Gordon Lee /

Since the parliamentary “debate” in January this year, which saw Members of Parliament coming out strongly as a united front against implementing a minimum wage, discussions on the pros and cons of a minimum wage seem to have died down.

Government rhetoric asserts that a minimum wage policy has few merits, but significant demerits – such as unemployment, inflation and loss of competitiveness. Lee Hsien Loong was reported to have said, “Singapore has something better than a minimum wage and it is called Workfare.”

This multi-part series will examine these claims from two perspectives: economic theory, and empirical research. In this first instalment, we look at the alleged “unemployment” that is predicted to occur with a minimum wage.

Unemployment in theory

This simple textbook model is easily recognisable by A-Level economics students. Briefly, the downward-sloping demand curve shows that as wages fall along the Y-axis, firms’ demand for workers will increase rightwards along the X-axis. The upward-sloping supply curve shows that as wages increase along the Y-axis, more workers are willing to work for longer, and the supply of labour increases rightwards along the X-axis. The equilibrium level of employment in this perfectly competitive labour market is at E2, with the equilibrium wage at W1.

With a minimum wage set above the equilibrium wage (W1) at the level W min, workers are willing to supply E1 amount of labour, but firms are only willing to employ E3 amount of labour, leading to a fall in employment from E2 to E3 with unemployment as shown. So far, this is what ministers seem to be implying.

There is a problem with this theoretical understanding, as it is based on the assumption that firms operate in a perfectly competitive labour market with practically no ability to set wages. For example, fast food chains and supermarkets seem to have considerable power to determine wages, and the sector can be said to be closer to a monopsony (sole buyer with full control over wages) than a perfectly competitive market (infinite buyers each of small size with no control over wages).

 

Modelling the monopsonistic market is a little more complex. Although the equilibrium in the free market between Supply (S) and Demand (MRP) for labour is at point C, the monopsonist would choose to employ where his marginal cost (MC) is equal to his marginal benefit (MRP) at point A, hence employing L amount of labour instead of L’ in order to maximise profits. Since a monopsonist has the power to decide wages, he will pay the minimum amount (W) required to secure L amount of labour instead of the equivalent W’ under a perfectly competitive market.

There is also a deadweight welfare loss to society shown by the triangle ACM – which means that because resources are not efficiently allocated, the overall cost to society (in terms of both consumer and producer) is more than the overall benefit to society.

But, if a minimum wage is set at W’, than the monopsonist has no choice but to pay W’ instead of W level of wages, and in order to continue to maximise profits, the monopsonist will increase employment from L to L’. Not only is employment increased, but the deadweight welfare loss is also eliminated with a minimum wage. It’s highly counter-intuitive, but true. In some markets (which are closer to a monopsony rather than a perfectly competitive one), employment increases!

The Singapore economy is a complex one which the first textbook model cannot represent adequately. The economy comprises a mix of competitive and monopsonist markets, and though employment might decrease in more competitive markets, employment increases in more monopsonist markets, mitigating (though not necessarily eliminating) effects of employment/unemployment either way.

Unemployment in practice

“We find that minimum wages … do not have a negative impact on employment.” [1]

“To sum up, the evidence for the UK presented in this paper indicates that the effect of the introduction of the minimum wage on the probability of employment is insignificantly different from zero for all four demographic groups and in all three datasets used.” [2] (If you are interested in studying the empirical evidence further, reference [2] provides a great overview of research done so far (US, UK, France), and the results.)

Due to the mitigating effects of monopsonist markets, it is no wonder that most empirical studies show little significant overall impact of a minimum wage on employment.

In any case, as past recessions have shown (and the government is quick to point out), any rise in unemployment is partially absorbed by foreign workers. The remaining unemployment has to be weighed against the benefits of a minimum wage, which will be explored in subsequent articles.

Conclusion

While a staggeringly high minimum wage could decrease overall employment, economic theory and empirical statistics demonstrate that a minimum wage set at a modest level* has little (if any) negative effect on unemployment. Unemployment should also be weighed against achieving a country’s other economic and social objectives.

*See http://wrap.warwick.ac.uk/1560/1/WRAP_Stewart_twerp630.pdf (pg. 29) for an elaboration

In subsequent parts of this series, I aim to show that there are strong economic as well as social justifications for the implementation of a national minimum wage.

