By Terry Xu

computersociety

Over 50 people attended a two hour long dialog jointly organized by the Singapore Computer Society (SCS) and the Internet Society, Singapore Chapter at the Singapore Computer Society Resource Center.

The dialog was organized to analyse and discuss the Media Development Authority (MDA)’s new licensing rules that took effect from 1st June 2013.

The panelists invited to sit in at the dialog were Mr Bryan Tan (Partner, Pinsent Masons MPillay LLP), Mr Aubeck Kam (Permanent Secretary for Ministry of Communications and Information), and Mr Kuek Yu-Chang (Internet policy expert).

Deliberating on international practices

Mr Bryan Tan brought out a comparison between the 1996 media regulation and the new MDA’s licensing rules. Since 1996, all sites and online service providers has automatically enrolled under the class licenses and there is no changes in the obligation of the service providers on their contents standard. The main difference lies on the $50,000 performance bond and 24 hours take down of contents in breach of contents standard.

Mr Tan in his presentation also raised an interesting question on how much weight Facebook announcements hold in reference to the MDA Facebook clarification on bloggers’ concern.

Answering a question on whether there have been similar legislation in Asia or other parts of the world, Mr Tan said that different countries are looking at  different ways, while not all will  follow the exact same way but different country already started out on this, “the registration cum  performance bond tactic, I don’t think I have seen that before, they usually go for the more severe, they will throw you in jail kind of remedy especially in Vietnam and Cambodia.” “Government do want to seek some form of control over the internet services and it varies between various degrees.”

Mr Kuek said that the issues that are happening in Singapore is a global issue that there are valid concerns that the country is trying to address.  But he also stated that the Internet has no boundaries – if the response is not calibrated according what the others are doing, there is a risk of fragmenting the Internet by disconnecting with the others.

aubeck
Mr Aubeck Kam, Permanent Secretary for Ministry of Communications and Information

Trust and clarity

“Trust MDA’s track record”,  is what Mr Aubeck Kam said while citing that no websites have been ever asked to take down content such as criticism of the government as there is nothing that prevents that in the content standards obligation. He emphasized on the point that there are no major changes to what the individual licensees had to comply with. The two main reasons that Mr Kam state for the new MDA regulation comes from the need for online news providers to take responsibility for the content they create and due to the rapid media convergence happening in Singapore.

The justification of which Mr Kam gave for the 24 hour take-down notice stems on the significant outreach of the news sites. The content which the identified significant news sites carry would influence public opinion and need urgent attention to address nonfactual reports and facts. But Mr Kam also states the 24-hour deadline would only take effect from the time when a formal take-down notice is issued as the government understands the complexity of decision making for large companies and the difference between timezones.

Other questions were thrown at Mr Kam, such as why a limit of 50,000 unique IPs was used as a benchmark for one of the criteria. One participant also brought out a point that niche sites have their one of their criteria for being licensed as being 100,000 unique viewers. Mr Kam’s reply did not really answer the question in full but went about explaining that  the measurements for sites are constantly evolving and the standards are not cast in stone.  He went on further they are still trying to find the right proxy but felt if they ported the 100,000 unique views directly, it would have been more bewildering.

Donaldson Tan, representing the FreeMyInternet movement, asked Mr Kam about the issue of government control over the ownership and management of licensed websites. Mr Kam reiterated that there are only two changes to how companies operate, which is the $50,000 performance bond and the 24 hour content take down obligation.

Limits and possibilities of new rules

Dr. John Ure, Executive Director of AIC asked Mr Kam on why is there a need for the new rules given that existing laws and regulations have already covered restricted content. Mr Ure also cited a finding from a study conducted in India, stating that a major constraint for Asian Internet companies going global as compared to their Western counter parts are rules and regulations that constraints their activity in one way or another.

Outside of the MDA new licensing rules, there were also questions on press accreditation, on whether the government would extend the press accreditation to Yahoo Singapore given that it recongnizes the significant outreach of the news platform and that it is the only new platform among the ten other news sites that does not have press accreditation.

Mr Kam responded that “government press accreditation is really just government press accreditation and the government does not warrant or provide any guarantee, and certainty does not recommend any private organization should rely on the fact that the holder has a press accreditation card and therefore suspend their own need to make their own decisions about who ought to be invited.”

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

消防栓锁起来 水管不出水! 裕廊-金文泰市镇会接民防部队警告

武吉巴督21街的第210A组屋的一户单位,在本月1日凌晨失火。然而有居民申诉,火患发生时,该楼的一个消防喉竟无法运作,紧急情况下没有水源可救火! 根据有关消防喉的标签,刚在今年10月经过检修,为此民主党秘书长徐顺全表示已致函民防部队申诉此事。据民主党文告,民防部队在本月5日回函,表示已和有关市镇会接洽跟进此事。 该区组屋由裕廊—金文泰市镇理事会负责。该市镇会也被民防部队警告,接到民防部队发出的“消除火患隐忧通知书”(Fire Hazard Abatement Notice),要求纠正问题。 民防在声明中指出,市镇会有责任维修和保养消防设施,并保证这些设施能正常运作。若被发现重犯,将面对罚款甚至是被起诉。 民防部队在上周五发布的声明中指出,火患现场附近好几个消防栓都被锁头锁住;但即便民防人员当时撬开其中一个消防栓锁头,却发现水管根本喷不出水! 民防部队表示,当天该部队约在凌晨4时31分接获失火投报,也出动了CPL60型云梯车赶赴现场。 两名分别年龄为60岁及30岁的男子站在厨房外窗沿。厨房中囤积的物品,加之两人皆已耗尽体力,也增加民防人员救援难度。 民防人员先从单位内以绳索保护两人,灾难拯救队(Disaster Assistance…

Singaporeans react to Law Minister’s statement on Elected Presidency

The Law and Home Affairs Minister K Shanmugam helmed a dialogue session…

销毁不符防火标准个人代步工具 两周内接获2800申请

在短短两周内,陆路交通管理局已经接到超过2800份,有关销毁不符合防火标准的个人代步工具之申请。 交通部高级政务部长普杰立医生在今天的国会上,回答议员提问时指出,自上个月23日到本月3日,当局也在这两周内,回收了超过940台不符合标准的个人代步工具。 陆交局自上个月开始,在指定地点收取民众不符合UL2272防火标准的代步工具,而符合资格的民众可获得100元的奖励金。 明年起每两年需强行检查 陆交局宣布,为了确保已经上路的电动滑板车符合安全规格,已注册的电动滑板车自明年4月起,必须每两年接受强行检查。 当局指出,在明年4月1日前注册,拥有UL2272认证的电动滑板车,都必须进行当局所安排的强制性免费检查。他呼吁持有者在接到通知后,将电动滑板车带到全岛九个检查中心中的任何一间进行调查。 而在明年4月1日之后申请注册的电动滑板车,则需要通过检查后才能注册。 持有者若没在期限内将电动滑板车送往检查,将有可能面对不超过1000元的罚款,或不超过三个月的监禁,或两者兼施。