Gerald Giam

Malaysia cleans up the mess. Singapore takes the credit – shamelessly.

“DEPUTY Prime Minister Wong Kan Seng commended the Internal Security Department (ISD) officers for going all out to track down the escaped terror leader Mas Selamat, who was eventually caught in Malaysia on April 1.”

– Straits Times, 8 May 2009

Firstly let me state that I am glad that Mas Selamat has been captured. I thank the Malaysian police for their excellent work in capturing the fugitive. Malaysian Home Minister Hishamuddin said that they arrested him under the ISD because he was plotting something, which means they not only caught the JI leader who escaped from under Singapore’s nose, but possibly managed to thwart a planned terrorist attack.

I am, however, appalled that the Singapore mainstream media and Home Affairs Minister Wong Kan Seng would go to the extent of congratulating themselves and taking credit for Mas Selamat’s arrest by the Malaysians. Instead of acting with a bit of humility and contrition, the Singapore Government has attempted to turn the tables on their “setback” and praise itself for the re-arrest of the alleged terrorist mastermind.

It should be pointed out that this is actually the second time that a neighbouring country has helped us nab the same man. Mas Selamat had escaped the first time in 2001 just before the first wave of JI arrests.

I’m sure MHA felt that this would be a PR coup for them, and that Singaporeans will queue up to congratulate the good work of the government if it blew its trumpet enough. Of course, reading the mainstream media, one would be forgiven for thinking this was the case.

“Minister’s hail arrest” – Straits Times

“ISD provides crucial lead” – Straits Times

“Singaporeans cheered by news of Mas Selamat’s arrest” – TODAY/CAN

“With Singapore downgrading from Orange to Yellow Alert for the flu virus, I think this comes as great news.” – a teacher quoted by TODAY

“Sources said that it was the Singapore ISD that gave the Malaysians the lead on Mas Selamat’s trail. If so, the department, which has come under the heaviest fire, has redeemed itself.” – Straits Times

I really wonder what Singaporeans really think?

Personally, I think this would be a most appropriate time for the Minister to apologise for all the worry, inconvenience and trouble caused to both Singaporeans and his counterparts in Malaysia and Indonesia for ISD’s slip up. It is not the time for praising the ISD for doing their job.

I am also surprised that Singapore decided to go public with the news of the arrest even before the Malaysians did. Obviously the Malaysians had a reason to keep the arrest under wraps for almost 1 1/2 months. I’m not sure if they were prepared to go public yet. If they were, I’m sure given the extreme political fire the BN government is under (Perak crisis, by-elections results, Altantuya case, etc) they would have badly wanted to boast about this capture to their own people.

I would have thought the gracious and diplomatic thing to do would be to let the Malaysian government announce the arrest and take some credit for it. At a minimum, it should have been announced jointly, rather than having Malaysians hear about it from the Straits Times.

You see, this is why Malaysians get so irritated with us all the time. Then we wonder why, and just retort that they are jealous of us. Yeah, I guess the Malaysians are “jealous” we have such an effective secret police, who are able to get others to clean up after the mess they created.

 ———

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

新加坡能复制大马变天?(2) 柔净选盟 国阵堡垒区办集会

2012年,隔着新柔长堤的柔佛仍牢牢掌控在国阵手中,即便在2008年全国大选,柔佛州国阵只丢失了一个选区巴克里,人民海啸也未冲倒这座老树盘根国阵堡垒。但即便如此,柔佛州公民组织干净选举联盟,毅然在首府新山举办净选盟3.0集会,就是希望能撼动霸权的主干,激发柔佛人民的政治醒觉。 柔佛非政府组织愿景工程(ENGAGE)主席范平东,也是该州南部净选盟副主席,在18日举行的“新加坡能否复制大马变天”时事论坛,分享柔佛公民组织的经验。 他说,当时受到净选盟主席安美嘉邀请,动员柔佛支持者出席在首都吉隆坡举行的集会。“可是在开会时,有同志就提到,为何不在柔佛同步办一场集会?因为巫统的发源地就在柔佛,马华的堡垒区也在这里。” 撼动国阵“主干” “与其拨动其他的树枝,倒不如直接撼动国阵的主干,这是我们当时的想法。于是就叫上志同道合者,动员了50人协助印传单、做宣传等。” 范平东说,当时根本就不知道什么是记者会,但还是办了,请来媒体柔宣传柔佛新山场的净选盟集会。他坦言,主流媒体并不搭理,只有中文媒体还给了中肯的报导。 https://youtu.be/80efIClIB2Q 他说,当地民众为了宣扬民主理念,参与者都是自费,好像推销员般到各个超级市场,协助民主登记成为选民,因为只要增加选民人数,才有可能在选票上削弱国阵势力。 由于资源都掌握在州国阵手上,可以预见警察、市议会都拒绝颁发集会准证,理由是当天有军警球赛和摇滚演唱会。 范平东说,原本预计只有数百人出席,当天净选盟支持者当天还是成功举办了和平集会,出席者超过八千人。范平东说,主办当局是基于宪法第十条,保障人民和平集会权力。他说,集会者在操场500米外集合。还得有不同的对策,应付被警方驱赶、干涉等可能情况。 “在活动前自愿者们都是挨家逐户派集会传单,从我们接触的普通群众,我们能感受到民心思变,是因为人民的支持,柔佛的社运才能支撑下去。” 他认为,马来西亚的变天,背后是经历了20年不间断的民间运动,多少人愿意付出代价,甚至有人被拘留、面临破产等。…

Gan: I feel we can afford to be more flexible for “severely disabled” SGs to withdraw cash from CPF

It was reported in the news today (4 Jul) that CPF members…

Think Centre – 2012 National Day Message

Media Release Think Centre – 2012 National Day Message Strengthen our collective…

"Do we want a system where children are penalized for their parents’ problems?" – SDP's Dr Paul Tambyah

Singapore Democratic Party (SDP) Chairman Dr Paul Tambyah asked if the ministry…