New People’s Action Party (PAP) candidate, Dr Janil Puthucheary, says that he “felt it was important to step up and stand forward to advocate on behalf of those who can’t do so for themselves, or aren’t heard.” He was responding to a question posed to him on his Facebook page on what he thought of Mr Chen Show Mao (Workers’ Party’s potential candidate) serving his National Service (NS), while he did not.

“I did not do NS, Mr Chen did, those are the facts, yes,” he said.

Dr Janil is 38-years old and is a pediatrician. He received his Singapore citizenship three years ago.

Mr Chen, 50, was born in Taiwan and moved to Singapore when he was 11-years old. Mr Chen had volunteered to serve his NS before he became a Singapore citizen in 1986.

The comparison between the two men have led to criticisms of Dr Janil not doing what most Singaporean men are required by law to do  – dedicating two years of their lives to serving the nation. As the criticisms mounted, Dr Janil finally responded in late March. According to the local press, he was reported thus:

“…As for criticism that he did not serve national service, as he became a Singapore citizen at the age of 35, the pediatrician said he has been in public service: ‘I’ve spent the last 10 years saving kids’ lives.’”

This led to further outrage as critics saw his answer as equating what he does as a profession to what Singaporeans do as an act of patriotism, besides the fact that as a pediatrician he is paid more than the average NSman.

In his reply on his Facebook page, while acknowledging that Mr Chen has done his NS and he did not, Dr Janil seems to avoid commenting any further than that.

National Service is not the only controversy surrounding the new PAP face who is expected to be fielded as a PAP candidate in Pasir Ris-Punngol GRC, under the wings of Deputy Prime Minister Teo Chee Hean.

In an earlier interview, he was asked if he was angry about the 10-month detention of his father, Mr Dominic Puthucheary, under the Internal Security Act (ISA) in 1963. Dr Janil said he “could not express any anger for that.” He said “it was something… that happened in the long history that we were told about. It wasn’t something that we lived with or we knew of ourselves.” He seemed to pledge support for the ISA, despite what his father had gone through, when he said, “The potential uses for that law after 9/11 are very different. I may philosophically argue with some aspects of policy. But the philosophy is not as important as the pragmatic implications for our state, security and country.” (Asia One)

His remarks were criticised, particularly by online commentators, for seemingly supporting the stand that things like the right to an open trial, access to counsel, and burden of proof, were not important as important as the “pragmatic implications for our state.”

On his Facebook page, Dr Janil also said he is giving his first speech (as an MP) “a lot of thought”. But he said “this is premature” as he has not been elected or even nominated yet.

He says his focus now is to “demonstrate” his sincerity and “earn the trust of the residents.”

Dr Janil’s latest comments on his lack of a National Service stint will probably fuel more criticisms. It is left to be seen if the PAP will address this head-on. The party has so far kept mum about it.

 

You May Also Like

重新建议首相人选 马国元首召见朝野党魁

马国国家元首苏丹阿都拉为了国家的未来,将再次召见身为政党党魁的国会议员,由他们建议首相人选。 马来西亚国家王宫王室事务协调官拿督阿末法迪今日发文告指出,苏丹陛下目前对于有国会议员能获得大多数议员的支持,组成新政府一事保持质疑。 因此陛下御令就任朝野政党党魁的国会议员,重新推荐新任首相人选。 国家王宫将会联系所有的相关议员。 他也指出,陛下感谢所有参与周二和周三会面的国会议员及政府首席秘书,给予充分配合。 文告中写到,国家元首也御准国家下议院议长丹斯里莫哈末阿里夫,不召开3月2日的国会特别会议。 马哈迪重新领导土团党 另一方面,于本月24日辞去土著团结党主席职位的敦马哈迪医生,昨日(27日)决定重新拿起该党领导职责。 土团党总秘书拿督马祖基昨日发出文告,证实有关事件,并表示会在日后公布详情。 文告中披露,马哈迪日前提呈的主席职辞函,经土团党最高理事会于2月25日开会商议后,一律拒绝接受。 马祖基将有关会议议决向马哈迪反映后,促请马哈迪撤回辞呈,而后者是在经过昨日的讨论和思虑后,同意重新出任主席职位。 阿兹敏加入土团党…

Let’s burn the flame bright

By Clarence Zeng I cannot recall exactly how long it has been since…

SOTA student defends art students' choice of dropping art

A former SOTA student, Gabbi Wenyi Ayane Virk, spoke out against the assumptions…

SPP’s Jeannette Chong-Aruldoss says she doesn’t know if she’s running in next GE because uncertainty in electoral map

On her Facebook page, Jeannette Chong-Aruldoss of the Singapore People’s Party recounts…