Kirsten Han /

As a little girl (and even now), I loved listening to my grandfather’s stories of his childhood and old Singapore. In the telling of these stories, he would often mention his parents – how close he was to his mother and how the children were all intimidated by his father.

I don’t know why, but it never actually occurred to me to ask where my great-grandparents were buried. I only found out last week, when I called my grandfather to ask if he knew anyone with relatives buried at Bukit Brown, which has been gazetted for development by the Urban Redevelopment Authority (URA).

“Of course I know someone,” he said. “Me.”

Not only are my grandfather’s parents buried in Bukit Brown, but also his maternal grandparents’. However, no one in our family can remember where my great-great-grandparents’ graves are anymore.

L - R: My mother, my grandfather and my cousin

Last Sunday my mother, my grandfather, our cousin and I took a trip to Bukit Brown. It was the first time in a long time that my grandfather had been to visit his parents’ graves. My mother had been once as a child, and I never at all. Our cousin would visit once or twice a year, and came to show us the way.

We drove deep into Bukit Brown, to the end of the road. Then we got out and had to walk up the hill. My grandfather was determined not to be left out but, at 86 years of age, he was panting and worn out halfway up. If he went up any further, it would be difficult for him to come back down, so my mother put her foot down and said that she would take him back to the car.

In Loving Memory

“Mrs Neo Pee Wan, died 26th April 1939, aged 47. Mr Neo Pee Wan, died 14th February 1958, aged 70.”

I stood staring at the gravestone, not quite knowing how to feel. These were my relatives, my family. Without them, I would not have my grandfather. I myself would not be alive. It was a little difficult to feel a connection, because I couldn’t picture them at all. I had never seen any photographs of my great-grandparents.

But I remember the stories my grandfather told me about them. About how his mother was an extremely musical woman with a “substantive lap” that he “rolled around on” as a child, and how his dad safeguarded his company’s money from the Japanese during the war (the amount of money involved increases with every retelling).

I also know how they died: my great-grandfather had a heart attack while combing his grandson’s hair. My grandfather went into the room after hearing the boy’s screaming, carried him to the sofa and was holding him when he died.

My great-grandmother died young. The doctor said it was hemorrhagic fever. “We stood around the bed and she was giving us a talk about family bonding,” my grandfather recalled. “Her parting words were, ‘When the day is finished, then I’ll go.’ She passed away almost exactly at midnight.”

“They may go somewhere else”

My grandfather has never been a particularly sentimental person. Speaking to him later, I was not very surprised to find that he was not upset about the prospect of Bukit Brown being developed.

“To be honest, I feel, putting aside all sentiments, even the living has to give way sometimes to make space, what more the dead,” he told me. “Some of the graves are really uncared for. So many are unattended.”

“I don’t think it’s very sad that they are going to dig up my parents’ resting place,” he continued. “What’s the difference between cremating and scattering the ashes? Spiritually they may go somewhere else, we do not know.”

The price we pay

To me, the stories my grandfather tells of his childhood days in Singapore are almost like fairytales. I can barely identify with them, because I cannot picture the open spaces of the kampungs, the images of children swinging from tree to tree like little Tarzans.

Listening to these stories, I often wish that I had the chance to see the Singapore he spoke of, feeling a nostalgia for a piece of Singapore’s history I never experienced, and never will.

“When you look around at Singapore, see how it’s changed, don’t you feel sad?” I asked him. “Don’t you feel sad to see the places you know disappear?”

“It can’t be helped, I suppose, unless you want to put the clock back,” he replied. “You can’t. That’s the price we pay for progress.”

Progress. It’s hard to argue with that. Everyone wants to move forward, everyone wants to develop and get better and better. I, too, feel that if we as a small country desperately need land for progress, then we don’t have much of a choice.

But then I think about the remnants of old Singapore that are disappearing one by one to make way for shiny glass-and-steel structures. I think about the lost backdrops to my grandfather’s childhood, and wonder if Progress will one day take the scenery of my childhood away too.

I think about my great-grandparents’ graves. Although my grandfather doesn’t mind their graves being exhumed to make way for development, I can’t help feeling a small sense of loss for a piece of family history, history that I was a little too late in discovering.

