽、70厘米高的铁丝猫笼中,实在令人发指。而这行为仅仅是那5岁孩童的亲生父母,用于“管住”他的众多恐怖手法之一。 而这个铁丝猫笼,也成为了呈堂证据。 男童在被发现时,臀部和大腿上有曾被钳子反复夹伤的痕迹,其头部、手和腿有被扫帚等物打伤的痕迹,甚至遭到近乎沸腾热水烫伤身体。 最终,男童昏倒并被送入竹脚妇幼医院(KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital),发现他身上伤痕累累,包括有急性肾损伤、脸部多处撕裂伤、鼻骨骨折以及覆盖身体大部分面积的严重烧伤。 虽然院方尽力挽救这个年轻的生命,但是男童还是在入院的隔天,即2016年10月23日过世。 显示多个器官衰竭迹象 男童的父母,利兹万(Ridzuan Mega…

罗拔申码头昨发生坠河事故 民众立即抛救生圈救女郎

罗拔申码头昨天(6月3日)傍晚约6时许,发生坠河事故,一名女郎被民众发现,在新加坡河河面载浮载沉,立即有人抛下救生圈,让女子捉住。 据目击者表示,较后民防人员赶到,把梯级伸入水中,并救起该名女子。她也被送往新加坡中央医院。