Government Control Grows as More Websites Must Get Onerous Licenses
2000px-Hrw_logo.svg(Bangkok, October 16, 2014) – The government of Singapore’s regulatory actions against two prominent online news websites is a serious setback for freedom of expression on the Internet, Human Rights Watch said today.
The Media Development Authority (MDA) ordered The Online Citizen in September 2014 and The Mothership in March to obtain licenses under the Broadcasting Act of 2013 to continue their online publishing. The terms of the license give officials virtually unlimited authority to force the removal of any content that they consider violates broadly defined notions of “the public interest, public order or national harmony” or contains content that “offends against good taste or decency.”
“Tight government control over printed publications, radio, and TV has forced Singaporeans to turn to online media for independent news and analysis – but now even that limited space for expression is under serious threat,” said Phil Robertson, deputy Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “Singapore should stop placing onerous, broad restrictions on news websites and respect that media freedom is a centerpiece of modern, rights-respecting countries.”
The MDA had ordered The Independent Singapore to register in July 2013. Another news website, The Breakfast Network, decided to close its operations when ordered to register in December 2013.
Singapore’s Broadcasting Act requires the registration of any online news website that receives, over a two-month period, an average of at least 50,000 unique visits per month from Singapore Internet addresses and is involved in “the propagation, promotion or discussion of political or religious issues related to Singapore.” Registering websites must provide a 50,000 Singapore dollar (US$40,000) performance bond to guarantee that they will promptly take down content that the MDA designates as inappropriate. The MDA also has the authority to ban outright material advocating same-sex relations, order that such posts be taken down within 24 hours, and demand apologies.
In addition, all licensed sites must abide by Singapore’s Internet Code of Practice, which requires Internet Service Providers (ISP) to filter in order to prevent users of their services from accessing materials on the Internet that the MDA deems “undesirable, harmful or obscene.” Those terms are not defined and are subject to sole interpretation by the MDA.
“Both the definitions and decisions of acceptable content lie with the Singapore government and its dismal record of respecting free expression,” said Robertson. “As more websites are forced to register, the power of the government to control what Singaporeans see on the Internet will grow too.”
Singapore’s government also enforces an onerous requirement on registered news websites, many of which are financially strapped, by preventing them from receiving foreign funds from any entity for any purpose. Officials state that this requirement is to prevent foreign influence or interference in Singapore affairs. As the Ministry of Communications and Information stated in January 2014, “foreign interests [will] not be allowed to control, or worse, manipulate out local media platforms, which are prime vehicles for influence or even subversion.” The practice of attempting to limit foreign influence in Singapore by capping the circulation of foreign newspapers goes back decades.
In the case of TOC Ltd., the parent company of The Online Citizen, the government previously compelled the TOC to register in February 2011 as a political association, so the company is already subject to foreign funding restrictions. However, in the future it will have to supply donor details, names, identification numbers, addresses, and more, which are conditions that could cause unease and help further reduce their existing group of donors. The Mothership, which has operated since August 2013, has also agreed to register and operate under the MDA regulations.
There are increasing concerns that individual blogs in Singapore may also be targeted for regulation, Human Rights Watch said. The MDA has stated that “If they [blogs] take on the nature of news sites, we will take a closer look and evaluate them accordingly.” The Broadcasting Act does not exempt such blogs, and the definition of “Singapore news programs” is extremely broad and includes “any program containing any news, intelligence, report of occurrence, or any matter of public interest, about any social, economic, political, cultural, artistic, sporting, scientific or any other aspect of Singapore.”
In April 2014, Dr. Yaacob Ibrahim, the minister for communications and information, stated that the Broadcast Act would possibly be amended in the future, but did not commit to specific changes or a clear timetable. He did, however, say that the ministry would conduct consultations with “industry partners and the public” before the government proposes amendments.
“Singapore regulators play down Internet registrations while amassing the tools for future censorship of online news sites,” said Robertson. “Sadly, Singapore is going backwards on freedom of expression and the media, and concerned governments should call on Singapore to revise these restrictive provisions.”
For more Human Rights Watch reporting on Singapore, please visit:
www.hrw.org/asia/singapore
 

Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

年长屋主售屋所得填公积金退休户头6万元 可获乐龄安居花红最高3万元

国家发展部长兼财政部第二部长黄循财,昨天(4日)在国会宣布,未来年长屋主售组屋套现,在乐龄安居花红(Silver Housing Bonus)下可获最高三万元花红。 他指出屋主未必是“大屋换小屋”,只要购买三房式组屋或更小单位,用售屋所得填补公积金退休户头,就能获得上述花红。 黄循财举例,住在成熟区三房式组屋的年长者,若购买非成熟区三房式组屋单位、且能从售屋套利,就可获得花红。 在乐龄安居花红下,屋主只需填补公积金退休户头六万元。过去则需取决于户头存款额和卖屋所得,有时可能要填补超过六万元。 事实上,过去民间就已呼吁当局对屋契回购计划理应更弹性化,特别是乐龄群体本来财务管理选择不多,有者公积金户口本来就没有多少储蓄,且急需现钱用在医疗和退休生活开销。 黄循财称,这是当局在收集到公众反馈后,作出的调整。他表示,其中民众指该计划复杂,设下好几个条件,故此当局检讨后决定简化勒令安居花红。 另一方面,屋契回购计划也配合上述调整,从下月1日起,,加入屋契回购计划的年长屋主,可获花红将增半,到介于7千500元至3万元之间,视组屋类型而定。

台湾前总统李登辉病逝 享年98岁

台湾前总统李登辉,于本月30日晚间7时24分,在台北病逝,享年98岁。 今年2月,因喝牛奶呛伤,引发吸入性肺炎,住院近半年,状况也起起伏伏;他生前也曾罹患大肠癌,有心脏病、糖尿病等问题。 他曾是台湾最有权势的政治人物。1988年,接替离世的蒋经国就任总统。直到1996年,在台湾首场民主选举胜选,继续当总统到2000年离任。 李登辉出生于日治时期的台北淡水郡三芝庄,为台湾客家人后代。自小在台湾接受日式教育,1943中学毕业前往日本就读京都大学农业经济系,日文名字是岩里政男。 1965年,李登辉赴美,于康乃尔大学工读农业经济博士,学成后返台回到当时的农复会工作,开始步入政坛,并受蒋经国赏识,此后政途平步青云,先后出任台北市市长,中华民国台湾省政府主席,并在1984年获蒋经国提拔,担任副总统一职。

Holiday gift from Scoot and Klook for victims of tour agency closure

It was reported on Wednesday how a 68-year-old cleaner, Madam Teo Ino…

装修工疑偷工减料 以报纸填塞墙内空隙

用旧报纸填充边墙空隙交差?建屋发展局昨日在其官方脸书专页,揭发某组屋单位的天台边墙的窗户边框,竟是以旧报纸填充,令住户怀疑相关组屋承包商在整修时,是否为偷工减料省成本,以报纸填塞缝隙了事。 在接获住户投诉后,建屋发展局派员前往视察,了解该单位是在1984年完成。有关住户在1999年时,为该天台处窗户进行翻新,相信是负责翻新工作的承包商,以报纸填塞连接窗户的边墙。 对此住户一直被蒙在鼓里,直到近期他打算换薪窗户,在拆下窗户时,才揭发此事。 建屋发展局在帖文中表示,经过检查已得知有关以报纸填塞的边墙缝隙,未构成结构安全威胁,不过也立即进行修补。该局称目前仍在进行调查,一旦发现有关装修承包商有失误,会马上采取行动对付。 立即就有许多网民在有关建屋局贴文留言,除了要求彻查偷工减料一事,也再引起大家对组屋品质的关注。一些网民纷纷留言申诉,在装修厕所时,还有装修工斗胆问他,有没有多余的旧报纸,好让他可以填补墙壁空间。 网民May Ngway也表示,有次装修时看见工人也这么做,立马要求他们拿出旧报纸,用真材实料补洞。 网民:空隙是否本就存在? 不过,有者就提出质疑,装修工以报纸填塞缝隙确实错了,但原本的缝隙,又是从何而来?是否有关组屋单位刚建造时,墙内本就是中空的? Lawrence Marshall则指出,填充旧报纸绝不是好注意,许多在中国和台湾的豆腐渣工程,就是因为发展商用旧报纸来填塞建筑物结构,而导致后来发生倒塌事故。 审视公共组屋问题…