~By: Jen~

I am very disturbed by the new Edusave Character Award scheme by the Ministry of Education to reward good character in students with hard cold cash. This award according to MOE’s Minister Heng Swee Keat, is to recognise students who exhibit values such as respect and who demonstrate exemplary civic responsibility through their behaviour and actions.

I am all for cultivating good values, but to actually have a scheme to give money to students for doing and being good just goes against the grain of what it means to be a good person. I believe most of us were taught by our parents to be good and to do good not for reward, but because, it is good for us and society in general. Isn’t this a universal principle?

Yet, now we have this pay-money-for-good-behaviour scheme. What exactly were our education minister and the ministry thinking? What values are they trying to inculcate in our impressionable young? That it literally has to ‘pay’ to do ‘good?’

As it is there are already so many award schemes at schools that pay cash to reward students. The Edusave Awards for Achievement, Good Leadership and Service (Eagles) and bursaries for most improved in school grades (which some kids have learnt to game the system to make money by deliberately doing badly in first half of the year).

I believe using reward as a motivator can be useful and good, but it cannot be the easy way out and cash should not be used in certain situations. Whatever happened to the good old days when reward meant getting a good book? Okay, maybe not a book in today’s internet age, but surely MOE can come out with more creative ways of motivation than just cash.

One cannot help, but wonder, if there is a political agenda behind the Edusave Character Award scheme that comes post-haste after GE2011. Based on Mr Heng’s comments in Parliament, he said such a scheme is not just to drive home the importance of character building among the young but it is to “ultimately, prepare them for a world of unknowns… It is more about how to process information, discern truths from untruths, connect seemingly disparate dots and create knowledge even as the context changes…”

Read Mr Heng’s quote again and one wonders how to connect the disparate dots between what he said with the new character building award. If one were to read between the lines or dots, it sounds like it may be part of a plan to mold young minds in a certain way so that it is aligned with the thinking of the PAP’s values. Shape the young so they can be “reasonable” and “speak with reason” in line with their definition of reasoning and make sure the kids here do not grow up to be the vocal “lunatic fringe”?

It will be interesting to know what criterion is used by MOE to judge if a student has good character and values. Will it be considered good character if a student is an activist who criticises a government policy because he or she views it as questionable and detrimental to the people? One wonders.

Despite all the initial signs shown by the PAP during GE2011 that they will try to be more understanding and open-minded, some of their actions post GE like introducing this Edusave Character Scheme leaves a bad taste in the mouth. This scheme is regressive as it smacks of political manipulation to shape young minds and teaches the wrong values of paying cash to reward good behaviour. As it is, Singaporeans are already being accused of being too money minded and here they go teaching our young the wrong values. Seriously, what is our government thinking?

 


This article first appeared on Jentrified Citizen. We thank Jen for allowing us to reproduce it here.

 

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

NSP sec gen weighs in on Nicole Seah controversy

Andrew Loh / The following is an excerpt from Mr Goh Meng…

A hub is not a home

The following is an excerpt of a letter published on March 4,…

李显龙:未来十年逐步调高退休和重新雇佣年龄

新加坡总理李显龙于今日(18日)傍晚,在宏茂桥工艺教育学院,发表国庆群众大会演说。其中他确认已收到年长员工劳资政工作小组建议,政府将在2021年迈出第一步,在未来十年逐步把退休年龄和重新雇佣年龄,分别调高至65岁和70岁。 他在致词时提及,去年,人力部设立了年长雇员劳资政工作小组,而上月他和小组成员一起吃午餐,即便午餐期间也能感受到组员激烈讨论,特别是雇主、年长雇员都有个资考量,年长员工希望确认能受聘更久,但雇主们担心营运成本及经济前景,希望政策有更大的灵活性。 他透露,工作小组提出四项建议,即:把退休年龄从现有62岁提高至65岁;重新雇佣年龄从67岁提高到70岁;增加年长者公积金缴交率。以及,放眼在2030年前,逐步实现上述建议。 “我觉得这些都是合理建议,政府全盘接受。” 他首先解释公积金缴交率,指目前的公积金缴交率在员工满55岁时开始下降。而政府将提高55岁以上员工的公积金缴交率。 总理透露,政府将在2021年迈出第一步,之后还会有后续行动;整个改变过程将长达约10年,不过会依据经济情况而定。 等到完成时,那些60岁或以下雇员将是全额的公积金缴交率。届时,公积金缴交率只会在60岁后才开始下降,并在70岁后持平。 不过他重申,政府对提取公积金的政策或提取公积金的年龄没有任何调整,国人仍可在55岁时取出一些钱,并从65岁起领取公积金入息,这些都和以前一样。 “如果有人告诉你不一样的消息,那是误导假新闻,到时会被《防假消息法》对付”。 到了2022年,将逐步调高退休和重新雇佣年龄。退休年龄将在2022年从62岁提高至63岁,并在2030年提高至65岁。 至于退休年龄将在2022年从62岁提高至63岁,并在2030年提高至65岁。 总理透露,政府将实行一个援助配套,帮助业界适应这些新调整,具体政策将由副总理王瑞杰在明年的财政预算案中公布。至于政府作为全国最大的雇主,将率先带来公务员,在在2021年提高退休及重新雇佣年龄,藉此鼓励私人界效仿。…

涉假冒中国政府官员 警今年接获逾400宗诈骗案

警方数据显示,警方自今年初至11月,一共接获401宗涉及假冒中国政府官员的诈骗案件,导致受害人损失了至少1880万新元。 仅仅下半年8月至11月就占了242宗案件,涉案款项高达1080万新元。 警方于上周五(13日)指出,类似案件在今年下半年剧增,而在今年1月至5月期间,警方也接获多达92起类似诈骗案件的投报。 当局指出,骗子通常会假冒快递公司、电信服务供应商或政府官员的职员,对受害者行骗。 他们的套路多数是:指受害者所注册的手机号码涉及罪案、或他们扣查了注明受害者为收货人士,装有非法物品的包裹、或有针对受害者的法庭案件、又或者指受害者涉及刑事案件,需要协助调查。 然后,骗子就会以为了方便调查,要求受害者提供网上银行户口的个人资料,以及一次性密码(OTP)。 甚至在一些情况下,他们还会将有关电话转接给另一名自称是“中国保安(或警察)”的人士。 骗子会向受害者展示“中国保安”所持有的逮捕令副本,并威胁受害者,若不配合调查将会有牢狱之灾。 受害者在提供了有关个资后,不久就会发现他们银行账户内的资金,已经被转账到未知账户了。 有的骗子会采用另外一种方式,即让受害者扫描一个二维码(QR Code),然后使用比特币自动贩卖机转移款项。 在某些情况下,受害者会被要求自银行账户中提款,然后转交给假政府官员,已进行审核。…