Is this really the price we need to pay for progress? Do I feel okay with paying this price? I cannot quite find the answer. To find the answer, more questions would have to be asked: What does the URA want to do with Bukit Brown? What do they want to build? Is there really no other land we could use?

My great-grandmother said, “When the day is finished, then I’ll go.” But I’m not quite sure that I want the day to be finished, or for yet another piece of our nation’s history to disappear, just yet.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Netizens divided over the call for ban on smoking at windows and balconies of residential homes

The call for a ban on smoking at windows and balconies in…

苏睿勇再次向奥委会发出律师信函 拒绝奥委会两项要求

我国马拉松名将苏睿勇再次向奥委会发出律师信函,表示无法理解奥委会“延期至下周回复“的行为,并拒绝对方不公开往来信件内容的要求。 苏睿勇近日因东南亚运动会落选而与新加坡国家奥林匹克委员会(SNOC),以及新加坡田径总会(SA)争执,奥委会指出苏睿勇作为国家代表和青年运动员的典范,却表现出“不符合该委会期望的态度和行为”,同时新加坡田径总会表示已“暂时”把苏睿勇封锁在总会的聊天群组和社媒平台外,包括whatsapp、脸书、推特和Instagram等,避免后者在这些平台发文,带来负面影响。 而苏睿勇于8月7日向两协会发律师信函,指控他们在未举办任何听证会或给他辩护的机会,已“违反自然公义的基本原则”, 并要求两人于8月13日下午5点前给出具体解释,为何将他排除出2019年东南亚运动会新加坡代表团参赛阵容。 翌日,奥委会透过律师回复苏睿勇并向苏睿勇提出两项要求:1. 他们将在“下周结束前“回复苏睿勇的问题;2. 他们要求苏睿勇不再公开双方之间的细项。 苏睿勇8月11日于个人部落格上发文表示10日再次向奥委会发出律师信函,拒绝奥委会两项要求。 文内表示,“我们无法理解为何主办方需要一整个星期来回应,对于排出参选东南亚运动会阵容的理由应记录在案。“ 另外,文中也指出拒绝私底下解决问题的行为,“我们相信奥委会在未提出具体事件时,已公开谴责我作为一名运动员却表现出“不符合该委会期望的态度和行为”,他们应该能够针对以上指控,以及主观地筛选成员的行为,在公开的场合下作出解释。 苏睿勇也坚信,只有公开所有过程,才能确保奥委会维持最高标准的问责制。 日前本社报导,新加坡运动选手将在今年11月30日,赴菲律宾马尼拉出征2019年东南亚运动会。但是,2015、2017年东运会马拉松冠军得主苏睿勇,却无缘在这场体育盛事角逐金牌。…

应对增长风险 尚穆根称或提升宗教场所保安

一名20岁的前全职国民服役人员阿米鲁,被指计划对本地犹太教徒发动袭击,在今年3月在《内部安全法》下被逮捕。 该名青年打算在某个周六,乘着滑铁卢街犹太教堂(Maghain Aboth Synagogue)举行集体祈祷后,袭击犹太信徒。他计划杀害三名犹太教男子,理由是他认为犹太教男性都曾在以色列服兵役,并曾对巴勒斯坦人“施暴”。 今日(10日),内政暨律政部长尚穆根,也随同穆斯林社群领袖,拜访上述犹太教堂,展示与本地犹太社群同在。 他也透露,考量到日渐增加的风险,宗教膜拜场所的安保或需要重新审视,以保护信徒。但当中也应取得平衡,宗教场所需继续保持开放,也避免变成戒备森严的堡垒要塞。 他也指由于自我激化的“孤狼式恐袭”威胁不断存在,社区的警惕和伙伴关系,仍是捍卫新加坡的主要防线。 他称,一些高风险场所可能采取额外措施,可能是增派保安、增设安保硬件等等。 至于犹太长老拉比莫迪凯·阿贝热尔(Rabbi Mordechai Abergel)也表示,有关犹太教堂已投入资源确保安保工作到位。 本地回教和犹太社群已表态,拒绝任何形式的极端和激进主义,以及暴力行为。…

Outside the Counting Centre – A Long Evening Before News of Decisive Win for Workers’ Party

By Sharon Ng From 5pm yesterday evening the space outside North Vista…