The following is an excerpt of an article posted on blog Give Life A 2nd Chance.

M Ravi in Second Chances in the Park

Published at East Asian Law Journal, Vol. 1 No. 2

By M. Ravi, Practitioner at L.F. Violet Netto, Lawyer for Yong Vui Kong and Alan Shadrake; Co-author Choo Zheng Xi

Overview: harsh substantive law unsupported by criminological statistics

Systematic penalogical data is hard to come by in Singapore, which has led the immediate past president of the Singapore Law Society to lament that “Singapore is sadly lacking a principled and transparent penal Policy because Government has not published detailed statistics of crime and punishment”.[1]  Neither of Singapore’s two universities offering law degrees have a department of criminology in their law faculties.

This statistical lacunae of general criminological data is alarming, but is rendered exponentially more egregious when one considers the most controversial application of the death penalty in Singapore: that trafficking in more than a quantity of drugs prescribed in the Schedule of the Misuse of Drugs Act is sufficient for a man to hang. The uniquely draconian nature of Singapore’s “Misuse of Drugs Act” deserves some elucidation.

The first aspect of the death penalty for drug trafficking in Singapore is that it attracts not just the possibility of a sentence of death, but the mandatory death penalty.

Secondly, the mandatory nature of the death penalty for trafficking is coupled with a presumption of trafficking in cases of possession.[2] This reverses the basic principle of criminal law that a charge must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt for conviction to follow.

To read on, click here.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

戴森终止电动车项目 徐芳达:因缺乏可行商业化方案

贸工部兼教育部高级政务部长徐芳达周二(5日)在国会解释,戴森(Dyson)终止电动车项目并非因为新加坡缺乏能力,而是因该项目缺乏商业可行性。 武吉知马集选区议员连荣华于国会中质询相关问题,徐芳达表示,“是因为新加坡缺乏能力吗?不是。是因为他们所选择的业务在商业上并不可行,因此他们才会终止计划。” 戴森上月初突然宣布终止计划,然而在此前却无任何迹象表明终止该项价值25亿欧元(43.7亿元)的项目。 戴森的同名创办人詹姆斯表示,纵然他的研究团队已研发一款“出色的汽车”,无奈却无法在商业上找到可行的价值,迄今为止无法找到该项目的买家,使之成为转化为商业化方案。 至于是否会履行先前对戴森的承诺,徐芳达则强调并不会给予该公司任何的福利。 “我想说明一点,目前项目尚未进行,因此不会予以任何福利”,他表示,并补充说该公司除了电动车计划,也正在扩展其他项目,而其他项目也会将被视为独立项目,与电动车项目无关联。 徐芳达也重新申明,戴森的临时改变注意,并不会影响戴森公司在新加坡的其他业务和运营。 他表示,“戴森公司内共有1200名员工,其中20名是电动汽车业务部门,而戴森也会重组内部,将重新部署安排受影响的员工。” 他续指,尽管戴森不再从事电动车行业,但未来仍将核心发展放在新加坡,包括开发消费类产品的电池技术、研发智能科技如扩大传感器、机器人和人工智能。徐芳达表示,不仅仅是戴森对开发智能方案感兴趣,许多公司也正有此意,因为他们发现新加坡的相关专业劳动力,在机器人与自动化先进技术的优势,稳固的智力财产保护与三方伙伴关系。 “这正式我们努力拓展的领域,无论是电动汽车、精密制造的高端医疗与生物设备,都是来自于新加坡值得信赖的劳动力与品牌共同创造,所以我们持续和这些公司合作,为新加坡谋取更多的机会与发展。” 戴森于2017年9月宣布投入电动车研发,并于2018年宣布在新加坡设立首个电动车厂。据戴森发言人表示,戴森同名创办人詹姆士已决定将本部转移至新加坡,戴森夫妇更在新加坡置产,购买位于华利世家(Wallich Residence)的三层顶层豪宅,引发热议。…

Massive cost overrun in infrastructure projects in Singapore in recent years

The media reported on Thu (‘Final stage of Circle Line to cost…

Coronavirus exposes 'weaknesses' in health systems: G20

The coronavirus pandemic has exposed “systemic weaknesses” in global health systems, the G20 said Monday, but there was no…