The following is an excerpt from Yawning Bread.

The Straits Times did the right thing to put the story on the front page, for it is a very serious case.

Ismil Kadar was acquitted of murder by the Court of Appeal after spending six years in jail facing the death penalty. The judges slammed the police investigators and the prosecution for more than sloppiness in building the case against him, questioning their motives as well.

Ismil and his brother Muhamad Kadar had been found guilty of murder by common intention in the 2005 killing of an elderly woman, Tham Weng Kuen, 69, while robbing her home. Her bedridden husband was in the flat as it happened, fully aware of what was happening but unable to help his wife.

Describing the case as ‘extraordinary’, Justice V. K. Rajah said the 42-year-old’s confessions were obtained ‘in troubling circumstances’ which appeared to be deliberate breaches in procedures rather than mere carelessness.

He added that investigators had been ‘less than thorough’ and said there was a ‘startling lack of any objective evidence’ that tied Mr Ismil to the crime.

– Straits Times, 6 July 2011, Man accused of murder freed after 6 years in jail, by Selina Lum

The judges also noted that there was a witness statement from the bedridden husband that there was only one intruder — and he had a sightline to the front door from his bed — which was suppressed by the prosecution until the very last minute and then dismissed  by the trial court when it would have exonerated at least one, if not both the brothers.

Continue reading here.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

蔡厝港械斗事件:13人被逮捕,五人被控上法庭

日前,蔡厝港德惠巷101座組屋附近发生可怕械斗事件,反恐紧急应对部队出动,警方将13名嫌疑人逮捕归案。该13名嫌疑人于2月29日被控上法庭,而第14名嫌疑人在近日被逮捕后,于今日(4日)被起诉。 事发当时,两群人正在械斗,其中一群人含至少八人,手握刀和手杖,而另一群则至少有5人,携带巴朗刀(Parang),双方正在互相殴打。 由于当时大批人员正在械斗,附近的居民也纷纷将其拍下,甚至录影,有目击者拍到当时有一群人正对着一名男子殴打,也有目击者拍到当时嫌疑人正在组屋下四处走动并大声叫嚣。 随后,警方便全副武装抵达现场,准备缉拿闹事者。 事发后,一名自称是伤者妹妹的人表示,自己的哥哥的尾指已经断了,并拍下视频,以马来文表示,“是谁将我哥哥的手指砍断,我一定把你揪出来,你给我小心点。”视频显示,那名男子的手掌被开了道很深的口子,血流如注。 2月29日,13名嫌疑人均被控上法庭,包括两名18岁的少年法汗、海克尔,以及20岁的罗斯兰被指使用致命武器闹事,违反刑事法典第148条,一旦罪成,将可被判最高10年加鞭苔。 而另两名则是18岁的萨法力与17岁的扎希鲁丁,被指非法集会与携带致命武器,若罪成,将可判处最高五年监禁或罚款。 而第14名嫌疑人赫尔米则被指违反《腐蚀性、爆炸性物质及进攻性武器法》,一旦罪成,将可判处最高三年以上监禁,和至少鞭苔六下。 五名嫌疑人今日也随同警方重返现场,讲述事情经过。 目前案件仍在侦办中,以确定其余8人或更多嫌疑人涉案。

HDB – S’poreans’ billions of ‘reserves’ raided?

Leong Sze Hian / I refer to the reports “WP rebuts Minister’s…

Teen receives S$225,000 payout after suffering cardiac arrest following vaccine jab

Having suffered a cardiac arrest after his first COVID-19 vaccine jab, a…

国家发展部:白沙榜鹅市镇会诉讼 也将由盛港市镇会接手

昨日(22日),国家发展部指随着榜鹅东区纳入盛港市镇理事会,白沙-榜鹅市镇会(PRPTC)诉讼也将移交给盛港市镇会。 该部是在本月13日,致函所有议员,限17日回复有关成立市镇会、委任市镇会主席等事宜。早前盛港集选区候任议员何廷儒,表示已联系国家发展部,表明有意自行管理盛港市镇会,预料将由她出任盛港市镇会主席。 2018年10月初,高庭展开对工人党市镇会诉讼审讯,阿裕尼—后港市镇会(AHTC)和白沙—榜鹅市镇会(PRPTC)指责工人党刘程强、林瑞莲、毕丹星等八造,必须对2011年5月至2015年11月期间,对第三方承包商的不当付款行为负起责任,并索偿3371万元。 高庭在去年10月11日判决,工人党议员林瑞莲等人,需为阿裕尼-后港市镇会蒙受损失,承担法律责任。诉辩双方都对判决提出上诉,不过目前已被展延至八月审理。 工人党在2013年补选中赢得榜鹅东单选区(Punggol East),该党组成阿裕尼-后港-榜鹅东市镇会(AHPETC)。   白沙—榜鹅市镇会诉讼回顾: 2015年3月21日:国家发展部委任独立会计师审查阿裕尼-后港-榜鹅东市镇会支出。 9月1日:阿裕尼-后港-榜鹅东市镇会准时提交2014/2015财政年度财务和审计报告。市镇会原主席林瑞莲称,市镇会虽出现年度亏损,但纳入国家发展部未发放的720万元津贴,仍有170万元盈余。