————-

References;

[1] The Effects of Minimum Wages on Employment: Theory and Evidence from Britain

[2] The Impact of the Introduction of the UK Minimum Wage on the Employment Probabilities of Low Wage Workers

 

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

台湾知名健身达人看似健康却中风! 妻子曝光关键原因

37岁台湾知名健身达人“筋肉爸爸”因经常在网络上分享运动心得而闻名,更多次受邀成为综艺节目的嘉宾。看似身体健康的他却在近日传出中风的消息,令人震惊。 妻子“筋肉妈妈”于中秋节(13日)当天向粉丝公开“筋肉爸爸”中风的消息,亦解释“筋肉爸爸”倒下的来龙去脉。 据“筋肉妈妈”表示,上周“筋肉爸爸”在送孩子上学后睡回笼觉,却被“筋肉妈妈”发现不对劲,后来才得知他中风了,便及时送到医院急诊,当时在经过脑断层扫描后被诊断出是脑部栓塞,但因为在三小时内送达,经评估后可以打脑栓塞溶剂。 但脑栓塞溶剂是有风险的,据“筋肉妈妈”说,医生告知在施打后会有6巴仙的机率成脑溢血,全身血管都会起作用,因此需要在加护病房内观察监测,同时也必须向“筋肉妈妈”发出病危通知书。 而“筋肉妈妈”在期间一直为此事忙碌,仍未强烈感受到危机,直到病危通知书交到手上,被要求要签名时,“筋肉妈妈”一瞬间天崩地裂,难以接受,甚至已经忘了如何回到家中。 “筋肉妈妈”表示,她无法接受自己的丈夫上周还在陪着她度假,而这一刻却已经在床上与死神搏斗。在心慌意乱之时,她仅仅记得某些琐碎的记忆片段,有一刻她朋友告诉他一些医疗资讯而她无法拿定主意,下意识发信息问“筋肉爸爸”,却发现他已经无法回他。 她也知道自己不能再此时倒下,必须照顾协助“筋肉爸爸”完成工作教学,同时兼顾自己的工作,还需要照顾孩子,幸好身边的家人一直给予他协助,才能让他好好完成工作。 “筋肉爸爸”持续昏沉很多天,即便从加护病房转移到普通病房,却一直昏睡不停,就连医生也感觉到奇怪,于是开始探究“筋肉爸爸”的作息,才发现中风原因。 尽管他的血脂、胆固醇、血压、内脏脂肪均属标准,但在检查家族病史检测后发现,家族一直都有凝血功能问题,容易出现凝血状况,当中也有一些亲戚就死于心血管疾病,加上年轻、不断运动、经常性健康检查的他,更容易忽略家族病史,同时仗着年轻的体力经常熬夜、睡回笼觉、一天睡眠不超过六小时,可能出现过劳的情况。 据悉,因为过劳加上家族病史伤害到了控制右边肢体运动神经的大脑,中风了! 文内最后也表示现在的筋肉爸爸也展开复健之路,也因为身体质量好的关系,康复速度也快,她们也因这件事开始力行早睡,重视健康生活。 中风不仅仅局限在老年,亦可能出现在更年轻的年龄层…

习近平贺李显龙选举获胜

中国国家主席习近平,昨日致电祝贺我国总理李显龙,带领人民行动党在选举获胜。 今年也是新中建交30周年,两国领袖在通话中重申两国稳固关系,并对冠病19疫情期间相互协助和支持表达谢意。 针对疫情期间,如何加强跨境、供应链连接,以及金融、投资贸易合作,促进经济复苏等,李显龙和习近平也交换意见,并欢迎透过双边和国际合作,应对疫情带来的公共卫生和社会经济影响。 李显龙也与习近平,讨论中新(重庆)战略性互联互通示范项目下的国际陆海贸易新通道,以及一带一路等主要双边项目的持续进展。 与此同时,李显龙也针对中国洪涝灾害表示慰问。

Malaysia identifies five generations of COVID-19 cases connected to mosque cluster

Malaysia’s Health Ministry has detected positive COVID-19 cases within five generations that…

Gov’t insists Operation Coldstore not politically motivated

  The Singapore Government has once again claimed that Singapore’s history is…